Philosophy › Section I · Normative moral theory › Topic I.4

Virtue ethics

Consequentialists and deontologists ask which acts are right. Virtue ethicists ask first what kind of person to be, holding that good action flows from good character shaped by habit, wisdom and community. The approach is ancient, both Greek and Chinese, and it has made a strong modern comeback.

Character first

Virtue ethics makes character, not rules or outcomes, the centre of morality. A virtue is a settled trait of character, such as honesty, courage or justice, that disposes a person to feel, choose and act well. In "Modern Moral Philosophy" (1958), Elizabeth Anscombe argued that ethics built on duty and law had lost its foundations and should return to the virtues. Alasdair MacIntyre's After Virtue (1981), Philippa Foot and Rosalind Hursthouse continued the revival. The topic "Classical Greek philosophy" introduced Aristotle's idea of eudaimonia, flourishing; here we look at how his theory works in detail and how it compares with Confucian thought.

The function argument

In the Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle asks what the good of a human being is. His answer turns on function, ergon. A flute player is good when she plays the flute well, and a sculptor when he sculpts well; in general, a thing is good when it performs its characteristic activity excellently. Plants share nutrition and growth with us, and animals share perception, but reason is distinctive of humans. So the human good is activity of the soul in accordance with reason, done excellently, over a complete life, with enough external goods such as friends and health. The Greek word for excellence, arete, is the word we translate as virtue.

The doctrine of the mean

Aristotle divided virtues into intellectual virtues, learned by teaching, and virtues of character. A virtue of character is a disposition to feel and act at a mean between excess and deficiency. Courage lies between rashness and cowardice, generosity between wastefulness and meanness. The mean is relative to us, not a midpoint: Aristotle noted that a ration suited to a beginner would be too little for the champion wrestler Milo. Virtue means feeling and acting at the right times, about the right things, towards the right people, for the right end and in the right way. Some acts, such as murder, have no mean; they are simply wrong.

Worked example: finding the mean

A colleague takes credit, in a meeting, for your report. How angry should you be? 1. Deficiency: saying nothing and feeling nothing, which Aristotle thought servile, since it fails to defend what is due. 2. Excess: shouting across the room and holding a grudge for months. 3. The mean depends on the facts: was it deliberate, is this a pattern, who is present? 4. A plausible mean: firm, calm correction, perhaps privately first, with anger proportioned to the wrong. 5. Notice the method: the answer is not halfway between silence and rage but what a person of practical wisdom would judge fitting here.

Habit and practical wisdom

Virtues of character are not innate; we acquire them by habituation. Aristotle's analogy: people become builders by building and lyre players by playing the lyre, and likewise just by doing just acts and brave by doing brave acts. Upbringing therefore matters enormously. But habit alone is not enough. Phronesis, practical wisdom, is the intellectual virtue of seeing what a situation requires, and Aristotle held that full virtue and practical wisdom require each other. He also distinguished the virtuous person, who wants to act well and finds it pleasant, from the merely self-controlled person, who acts well while struggling against contrary desires.

Friendship

Aristotle gave two of the ten books of the Nicomachean Ethics to friendship, philia. He identified three kinds. Friendships of utility last while each is useful to the other, like many business relationships. Friendships of pleasure last while the company is enjoyable. Friendships of character, between good people who wish each other well for the other's own sake, are complete and lasting, and they are rare. Such a friend is "another self": we share in their good actions and are improved by their company. Because humans are social by nature, Aristotle held that no one would choose to live without friends, even with every other good.

Confucian virtue ethics

Many scholars read Confucian ethics as a virtue ethics too. The topic "Classical Chinese philosophy" introduced ren, li and the junzi, the exemplary person. Two features stand out by comparison with Aristotle. First, virtue is role-relative: what you owe depends on whether you act as child, parent, friend, ruler or subject, and care begins in the family. Second, ritual is the main tool of habituation, training feeling as well as conduct. Confucius stressed moral example in rulers: in Analects 12.19 he compares the ruler's virtue to wind and the people's to grass, which bends when the wind blows. Both traditions see character as formed in community.

Worked example: honest feedback

A friend has spent two years on a song demo and asks what you think. You find it weak. 1. A strict rule-based approach asks whether any false praise would be a lie. 2. A consequentialist weighs her hurt feelings now against better songs later. 3. A virtue ethicist asks what honesty, kindness and friendship require together. 4. Honesty rules out false praise; kindness rules out a cold list of faults; friendship asks what will actually help her grow. 5. A fitting answer: sincere praise for what works, one or two specific suggestions, offered when she can take them in. 6. Note that the guidance comes from virtue terms, not a formula.

Objections: guidance and whose virtues

Critics say "do what a virtuous person would do" gives no guidance when you do not know what that person would do, and seems circular if virtues are defined by right acts. Hursthouse replied in On Virtue Ethics (1999) that right action is what a virtuous agent would characteristically do in the circumstances, and that every virtue and vice term supplies a rule: do what is honest, do not do what is cruel. A second worry is relativity: Aristotle's list includes greatness of soul, a proud aristocratic ideal, and he denied full virtue to women and slaves. A third charge is self-centredness: if virtue serves my flourishing, is my concern for others secondary?

The situationist challenge

Some philosophers, including Gilbert Harman (1999) and John Doris in Lack of Character (2002), argued from social psychology that stable character traits barely exist. In a 1973 study by John Darley and Daniel Batson, seminary students in a hurry were far less likely to help a slumped stranger, even when on their way to speak about the Good Samaritan. Small situational factors seemed to matter more than character. Defenders reply that virtue was always meant to be rare, so ordinary people's failures are no surprise; that such studies show traits are narrower than assumed, not absent; and that some of the experiments have proved hard to replicate.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, reading the mean as a mathematical midpoint or as "always be moderate"; sometimes great anger is fitting. Second, thinking virtues are innate; Aristotle held they come from habit. Third, confusing the self-controlled person, who struggles, with the virtuous person, who wants to act well. Fourth, assuming virtue ethics gives no guidance at all; virtue terms guide, if not mechanically. Fifth, assuming Aristotle and Confucius held the same view; Confucian virtue is more role-relative and family-centred.

Key takeaways

Virtue ethics centres on character, revived after Anscombe (1958) by MacIntyre, Foot and Hursthouse. Aristotle's function argument makes the human good activity in accordance with reason, done excellently. Virtues of character are means relative to us, acquired by habit and completed by practical wisdom. Friendships of character are the best kind. Confucian ethics adds role-relative virtue and ritual. Right action is what a virtuous agent would characteristically do. Objections cite weak guidance, contested virtue lists, self-centredness and the situationist challenge.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Virtue

A settled trait disposing a person to feel, choose and act well

Honesty, courage, justice.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did Aristotle mention the wrestler Milo?

Question 2 of 5

Two people both return a lost purse. One wants to and is glad; the other longs to keep it but forces herself. How would Aristotle describe them?

Question 3 of 5

According to Aristotle, how do we acquire virtues of character?

Question 4 of 5

What did the 1973 Darley and Batson study seem to show, according to situationist critics?

Question 5 of 5

How did Rosalind Hursthouse answer the objection that virtue ethics gives no guidance?

← Previous topicNext topic →