Philosophy › Section I · Normative moral theory › Topic I.6
Feminist theories of ethics
Feminist ethicists ask how centuries of moral philosophy written almost entirely by men shaped what counted as reasoning, virtue and value. Their answers range from criticism of the classic theories to new ones, above all the ethics of care, and they have drawn strong objections from inside feminism as well as outside it.
A family of approaches
Feminist ethics is not one theory. Its shared aims are to understand and end the subordination of women and others, and to ask how gender has shaped moral thought. Some feminists work within the existing theories, developing feminist Kantian, consequentialist or virtue ethics. Others argue that the traditional theories are built on a narrow picture of moral life and propose alternatives, most famously the ethics of care. All share a method: look at whose experience a theory takes as standard, whose work it ignores, and whom its conclusions serve. That question applies to every theory in this section.
The historical critique
Many canonical philosophers described women as lesser moral agents. Aristotle, in the Politics, wrote that a woman has the deliberative part of the soul but that it lacks authority. Jean-Jacques Rousseau's Emile (1762) proposed educating girls to please and serve men; Mary Wollstonecraft replied in A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792) that women seem less rational only because they are denied education. Kant's 1764 essay on the beautiful and the sublime linked women's minds to feeling rather than deep reasoning. Feminists add a structural point: theories modelled on agreements between independent adults overlook the dependence of children, the sick and the old, and the mostly female, unpaid work of caring for them.
Beauvoir and the construction of gender
Simone de Beauvoir's The Second Sex (1949) argued that man has been treated as the default human and woman defined as the Other, in relation to him. Her famous claim is that one becomes a woman rather than being born one: femininity is a set of expectations a society imposes, not a fixed nature. Later feminists distinguished sex, a biological category, from gender, the social roles built on it. For ethics, the lesson is that traits labelled "feminine", such as emotionality, may be products of social roles, not evidence of lesser reason.
Gilligan's different voice
The psychologist Lawrence Kohlberg ranked moral development in stages, with reasoning from abstract, universal principles of justice at the top. On his scale, girls often scored lower than boys. Carol Gilligan, his colleague, argued in In a Different Voice (1982) that the scale was biased. Many of the women she interviewed reasoned in terms of relationships, responsibility and avoiding harm, which she called the perspective of care, as opposed to the perspective of justice, rights and rules. Gilligan stressed that the care voice is identified by its theme, not by gender: men can speak it, and women can reason from justice.
Worked example: the Heinz dilemma
Kohlberg's best-known case: Heinz's wife is dying, and a druggist will sell the drug that could save her only at a price Heinz cannot pay. Should he steal it? Gilligan described two eleven-year-olds. 1. Jake says yes: a life is worth more than money, so stealing is justified, an answer reached like solving a sum with people in it. 2. Amy says Heinz should not steal but his wife should not die either; he should talk to the druggist or borrow the money, and if he went to prison, who would look after his wife? 3. Kohlberg's scoring placed Jake higher. 4. Gilligan's reading: Amy sees a web of relationships to keep intact, not a weaker grasp of principle.
Noddings and the caring relation
Nel Noddings, in Caring (1984), built an ethics on the relation between the one-caring and the cared-for. Caring begins with engrossment, receiving the other person as they actually are, and motivational displacement, in which the carer's energy flows towards the other's goals. Care is complete only when the cared-for responds, even with a smile. Noddings defended partiality: our first obligations are to those we can actually care for, not to humanity in the abstract. In her early work she held that obligations to distant strangers are weaker when care cannot be completed; in Starting at Home (2002) she gave caring about distant others a larger role.
Care beyond the home
Later theorists took care into politics. Joan Tronto, in Moral Boundaries (1993), described phases of care, caring about, taking care of, care-giving and care-receiving, and coined "privileged irresponsibility" for the way the advantaged pay others to do caring work and then ignore it. Eva Feder Kittay, in Love's Labor (1999), argued that everyone is dependent at some point, as infants, in illness or in old age, so a just society must support those who care for dependants. Virginia Held, in The Ethics of Care (2006), argued that care is a value and practice that should shape public policy, not only private life.
Worked example: caring for an ageing parent
Maria's father has dementia, and she must decide whether to move him into her home or a care facility. 1. An impartial approach might ask which option produces the most well-being overall, or which rule everyone could accept. 2. A care approach starts with engrossment: what does her father actually need and want, as far as he can say? 3. It counts the relationship itself as morally significant, not one more input. 4. Following Kittay, it asks who cares for Maria, since an exhausted carer cannot care well. 5. The outcome might be either option; what differs is that the relationship and dependency shape the reasoning from the start.
Intersectionality
The Combahee River Collective, a group of Black feminists in Boston, argued in 1977 that race, sex and class oppressions interlock. The legal scholar Kimberlé Crenshaw named the idea intersectionality in 1989. She discussed a 1976 case in which Black women sued General Motors: the court rejected the claim, since the company hired Black people, mostly men, and women, mostly white, so the women's particular exclusion fell through the gaps. Intersectional feminists argue that a theory built around "typical" women may serve only the most privileged. Naomi Zack (2005) worried that dividing women into ever smaller groups weakens shared advocacy; defenders reply that recognising difference makes solidarity honest.
Objections
First, essentialism: Elizabeth Spelman's Inessential Woman (1988) criticised feminist theory for treating women as one group with one nature, and Tronto found the same fault in early care ethics, which can reinforce stereotypes. Second, the "slave morality" worry, pressed by Claudia Card and Bill Puka around 1990: care ethics may praise the self-sacrifice that subordination imposed on women. Third, the empirical base: later reviews, such as Lawrence Walker's in 1984, found few sex differences in moral reasoning, and Gilligan's samples were small. Fourth, parochialism: focusing on close relationships may excuse neglect of distant strangers and global injustice. Fifth, Michael Slote and others argue that care ethics is really a form of virtue ethics, not a rival theory.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, equating feminist ethics with care ethics; there are feminist Kantians, consequentialists and virtue ethicists. Second, thinking Gilligan claimed that only women use the care perspective. Third, treating care as merely a feeling; Noddings and Tronto describe it as a practice and relation. Fourth, assuming care ethics ignores justice; Kittay and Held build care into theories of justice. Fifth, reading intersectionality as a simple tally of disadvantages, rather than an account of how oppressions combine into distinct experiences.
Key takeaways
Feminist ethics asks how gender shaped moral theory and seeks to end subordination. Aristotle, Rousseau and Kant cast women as lesser reasoners; Wollstonecraft blamed lack of education, and Beauvoir argued that femininity is socially made. Gilligan's 1982 critique of Kohlberg contrasted the care and justice perspectives. Noddings grounded ethics in the caring relation; Tronto, Kittay and Held extended care to politics and justice. Crenshaw named intersectionality. Objections cite essentialism, praise of self-sacrifice, a weak empirical base, parochialism and possible reduction to virtue ethics.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Ethics that asks how gender shaped moral thought and seeks to end subordination
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What was Carol Gilligan's main criticism of Lawrence Kohlberg's stages of moral development?
Question 2 of 5
In the Heinz dilemma, Amy suggests Heinz talk to the druggist and worries about who would care for his wife if he went to prison. How did Gilligan read her answer?
Question 3 of 5
In Noddings's ethics of care, what is engrossment?
Question 4 of 5
What point did Kimberlé Crenshaw draw from the 1976 case of Black women suing General Motors?
Question 5 of 5
Claudia Card and Bill Puka raised which objection to care ethics?
