Philosophy › Section L · Contemporary philosophy and social theory › Topic L.2
The Marxist solution
Enlightenment reformers tried to fix the problems of industrial society one by one. Marx and Engels argued that the problems came from capitalism itself and that history was preparing its overthrow. This topic sets out their theory, its later revisions, its strongest defences and its strongest objections.
From reform to revolution
Karl Marx (1818-1883) and Friedrich Engels (1820-1895) saw factory towns full of poverty and disease and concluded that the cause was the capitalist system itself, so the remedy was to replace it. Their Communist Manifesto (1848) and Marx's Capital (volume 1, 1867) set out the case. Marx's ideas of base and superstructure, class and alienation appear in the Sociology topic "Theoretical perspectives on society", and socialism as a political ideal in "Egalitarianism, socialism, and anarchism". This topic looks at the philosophy of history behind them and at how the theory has fared.
Hegel's dialectic
Marx took his method from G. W. F. Hegel (1770-1831). For Hegel, reality is a developing whole driven by contradiction. Any limited idea or form of life contains tensions that undermine it, and the conflict is resolved in a richer form that both cancels and preserves what came before; his word for this is Aufhebung, often translated sublation. Hegel saw history as Spirit, or Geist, coming to know itself, and as the growth of human freedom. The popular formula thesis, antithesis, synthesis is a later simplification: Hegel himself rarely used those terms, and scholars warn that it distorts his method.
Marx turns Hegel upside down
Marx kept the dialectic but rejected Hegel's idealism, the view that ideas or Spirit drive history. In the 1873 afterword to Capital he wrote of Hegel's dialectic: "With him it is standing on its head. It must be turned right side up again, if you would discover the rational kernel within the mystical shell." For Marx the contradictions that move history are material ones, in how people produce food, goods and shelter and who controls that production. Engels called this the materialist conception of history, later known as historical materialism; Georgi Plekhanov popularised dialectical materialism as a name for the wider philosophy.
Class struggle as the engine of history
The Manifesto opens its first chapter: "The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles." Each economic system, Marx argued, sets a ruling class against an exploited class: masters and slaves in the ancient world, lords and serfs under feudalism, the bourgeoisie, who own the means of production, and the proletariat, who sell their labour, under capitalism. The bourgeoisie was once revolutionary, sweeping away feudalism and building world markets. But capitalism gathers workers into factories and cities where they can organise. In the Manifesto's words, "What the bourgeoisie therefore produces, above all, are its own grave-diggers."
Surplus value and exploitation
Capital explains where profit comes from. Marx held that labour creates new value. A worker sells the employer not labour itself but labour power, the capacity to work for a day, and is paid roughly what it costs to keep a worker alive and working. During the day, however, the worker creates more value than that wage. The difference is surplus value, which the owner keeps as profit. Marx called this exploitation in a technical sense: it can happen even when wages are fair by market standards. The rate of surplus value is surplus value divided by wages.
Worked example: one working day
Follow Marx's reasoning with simple figures. 1. A worker is paid $120 for an 8-hour day, roughly the cost of the goods needed to keep a worker going. 2. In those 8 hours the worker's labour adds $240 of new value to the materials. 3. So after 4 hours the worker has produced value equal to the wage; Marx called this necessary labour. 4. The other 4 hours are surplus labour, and the $120 they produce is surplus value. 5. Rate of surplus value: $120 divided by $120, or 100%. 6. Marx's prediction: owners will push this rate up by lengthening days or raising output per hour, sharpening class conflict.
Predicted and actual revolutions
Marx generally expected rising conflict to make workers conscious of their shared interests, form unions and parties, and overthrow capitalism first in the most industrial countries, such as Britain. A transitional workers' state, which he called the dictatorship of the proletariat, would lead to a classless society. Instead the first lasting communist revolution came in mainly agrarian Russia in 1917. Vladimir Lenin's Imperialism (written in 1916, published in 1917) explained why: monopolies in rich countries had exported their exploitation to colonies, buying off workers at home. Mao Zedong (1893-1976) went further, making peasants and nations oppressed by imperialism the revolutionary force behind China's revolution of 1949.
The strongest case for Marxism
Defenders argue that Marx's analysis outlived his forecasts. He described capitalism's drive to expand into a global market, its booms and crises, and the way it can turn work into a mere means of survival, themes many non-Marxist scholars take seriously. His insistence that ideas be studied alongside material interests reshaped history and the social sciences. Many Marxists add that Soviet-style states betrayed Marx's democratic hopes: Rosa Luxemburg criticised the Bolsheviks' suppression of democracy as early as 1918. Analytical Marxists, such as G. A. Cohen in Karl Marx's Theory of History: A Defence (1978), restated the theory in rigorous form.
The strongest objections
Critics reply on several fronts. The predictions failed: revolutions came in agrarian countries, while workers' living standards in industrial ones rose. Karl Popper, in The Open Society and Its Enemies (1945) and later essays, argued that Marxists rescued the theory by reinterpreting each failure, which made it unfalsifiable. Economists from Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk (1896) onwards rejected the labour theory of value, holding that prices reflect what buyers want as well as labour spent. Ludwig von Mises (1920) and Friedrich Hayek argued that central planning cannot calculate prices well. And communist states produced repression and famines, such as China's Great Leap Forward, in which historians estimate that tens of millions died.
Worked example: weighing a failed prediction
Marx expected revolution in industrial Britain; it came in Russia. What follows? 1. The fact is not disputed: the prediction failed. 2. A defender's move: Lenin's theory of imperialism adds a new factor explaining the failure while keeping the core theory. 3. Popper's test: is the new factor independently checkable, or was it added only to save the theory? A theory that can absorb any outcome tells us nothing. 4. A reply: all sciences revise auxiliary assumptions after failed predictions, and Lenin's claim made its own predictions about colonial revolts. 5. Conclusion: the failure counts against the original forecast; whether it refutes Marxism as a whole depends on how the revision is judged.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, crediting Hegel with the slogan thesis, antithesis, synthesis as if it were his method. Second, confusing labour with labour power: workers are paid for their capacity to work, and surplus value is the gap between what that costs and what it produces. Third, treating exploitation in Marx's sense as the claim that wages break the law or market rules. Fourth, assuming the Soviet Union or Maoist China simply was Marx's plan; Marxists and their critics debate how far it followed from his ideas. Fifth, thinking one failed prediction settles the debate without weighing the revisions.
Key takeaways
Marx and Engels sought to replace capitalism rather than reform it. Marx turned Hegel's dialectic of Spirit into a dialectic of material production, with class struggle as history's engine. Surplus value is the value workers create beyond the cost of their labour power, and the rate of surplus value is surplus value divided by wages. Revolutions came not in Britain but in Russia and China, explained by Lenin's theory of imperialism and Mao's peasant revolution. Defenders stress the lasting analysis of capitalism; critics stress failed predictions, unfalsifiability, the labour theory of value, the calculation problem and the record of communist states.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Marx and Engels's 1848 call for workers' revolution
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
How did Marx's version of the dialectic differ from Hegel's?
Question 2 of 5
A worker's 10-hour day produces value equal to the wage in the first 4 hours. In Marx's terms, what is the rate of surplus value?
Question 3 of 5
How did Lenin explain why revolution came in Russia rather than in Britain?
Question 4 of 5
What was Karl Popper's main objection to Marxism?
Question 5 of 5
What was distinctive in Mao Zedong's reframing of Marxism?
