Philosophy › Section L · Contemporary philosophy and social theory › Topic L.3

Continental philosophy and existentialist themes

Enlightenment theory pictured a detached observer studying the world from outside. Continental philosophers argued that we always understand from inside a history, a body and a life we must choose how to lead. This topic covers hermeneutics, phenomenology and existentialism, with their strengths and their critics.

Challenging the detached observer: hermeneutics

In the 19th and 20th centuries, continental philosophers, mainly in Germany and France (see "An overview of contemporary philosophy"), questioned the Enlightenment picture of knowledge. Hermeneutics, the theory of interpretation, began with reading texts. Friedrich Schleiermacher (1768-1834) made it a general art of understanding, and Wilhelm Dilthey (1833-1911) argued that the human sciences seek understanding of meaning, not only causal explanation. Hans-Georg Gadamer's Truth and Method (1960) held that every reader starts from inherited assumptions, which he called prejudices, shaped by their historical situation. Understanding is a fusion of horizons, the reader's and the text's. This historicity of understanding does not mean any reading goes: interpretations still answer to the text. Paul Ricoeur (1913-2005) added that people understand their own lives and societies by telling stories about them.

Phenomenology: describing experience

Phenomenology studies experience as it is lived, from the first-person point of view. Its founder, Edmund Husserl (1859-1938), urged a return to the things themselves. His method, the epoché or bracketing, sets aside assumptions about what an object really is, or whether it exists, in order to describe exactly how it appears. He stressed intentionality: consciousness is always consciousness of something. Maurice Merleau-Ponty (1908-1961), in Phenomenology of Perception (1945), rejected the split between mind and body discussed in "Descartes, mind-body dualism, and behaviorism", arguing that we perceive through our bodies. Emmanuel Levinas (1906-1995) found ethics in the face-to-face encounter with another person, which calls us to responsibility before any theory does.

Heidegger: being-in-the-world

Martin Heidegger's Being and Time (1927) asked what it means to be at all. He called the human way of existing Dasein, roughly being-there, and described it as being-in-the-world: we are always already involved with tools, tasks and other people, not minds looking out at objects. Most of the time we live by what "one" does, following the anonymous crowd he called das Man, the they. Facing our own death, being-towards-death, can call us back to authentic choices about how to live. Heidegger joined the Nazi Party in 1933 and served as a university rector under the regime, which still shapes debate about his work.

Worked example: when the pen runs dry

Use phenomenology to describe writing a note. 1. Describe the experience before any theory: while you write, you do not notice the pen at all; your attention is on the words. Heidegger called equipment in smooth use ready-to-hand. 2. Introduce a disruption: the ink runs out. 3. Describe the change: suddenly the pen appears as an object with a shape, a weight and an empty cartridge, which Heidegger called present-at-hand. 4. Draw the lesson: detached observation of objects, the Enlightenment's starting point, is a special case that arises when practical involvement breaks down. 5. Bracket the science: physics of ink flow is true, but it does not describe the experience itself.

Existentialist roots: Kierkegaard and Nietzsche

Søren Kierkegaard (1813-1855), often called the father of existentialism, put the single existing individual above abstract systems such as Hegel's. He described aesthetic, ethical and religious stages of life, argued that faith requires a leap beyond reason, and compared anxiety to dizziness before one's own freedom. Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900) announced in The Gay Science (1882) that "God is dead": belief in God had lost its power to ground Western values. He warned that nihilism, the collapse of all values, might follow, and called for a revaluation of values led by the Übermensch, a person who creates values instead of following herd morality.

Sartre: existence precedes essence

Jean-Paul Sartre (1905-1980) set out his views in Being and Nothingness (1943) and a popular lecture of 1945. A paper-knife is designed for a purpose before it is made, so its essence comes first. Humans, Sartre argued, have no designer and no fixed nature: we exist first and define ourselves by what we do, so for us existence precedes essence. We are condemned to be free, and so fully responsible. Bad faith is self-deception that denies this freedom; his example is a café waiter who acts as if being a waiter were all he could be. Authenticity means owning one's choices.

Beauvoir and Fanon: freedom in a situation

Simone de Beauvoir (1908-1986) argued in The Ethics of Ambiguity (1947) that to will my own freedom I must also will the freedom of others. In The Second Sex (1949) she argued that a person is not born a woman but becomes one, because society shapes what femininity means, a founding text of modern feminism. Frantz Fanon's Black Skin, White Masks (1952) used phenomenology to describe how racism makes a Black person experience their own body through others' hostile gaze. Both kept existentialist freedom but showed that it is exercised in situations that others and society shape. The absurd and Albert Camus appear in "Well-being and a meaningful life".

Worked example: "that's just who I am"

Dana has worked in sales for ten years and says, "I'm a salesperson, that's just who I am; I could never retrain." 1. Sartre: this is bad faith, treating a role as a fixed essence; Dana keeps choosing sales each day and should own that choice. 2. Heidegger: Dana may be living by what "one" does, the career others expect; awareness that life is finite could prompt an authentic decision. 3. Beauvoir: ask how Dana's situation, such as debts or caring duties, limits real options, and whether staying respects the freedom of those who depend on Dana. 4. Conclusion: existentialism does not say what Dana should do, only that the choice is Dana's to make and own.

The case for these traditions

Defenders argue that these movements capture what detached theory misses: that understanding is always from somewhere, that experience comes before scientific abstraction, and that a human life is a project to be chosen rather than a fact to be observed. Existentialism shaped novels, theatre, theology and existential psychotherapy; phenomenology informs research on perception and embodiment; Beauvoir and Fanon turned these tools on sexism and racism. Later topics show how these ideas fed critical theory and postmodernism.

The strongest objections

Analytic philosophers charged obscurity: Rudolf Carnap (1932) argued that Heidegger's sentences about nothingness were meaningless pseudo-statements. Many critics, including Marxists, said Sartre's radical freedom ignores how class, race, gender and poverty constrain choice, a point Beauvoir and Fanon themselves pressed. A freedom that creates all values also seems to give little guidance on which choices are good. Finally, if every reader brings prejudices, interpretation risks relativism; E. D. Hirsch, in Validity in Interpretation (1967), defended the author's intended meaning as the standard for a correct reading. Heidegger's Nazi involvement adds a further question about how a philosophy relates to its author's politics.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking hermeneutics says every interpretation is equally good; Gadamer held that readings still answer to the text. Second, confusing bracketing with denial: Husserl suspends judgement about an object's existence, he does not deny it. Third, reading "God is dead" as a claim about a being that once lived; it describes a collapse of belief's cultural authority. Fourth, taking existence precedes essence to mean that people can do anything; Sartre stressed responsibility, and Beauvoir stressed situation. Fifth, assuming all continental philosophers were existentialists: Husserl and Gadamer were not, and Heidegger rejected the label.

Key takeaways

Continental philosophy challenged the detached Enlightenment observer. Hermeneutics, from Schleiermacher and Dilthey to Gadamer (1960), holds that understanding is historical, a fusion of horizons. Husserl's phenomenology brackets assumptions to describe experience; Merleau-Ponty grounded perception in the body and Levinas grounded ethics in the face of the other. Heidegger (1927) described being-in-the-world, the they and being-towards-death. Kierkegaard and Nietzsche set existentialist themes; Sartre held that existence precedes essence and condemned bad faith; Beauvoir and Fanon situated freedom. Critics charge obscurity, exaggerated freedom, thin moral guidance and relativism.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Hermeneutics

The theory and practice of interpretation

Schleiermacher, Dilthey, Gadamer, Ricoeur.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A manager says, "I had no choice but to approve it; I'm just doing my job." What would Sartre call this?

Question 2 of 5

What does Husserl's epoché, or bracketing, ask a phenomenologist to do?

Question 3 of 5

According to Gadamer, how does understanding a text work?

Question 4 of 5

You notice your phone as a heavy glass object only when its screen freezes. Which idea does this illustrate?

Question 5 of 5

Which objection did Beauvoir and Fanon themselves press against radical existentialist freedom?

← Previous topicNext topic →