Philosophy › Section I · Normative moral theory › Topic I.5

Daoism as an ethical theory

Daoism looks like an odd candidate for an ethical theory, since it attacks moral rules, praise of virtue and striving itself. Yet the Daodejing and the Zhuangzi offer a sustained account of how to live and govern well, and that account can be stated, applied and criticised like any other.

An ethics that distrusts morality

The topic "Classical Chinese philosophy" introduced the two Daoist classics, the dao that words cannot capture, and wu wei, non-forcing action. Here the question is whether Daoism amounts to an ethical theory. Tradition, following the historian Sima Qian (about 145 to 86 BCE), placed Laozi in the sixth century BCE, but many scholars think the Daodejing was compiled over generations; the oldest surviving version, on bamboo slips from a tomb at Guodian sealed around 300 BCE, is partial. Scholars disagree about the ethics too. Some, such as Chad Hansen, read Daoism as a critique of every fixed guide to conduct; others read the Daodejing as a kind of virtue ethics.

The critique of conventional virtue

The Daodejing turns the Confucian picture upside down. In James Legge's 1891 translation of chapter 18: "When the Great Tao (Way or Method) ceased to be observed, benevolence and righteousness came into vogue." Named virtues are symptoms of loss, not cures: we preach filial piety when families have broken down. Chapter 2 adds that naming a quality creates its opposite: once everyone knows what counts as beautiful, ugliness appears too. Moral labels set up contrasts, rankings and competition, and people then perform virtue for reward or reputation, deepening the disorder that preaching meant to cure.

De, ziran and the uncarved block

Daoism offers its own ideals. De, often translated virtue or potency, is the power a person has when living in accord with the dao, a quiet influence that does not seek credit. Ziran, literally "so of itself", means naturalness or spontaneity: things following their own course without outside force. The image of pu, the uncarved block of wood, stands for simplicity before artificial shaping. The ethical ideal that follows is a life of few desires, little contention and humility, in which a person does not grasp at status, wealth or fame. These are traits of character, which is why some scholars compare Daoism with virtue ethics.

Wu wei and its paradox

Chapter 37, in Legge's version: "The Tao in its regular course does nothing (for the sake of doing it), and so there is nothing which it does not do." Wu wei is not idleness. It is action free of self-serving striving, responsive to the situation, like a skilled craftsman's movements. But how do you learn it? Edward Slingerland, in Effortless Action (2003) and Trying Not to Try (2014), calls this the paradox of wu wei: if you try to be spontaneous, you are not spontaneous, yet if you do not try, how will you change? Slingerland argues that Confucius, Mencius, Laozi and Zhuangzi all wrestle with versions of the same problem.

The ethics of water

Water is the Daodejing's moral model. Chapter 8 begins, in Legge's words, "The highest excellence is like (that of) water", which benefits all things and takes the low place others dislike, without contending. Chapter 78 adds that nothing is softer or weaker than water, yet nothing surpasses it for wearing down what is hard and strong. The ethical lessons are humility, non-contention and yielding: someone who does not compete for the top position provokes no rivals, and softness can outlast force. The ideal is not weakness but strength that works through patience rather than domination.

Governing by not governing

Much of the Daodejing addresses rulers. Its advice is minimal intervention: heavy laws, taxes and wars provoke the disorder they aim to prevent. Chapter 3 says that if rulers stop prizing rare goods, people will not become thieves, and chapter 80 imagines a small state with few people, content with simple lives. The best ruler is barely noticed. Chapter 65 is more troubling: in Legge's translation, the ancients who practised the dao sought "not to enlighten the people, but rather to make them simple and ignorant." Readers divide over whether this means unpretentious or kept in the dark.

Zhuangzi: perspective and uselessness

The Zhuangzi, whose first seven Inner Chapters are usually treated as closest to Zhuangzi himself, adds playful scepticism. Judgements of right and wrong, it suggests, depend on where you stand, so we should hold our own with a light grip. In one story a carpenter dismisses a huge tree as useless timber; the tree later appears in his dream and points out that its uselessness is what has let it live out its years. Conventional usefulness serves others' purposes and gets you cut down. The ethical lesson is to loosen attachment to status and fixed values, to tolerate other perspectives and to accept change, including death.

Worked example: the thief problem

A ruler asks what to do about rising theft. 1. A Confucian answer: set a moral example, since the people follow the ruler as grass bends to the wind, and teach ritual. 2. A Mohist answer: apply clear standards that benefit everyone, reward the worthy and promote inclusive care so that no one gains by harming others. 3. A Daoist answer, from chapter 3: stop displaying and prizing luxury goods, reduce desires and keep government light, so that the motive for theft fades. 4. Compare: the first two add something, either virtue or standards; the Daoist removes the cause. 5. Evaluate: the Daoist answer is bold but says little about victims of theft today.

Worked example: the pushy parent

A parent drives a child through hours of daily practice to become a concert pianist, though the child loves building things. 1. Identify the forcing: the parent imposes an outside shape on the child, like carving the uncarved block. 2. Apply ziran: a Daoist asks what the child's own course is and how to support it. 3. Apply wu wei: guidance should be responsive and light, not driven by the parent's ambition or pride. 4. Apply the useless tree: the parent's idea of a "useful" talent may serve status rather than the child. 5. Limits: Daoism does not say the child should never practise anything hard; skill, as in the Cook Ding story, comes from long training.

Objections

First, passivity: critics charge that Daoism counsels withdrawal when injustice demands resistance; defenders reply that wu wei is skilled responsiveness, not inaction. Second, the appeal to the natural is vague, and nature includes predators and disease, so it is unclear how facts about nature yield norms; the topic "The fact-value distinction" examines that gap. Third, the Confucian Xunzi complained that Zhuangzi valued heaven, or nature, and failed to recognise the value of the human. Fourth, perspectivism may leave no ground for condemning cruelty. Fifth, the political advice of chapter 65 can read as paternalism that keeps the governed ignorant.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, equating wu wei with doing nothing. Second, thinking Daoists reject all value; they reject artificial, imposed values and prize simplicity, humility and naturalness. Third, assuming Laozi is a securely dated author of the sixth century BCE; the text's origins are disputed. Fourth, reading the critique of benevolence as a call to cruelty; the claim is that preached virtue is a symptom of lost harmony. Fifth, treating Daoist ethics as only personal; much of the Daodejing is advice to rulers.

Key takeaways

Daoist ethics criticises conventional morality: named virtues appear when the dao is lost, and labels breed competition. Its ideals are de, ziran and pu: quiet power, naturalness and simplicity, with few desires and little contention. Wu wei is unforced action, which raises the paradox of trying not to try. Water models humility and yielding strength. Rulers should govern lightly. Zhuangzi adds perspectivism and the value of uselessness. Critics cite passivity, the vagueness of the natural, Xunzi's complaint, relativism and paternalism.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Guodian slips

The oldest surviving Daodejing material, from a tomb sealed around 300 BCE

A partial text.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why does the Daodejing say benevolence and righteousness "came into vogue" when the great dao ceased to be observed?

Question 2 of 5

What is the paradox of wu wei, as Edward Slingerland describes it?

Question 3 of 5

A ruler faces rising theft. Which answer is the Daoist one?

Question 4 of 5

What is the lesson of Zhuangzi's useless tree?

Question 5 of 5

Which objection holds that facts about nature do not by themselves tell us what we ought to do?

← Previous topicNext topic →