Philosophy › Section I · Normative moral theory › Topic I.3
Deontology
Deontologists hold that some acts are required or forbidden whatever their results: you may not frame the innocent or break your word just because the sums come out better. Kant's ethics of the good will and Ross's plural duties are the two classic forms, and each faces serious objections.
Duty before outcomes
The word deontology comes from the Greek deon, duty. Deontologists deny that rightness is only a matter of consequences. Their theories include constraints, limits on what you may do to others even for good ends, such as bans on killing the innocent, lying and coercion. Many also include options: permission to pursue your own projects instead of always maximising the good, a point Samuel Scheffler discussed in 1982. Most hold that doing harm is worse than allowing it. Consequences still matter to most deontologists; they just do not settle everything.
Kant and the good will
Immanuel Kant (1724 to 1804) set out his ethics in the Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals (1785). Its first claim is that nothing is good without qualification except a good will. Intelligence, courage and even happiness can be put to bad use; a good will is good in itself, whatever it achieves. What makes a will good is acting from duty, because the act is right. Kant's shopkeeper charges children fair prices only to protect his reputation. He acts in accordance with duty, but not from duty, so his honesty, though correct, lacks moral worth.
Maxims and imperatives
A maxim is the personal principle behind an act, such as "when I need money, I will borrow it and promise to repay." Reason gives commands, which Kant called imperatives. A hypothetical imperative holds only if you want some end: if you want to pass, study. A categorical imperative binds every rational being unconditionally, whatever they happen to want. Kant summed up morality in one supreme principle, the categorical imperative, knowable by reason alone rather than by experience or culture. He gave several formulations; two are most often used.
The formula of universal law
The first formulation: act only on a maxim that you could at the same time will to be a universal law, followed by everyone. Kant described two ways a maxim can fail. Some cannot even be conceived as universal laws: if everyone made false promises whenever convenient, no one would trust promises, so the practice the maxim relies on would vanish. These failures reveal perfect duties, which allow no exceptions. Other maxims can be conceived but not consistently willed: a world where no one ever helps others is possible, but no one who will one day need help can rationally want it. These reveal imperfect duties, such as beneficence, which leave room for choosing when and how.
Worked example: testing a maxim
Maxim: "When I want a day off, I will phone in sick though I am well." 1. Universalise it: everyone who wants a day off falsely reports illness. 2. Ask whether that world is conceivable with the maxim still working: employers would stop believing sick calls and demand proof, so the lie would no longer get anyone a day off. 3. The maxim defeats itself, a contradiction in conception, so the act breaks a perfect duty. 4. Contrast the maxim "I will take an unpaid day off when I am owed leave and say so": universalised, it causes no contradiction. 5. Note what did the work: not bad outcomes, but the maxim's dependence on others not acting as you do.
The formula of humanity
The second formulation: treat humanity, whether in yourself or in anyone else, never merely as a means but always also as an end. Rational beings, for Kant, have dignity, a worth beyond any price, because they can set ends and govern themselves by reason; this idea later shaped thinking about human rights and informed consent. Using people is unavoidable: you use a bus driver to get to work. The wrong is using someone merely as a means, in a way they could not consent to, as deception and coercion do, because both bypass the other person's own reasoning. Kant's further formulations speak of autonomy and of a kingdom of ends, a community of rational beings each treated as a lawmaker.
Worked example: means and mere means
Two drug trials test the same medicine. 1. In trial A, volunteers are told the risks, paid fairly and free to leave. The researchers use them as a means to knowledge, but the volunteers share the end and consent. 2. In trial B, patients are given the drug without being told. Even if the results are equally valuable, the patients cannot consent to an arrangement hidden from them. 3. Verdict: trial A treats people as ends as well as means; trial B uses them merely as means. 4. A strict consequentialist could, in principle, defend B if the benefits were great enough, which is exactly where the two theories part.
Ross and prima facie duties
W. D. Ross (1877 to 1971), in The Right and the Good (1930), rejected both utilitarianism and Kant's exceptionless rules as too simple. He held that we have several prima facie duties, each binding unless outweighed by a stronger one in the situation. His initial list had seven: fidelity, reparation, gratitude, justice, beneficence, self-improvement and non-maleficence, though he argued that justice and self-improvement can be folded into beneficence. When duties clash, your actual duty is the one that weighs most in the circumstances, found by judgement, not by formula. Breaking a promise to help an injured stranger is right, yet you still owe the friend an apology.
Objections to Kant
First, rigidity: in a 1797 reply to Benjamin Constant, Kant held that you may not lie even to a murderer asking where your friend is hiding, a verdict most readers reject. Second, conflicts: if two perfect duties clash, the theory offers little guidance. Third, G. W. F. Hegel charged that the universal law test is an empty formalism, since almost any maxim can pass if described cleverly enough. Fourth, coldness: Michael Stocker argued in 1976 that a friend who visits you in hospital only from duty has missed something central to friendship. Fifth, Kant gave animals and humans without rational capacities no direct moral standing, only indirect duties concerning them.
Objections to deontology itself
Some objections target any theory with constraints. The paradox of deontology: if killing the innocent is so bad, why may you not kill one innocent to prevent five other killings? Deontologists reply that constraints govern what each agent does, not what states of the world to promote, but critics find this agent-centred focus puzzling, even self-indulgent. Ross faces a different charge: without a rule for weighing duties, appeals to judgement may look arbitrary, and intuitions about which duty wins differ between people. A modern alternative, T. M. Scanlon's contractualism (1998), holds that an act is wrong if any principle permitting it could reasonably be rejected by those affected.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking deontologists ignore consequences entirely; most count them, but not as the whole story. Second, reading "never merely as a means" as "never as a means"; using a bus driver is fine. Third, confusing acting in accordance with duty and acting from duty. Fourth, thinking the universal law test asks whether outcomes would be bad if everyone acted so; it asks whether the maxim could work or be willed as a law. Fifth, treating Ross's prima facie duties as absolute rules; any of them can be outweighed.
Key takeaways
Deontology holds that some acts are required or forbidden regardless of results. For Kant, only a good will, acting from duty, is good without qualification. The categorical imperative binds unconditionally: act on maxims you could will as universal laws, yielding perfect and imperfect duties, and never treat humanity merely as a means. Ross offered prima facie duties weighed by judgement. Critics cite rigidity on lying, duty conflicts, empty formalism (Hegel), coldness (Stocker), the paradox of deontology and arbitrary weighing.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Ethics in which some acts are required or forbidden regardless of results
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A shopkeeper gives correct change only because cheating would hurt his reputation. What would Kant say?
Question 2 of 5
Why does the maxim "make a false promise whenever convenient" fail the universal law test?
Question 3 of 5
Which act treats someone merely as a means, according to Kant's humanity formula?
Question 4 of 5
You promised to meet a friend but stop to help an injured stranger. How does Ross analyse this?
Question 5 of 5
What does Michael Stocker's hospital-visit example criticise?
