Philosophy › Section D · Classical philosophy › Topic D.3

Jewish, Christian, and Islamic philosophy

For roughly fifteen centuries, thinkers in the Jewish, Christian and Islamic worlds asked how Greek philosophy fits with revealed scripture. Their answers carried Plato and Aristotle into the modern age and produced arguments that are still debated.

Faith, reason and a question of definition

Alexander's conquests and later Roman rule spread Greek learning across the Mediterranean and the Near East, where Jewish, then Christian and later Muslim scholars met it. Each tradition faced the same question: how should revelation and reason relate? Even defining these philosophies is debated. The rabbi and scholar Eliezer Berkovits argued that a Jewish philosopher, unlike Descartes, never starts from a blank slate: the events and teachings at the heart of the faith always come first, and the same holds for Christian and Muslim thinkers. All three scriptures teach that God created the world, for instance, while Aristotle held that the world had always existed.

Philo of Alexandria

Philo (about 20 BCE to 50 CE), a Jewish scholar in the Greek-speaking city of Alexandria, made the first systematic attempt to explain Jewish scripture with Greek, mainly Platonic, philosophy. He read many biblical passages allegorically and described the logos, God's reason or word, as the go-between through which a transcendent God shapes the world; Plato's Forms became, in effect, God's thoughts. His writings were preserved mainly by Christians and influenced early Christian theology.

Augustine

Augustine of Hippo (354 to 430 CE), a North African bishop, drew heavily on Neoplatonism. His Confessions tells the story of his slow conversion and probes memory and time: the past exists in us as memory, the future as expectation and the present as attention. As a young man he had followed Manichaeism, which taught a struggle between two equal powers of good and evil. He later replied that everything God made is good, and evil is not a substance but a privation, a lack of good, as blindness is a lack of sight. Against Pelagius he argued that humans cannot be saved without divine grace, while holding that we sin by our own will.

Boethius and Anselm

Boethius (about 477 to about 525), a Roman statesman, translated parts of Aristotle's logic into Latin, long the main logic texts of the early medieval West. Imprisoned under the Ostrogothic king Theodoric before his execution, he wrote The Consolation of Philosophy, in which Lady Philosophy shows him that true happiness lies in the highest good, not in fortune. Anselm (1033 to 1109), Archbishop of Canterbury, described his work as faith seeking understanding. His ontological argument runs: God is that than which nothing greater can be conceived; such a being is greater if it exists in reality as well as in the mind; so God exists. The monk Gaunilo replied that the same reasoning could prove a perfect island exists.

Translation and falsafa

From the eighth to the tenth century, under the Abbasid caliphs, scholars in Baghdad translated Greek philosophy, medicine and science into Arabic, often by way of Syriac. Many translators, such as Hunayn ibn Ishaq, were Christians. Philosophy in this Greek-inspired style was called falsafa. Al-Kindi (about 801 to 873) argued that truth should be welcomed whatever its source, and al-Farabi (about 870 to 950), called the Second Teacher after Aristotle, wrote on logic and on the virtuous city. Theologians of kalam, meanwhile, developed their own rational theology, often in debate with the philosophers.

Ibn Sina

Ibn Sina (980 to 1037), known in Latin as Avicenna, was a Persian polymath whose Canon of Medicine was used in European universities for centuries. He distinguished a thing's essence, what it is, from its existence, the fact that it is. Anything whose existence is merely possible, a contingent thing, needs a cause outside itself. Even an endless chain of such things would remain contingent as a whole, so there must be a Necessary Existent, a being that exists by its own nature; Ibn Sina identified it with God.

Worked example: the floating man

Ibn Sina's best-known thought experiment asks what the self is. 1. Imagine you are created all at once, fully grown, floating in empty air, eyes covered and limbs spread so that nothing touches you, with no sensations at all. 2. Ask whether you would be aware of anything. Ibn Sina answers that you would still be aware that you exist. 3. You would not be aware of your body, since no sense reports it. 4. He concludes that the self you are aware of is not the same thing as the body: the soul is distinct. 5. Evaluate: critics ask whether being unaware of the body shows that the self is not the body, or only that we can think of ourselves without thinking of it.

Worked example: fire and cotton

Al-Ghazali (about 1058 to 1111), a Sunni theologian, attacked the philosophers in The Incoherence of the Philosophers, especially their claim that the world is eternal. One debate concerns causes. 1. Observation: when fire touches cotton, the cotton burns. 2. Al-Ghazali: we observe only that burning happens with the contact, not that fire produces it; God creates the burning directly and could withhold it, which leaves room for miracles. 3. Ibn Rushd (1126 to 1198), a judge in Córdoba, replied in The Incoherence of the Incoherence that if things lack real natures and powers, we can know nothing about them. 4. Assess: al-Ghazali's point about observation anticipates David Hume, who reached a non-religious conclusion. 5. Both men argued by reason; they disagreed about what reason shows.

Maimonides

Moses Maimonides (1138 to 1204) was born in Córdoba, left Spain when the Almohad rulers persecuted religious minorities, and settled in Egypt as a court physician and communal leader. His Guide for the Perplexed (about 1190) was written for readers torn between the Torah and Aristotle. He argued that biblical descriptions of God's body or emotions are figurative, and he developed a negative theology: we can say what God is not, but never what God is in essence. On whether the world is eternal, he held that neither side can be strictly demonstrated, so one may accept creation as scripture teaches.

Thomas Aquinas

Thomas Aquinas (1225 to 1274), an Italian Dominican friar who taught in Paris, worked as Latin translations of Aristotle and his commentators spread through the new universities. He called Aristotle "the Philosopher" and Ibn Rushd "the Commentator", and drew on Ibn Sina and Maimonides. Some truths, such as that God exists, can be reached by reason; others, such as the Trinity, only by revelation, but the two cannot truly conflict. His Summa Theologiae offers five ways to show that God exists: from motion, from efficient causes, from contingency, from degrees of perfection, and from the ordering of nature towards ends. He also developed an influential theory of natural law.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking medieval religious thinkers rejected reason: nearly all argued carefully and disagreed about reason's limits. Second, saying Islamic scholars merely preserved Greek texts; they added original ideas, such as the essence-existence distinction and the floating man. Third, treating al-Ghazali as an enemy of all philosophy, when he used and endorsed logic while rejecting particular conclusions. Fourth, confusing Ibn Sina (Avicenna) with Ibn Rushd (Averroes). Fifth, treating the ontological argument as based on observation; it starts from the concept of God alone.

Key takeaways

Jewish, Christian and Islamic philosophers shared the question of how revelation and reason relate. Philo read scripture through Plato and the logos. Augustine called evil a privation of good; Boethius passed on Aristotle's logic; Anselm framed the ontological argument. Baghdad's translators fed falsafa, including Ibn Sina's Necessary Existent and floating man. Al-Ghazali and Ibn Rushd debated causes and the eternity of the world. Maimonides taught negative theology, and Aquinas joined Aristotle to Christian doctrine in five ways to God and a theory of natural law.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Logos (Philo)

God's reason or word, the go-between linking God and the world

Plato's Forms as God's thoughts.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

How did Augustine answer the Manichaean view of evil?

Question 2 of 5

What is Ibn Sina's floating man thought experiment meant to show?

Question 3 of 5

In the fire and cotton debate, what did al-Ghazali claim?

Question 4 of 5

What is Maimonides's negative theology?

Question 5 of 5

How did Aquinas relate reason and revelation?

← Previous topicNext topic →