Philosophy › Section I · Normative moral theory › Topic I.2
Consequentialism and utilitarianism
Consequentialists hold that what makes an act right is simply how much good it brings about. In its utilitarian form, counting everyone's happiness equally, the idea has reshaped law, economics and charity, and it faces some of the sharpest objections in ethics.
Judging acts by results
Consequentialism is the view that the rightness of an act depends only on its consequences. Elizabeth Anscombe coined the word in 1958, though the idea is far older. Most versions combine three claims. Value: some states of affairs, such as happiness, are good. Maximising: the right act produces the most good available. Impartiality: everyone's good counts equally, the agent's own included but no more. Utilitarianism is the consequentialism that identifies the good with well-being. What well-being is, whether pleasure, satisfied preferences or a list of objective goods, is explored in "Well-being and a meaningful life".
An ancient Chinese version
Consequentialist reasoning is not only modern or Western. In the fifth century BCE, Mozi judged practices by their benefit, li, to the people as a whole, as the topic "Classical Chinese philosophy" explained along with his ideal of inclusive care. Mohists condemned wars of aggression because they waste lives and harvests, and opposed lavish funerals and costly court music because these drain resources from the poor. Their goods were concrete: a populous, orderly, well-fed society. The core idea, judging conduct by its contribution to the general welfare, arose independently in very different settings.
Bentham's principle of utility
Jeremy Bentham (1748 to 1832) opened An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation (printed 1780, published 1789) with the words: "Nature has placed mankind under the governance of two sovereign masters, pain and pleasure." He was a hedonist: pleasure is the only thing good in itself and pain the only thing bad. To compare options, he listed dimensions of a pleasure or pain, now called the felicific calculus: intensity, duration, certainty, nearness, fecundity (its tendency to produce more pleasure), purity (freedom from later pain) and extent (how many people it reaches). On animals he wrote: "the question is not, Can they reason? nor, Can they talk? but, Can they suffer?"
Worked example: a Bentham-style calculation
You have $100: spend it on a concert, or give it to a food bank? Use invented units of pleasure. 1. Concert: intensity 6 for you, lasting 3 hours, so 6 × 3 = 18 units. 2. Donation: 10 people each gain intensity 2 for 4 hours, so 10 × 2 × 4 = 80 units. 3. Certainty: suppose there is a 50% chance the gift is poorly used, so the expected value is 0.5 × 80 = 40 units. 4. Subtract your disappointment at missing the concert, intensity 2 for 3 hours, 6 units: 40 − 6 = 34. 5. Compare: 34 is more than 18, so the donation is right. 6. Reflect: every number was guessed, which is exactly what critics doubt can be done well.
Mill: quality as well as quantity
John Stuart Mill (1806 to 1873), raised by his father James Mill in Bentham's circle, defended the theory in Utilitarianism (1861): acts are right to the degree that they tend to increase happiness and wrong to the degree that they tend to produce unhappiness. Unlike Bentham, Mill held that pleasures differ in quality. Higher pleasures of intellect, feeling and imagination outrank lower bodily ones, and the test is the preference of competent judges who have experienced both; if they differ, the majority decides. Hence: "It is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied; better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied."
Motives, agents and outcomes
For a utilitarian, an act's rightness depends on its consequences, not on the motive behind it. Mill's example: someone who saves a drowning person does right whatever the motive, even if hoping for a reward. Motive still matters to how we judge the agent, because good motives tend to produce good acts in future. Utilitarians also distinguish actual from expected consequences. Many modern versions judge an agent by the best expected outcome given the available evidence, so a careful driver is not blamed for a freak accident no one could foresee.
Act and rule utilitarianism
Act utilitarianism applies the principle directly to each choice: do whatever, here and now, produces the most well-being. Rule utilitarianism applies it to rules: follow the rules whose general acceptance would produce the most well-being, such as rules against lying and punishing the innocent, even in a case where breaking one would do slightly better. Critics press both sides. J. J. C. Smart, an act utilitarian, called sticking to a rule when breaking it is better "rule worship". David Lyons argued in 1965 that a rule utilitarian who keeps adding exceptions to improve outcomes ends up giving the same verdicts as act utilitarianism.
Worked example: the scapegoat
A town is about to riot over a murder, and the sheriff could stop it by framing an innocent drifter. The riot would kill several people. 1. Act utilitarian reasoning: if the framing stays secret, one wrongful punishment costs less than several deaths, so framing seems right. 2. The obvious reply: secrets leak, and discovery would destroy trust in courts, so the expected outcome may be worse. 3. The critic tightens the case: stipulate that discovery is impossible. Many still judge the framing deeply wrong, which suggests rightness is not only about outcomes. 4. Rule utilitarian reasoning: a rule permitting officials to frame the innocent would cause great insecurity if generally accepted, so the act is wrong. 5. The open question: why keep the rule in the secret case?
Justice and the separateness of persons
The scapegoat case illustrates a wider objection. Utilitarianism adds up benefits and harms across people, so a large harm to one person can be outweighed by small gains to many. John Rawls argued in A Theory of Justice (1971) that utilitarianism does not take seriously the distinction between persons. Trading pain for gain makes sense within one life, as when you accept a dentist's drill for later health, but one person's suffering is not compensated by someone else's pleasure. Critics conclude that people have rights, limits on what may be done to them, which a sum of welfare cannot capture.
Demandingness and integrity
Peter Singer argued in "Famine, Affluence, and Morality" (1972) that if you would ruin your clothes to save a child drowning in front of you, distance does not excuse you from preventing deaths from poverty abroad. The argument helped inspire the effective altruism movement. Singer accepts the demanding conclusion; critics see a reductio, since maximising seems to forbid almost any spending on yourself. Bernard Williams pressed a related objection in 1973. His character George, a chemist who opposes chemical weapons, is offered a job in a weapons laboratory; if he refuses, a more zealous chemist will take it. Williams argued that utilitarianism treats George's deepest commitments as just more inputs to a sum, which attacks his integrity.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking consequentialists care only about the agent's own happiness; their standard is impartial. Second, assuming "greatest happiness" means pleasing the majority while ignoring minorities; every person's well-being counts, though critics say the sum can still sacrifice individuals. Third, equating all consequentialism with Bentham's hedonism; the value claim varies. Fourth, confusing the rightness of an act with the worth of the agent's motive. Fifth, believing rule utilitarianism ignores consequences; it judges rules by their results.
Key takeaways
Consequentialism makes rightness depend only on outcomes: promote the most good, counting everyone equally. Mohism is an early form. Bentham's hedonism weighed pleasures along seven dimensions and counted animals because they can suffer. Mill added higher and lower pleasures ranked by competent judges. Act utilitarianism judges each act; rule utilitarianism judges rules, facing charges of rule worship and collapse. Key objections are justice and the separateness of persons (Rawls), demandingness (Singer accepts it) and integrity (Williams).
Flashcards
Flashcard
Rightness depends only on consequences
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which statement best captures the impartiality claim of classical utilitarianism?
Question 2 of 5
Using Bentham-style units, a choice gives 10 people 3 units each for 2 hours, but it has a 50% chance of failing. What is its expected value?
Question 3 of 5
How did Mill decide which of two pleasures is higher in quality?
Question 4 of 5
A rule utilitarian refuses to frame an innocent person even in a case where doing so would produce slightly better results. What objection did J. J. C. Smart raise against this?
Question 5 of 5
What is Rawls's objection that utilitarianism ignores the separateness of persons?
