Philosophy › Section F · Metaphysics › Topic F.6
Cosmology and the existence of God
Can reason alone show whether God exists? Philosophers in many traditions have built arguments from the existence and order of the world, from morality and from the very idea of God, and others have answered with powerful objections, above all the problem of evil. This topic sets out both sides; it does not decide between them.
The question and its terms
Cosmology, in the philosophical sense, asks how reality as a whole is ordered and why it exists at all. Theism is the belief that God exists; atheism the belief that God does not; agnosticism holds that we cannot know, or should suspend judgement. Most Western arguments concern the God of classical theism: all-powerful, all-knowing, wholly good and the creator of everything else. Arguments for God are of two kinds. A posteriori arguments start from experience, such as the existence or design of the world; a priori arguments start from reason and concepts alone. Others set proof aside: Blaise Pascal's wager says belief is the prudent bet, and William James defended a right to believe where evidence is indecisive; critics reply that belief cannot simply be chosen.
Cosmological arguments
Cosmological arguments reason from the existence of the world to a cause beyond it. Thomas Aquinas, in the first three of his Five Ways, argued that things are moved and caused by other things, and that such chains cannot go back forever, so there must be a first, uncaused cause. His third way adds that natural things are contingent, able not to exist, so something must exist necessarily. Critics, including David Hume, ask why an infinite chain of causes is impossible, and why a first cause must be the God of theism rather than something impersonal.
Worked example: the kalam argument
The kalam argument, developed by medieval Islamic theologians such as al-Ghazali and revived by William Lane Craig, is short. 1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause. 2. The universe began to exist. 3. So the universe has a cause. Evaluate: the argument is valid, so the debate is over the premises. For premise 2, supporters cite the Big Bang and arguments that an actually infinite past is impossible. Critics reply that physics has not established an absolute beginning, and that causes inside the universe may not tell us about the universe as a whole. Even if it succeeds, a further step must show the cause is personal and divine.
Design arguments
Teleological, or design, arguments start from order and apparent purpose. Aquinas's fifth way argued that things without intelligence act towards ends, as an arrow flies towards a target only because an archer aims it. William Paley (1802) compared a watch found on a heath, whose parts work together to tell time, with living things, whose eyes are more intricate still. Hume's Dialogues (1779) had already argued that the analogy is weak and could as easily point to many limited designers. Darwin's theory of natural selection (1859) explained biological adaptation without design. Modern fine-tuning arguments point instead to physical constants that seem set within narrow life-permitting ranges; critics appeal to a multiverse or observer selection.
The moral argument
The moral argument reasons from ethics. 1. Objective moral values exist: some things are wrong whatever anyone believes. 2. Objective values need a source that grounds their authority. 3. The best explanation of that source is God. 4. So God exists. Critics deny that values are objective, or ground them without God, in reason or human nature. Many raise the Euthyphro dilemma, adapted from Plato's dialogue about piety: is an act good because God commands it, which makes goodness arbitrary, or does God command it because it is good, which makes goodness independent of God? Theists reply that goodness flows from God's unchanging nature.
Anselm's ontological argument
Anselm of Canterbury (1033 to 1109), in his Proslogion, gave an a priori argument. God is defined as that than which nothing greater can be conceived. Even someone who denies God understands this idea, so God exists at least in the understanding. But what exists in reality as well as in the mind is greater than what exists only in the mind. So if God existed only in the mind, we could conceive something greater: the same being existing in reality. That contradicts the definition, so God exists in reality.
Worked example: testing Anselm
Apply the two classic objections. 1. Gaunilo of Marmoutiers, a monk of Anselm's day, offered a parody: define an island than which no greater island can be conceived; by the same steps it must exist, which is absurd, so the form of reasoning is faulty. 2. A defender's reply: an island has no maximum of greatness, since one could always add more palm trees, while perfections such as knowledge and power do have a maximum. 3. Immanuel Kant (1781) objected that existence is not a real predicate: saying a thing exists adds nothing to the concept of it, so it cannot make a concept greater. 4. Assessment: modern modal versions, such as Alvin Plantinga's, avoid some objections; the debate continues.
Arguments in Indian philosophy
Indian schools debated a creator too. Nyāya philosophers, notably Udayana around the tenth or eleventh century CE, argued that the world is an effect, like a pot, and every effect needs an intelligent maker. They added that karma, the law linking actions to fitting results across lives, needs a conscious overseer, God, to match results to deeds. The Mīmāṃsā school rejected a creator: it held that the Vedas are eternal and authorless and that karma operates by itself. Buddhist and Jain philosophers also rejected a creator, asking, for example, why an unchanging God would create at one time rather than another.
The problem of evil
The best-known argument against God starts from suffering. The logical problem of evil, an ancient dilemma that Lactantius and later Hume attributed to Epicurus, restated by J. L. Mackie (1955), claims inconsistency: a God who is all-powerful, all-knowing and wholly good would prevent evil, yet evil exists. The evidential problem makes a weaker but harder claim. William Rowe (1979) argued that intense suffering which seems to serve no greater good, such as a fawn dying slowly in a forest fire, makes it probable, though not certain, that no such God exists.
Responses to the problem of evil
Augustine argued that evil is not a thing God created but a privation, a lack of the good that should be present. Alvin Plantinga's free will defence (1974) answers the logical problem: a world of free creatures may be better than one without them, and even God cannot guarantee that free creatures never choose wrongly, so God and evil are consistent. John Hick's soul-making theodicy says suffering allows virtues such as courage and compassion to grow. Sceptical theists say we should not expect to see God's reasons. Natural evils, such as disease, remain the hardest case. Yoruba thought frames evil differently, tracing it to spiritual forces, the Ajogun, rather than to the supreme God.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, cosmological arguments do not by themselves show that the first cause is good or personal. Second, Paley's argument is about intricate function, not merely order. Third, Kant's objection targets existence as a property, not the definition of God. Fourth, the logical problem claims contradiction, while the evidential problem claims only improbability; a reply to one is not a reply to the other. Fifth, the free will defence aims to show consistency, not to explain every particular evil.
Key takeaways
A posteriori arguments start from experience; a priori arguments from concepts. Cosmological arguments, from Aquinas to the kalam, infer a first or necessary cause. Design arguments from Aquinas and Paley meet Hume's and Darwin's replies, and fine-tuning meets multiverse responses. The moral argument faces the Euthyphro dilemma. Anselm's ontological argument faces Gaunilo and Kant. Nyāya argued for God from effects and karma; Mīmāṃsā denied a creator. The logical and evidential problems of evil meet privation, free will, soul-making and sceptical responses.
Flashcards
Flashcard
God exists / God does not exist / we cannot know or should suspend judgement
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which of these is an a priori argument for God's existence?
Question 2 of 5
What was Gaunilo's objection to Anselm?
Question 3 of 5
William Rowe argues that a fawn's slow, apparently pointless death makes God's existence improbable. Which argument is this?
Question 4 of 5
What does Plantinga's free will defence aim to show?
Question 5 of 5
"Is an act good because God commands it, or does God command it because it is good?" This question is usually aimed at which argument?
