Philosophy › Section K · Political philosophy › Topic K.3

Political legitimacy, the social contract, and duty

Governments tax, imprison and send people to war, and most of us never agreed to any of it. What, if anything, gives a state the right to rule, and when, if ever, may a citizen refuse to obey?

Why obey?

You stop at a red light on an empty road at 3 a.m. Why? Perhaps fear of a fine. But most people also feel they ought to obey the law. Political philosophy asks whether that feeling is justified. A state has legitimacy if it has the right to rule, and citizens have political obligation if they have a moral duty to obey. The sociology topic "Power and authority" explained Max Weber's descriptive account: why people in fact accept authority. This topic asks the normative question: when ought they to? Older answers appealed to divine right, as the topic "Forms of government" showed. From the seventeenth century, social contract theorists grounded authority instead in the agreement of the governed.

Hobbes: escaping the war of all against all

Thomas Hobbes, in Leviathan (1651), written amid the English Civil Wars, imagined a state of nature without government. People are roughly equal, compete for scarce goods and fear one another, so life becomes a war of every person against every other, in which, he wrote, life is "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short". Rational people would agree to hand their power to a sovereign strong enough to keep peace. Because a divided sovereign invites renewed war, Hobbes favoured absolute authority, though subjects keep the right to defend their own lives. Critics ask why anyone would trust an unchecked ruler; Hobbes replied that even a harsh sovereign is better than civil war.

Locke: government to protect rights

John Locke's Second Treatise of Government (1689) pictured a gentler state of nature, governed by a natural law that reason can discover. People have natural rights to life, liberty and property, acquiring property by mixing their labour with unowned resources. What the state of nature lacks is an impartial judge and reliable enforcement, so people consent to form a government to protect their rights. That government is limited: legislative and executive powers should be separate, and if rulers violate the rights they were trusted to protect, the people may resist and replace them. These ideas influenced the American Declaration of Independence. Critics note that Locke's property theory was used to justify taking Indigenous lands deemed unimproved.

Rousseau: the general will

Jean-Jacques Rousseau's The Social Contract (1762) contains the famous line "Man is born free; and everywhere he is in chains." He asked how people could unite for protection yet remain as free as before. His answer was that each person gives themselves wholly to the community, which is governed by the general will: the shared will of citizens aimed at the common good, as distinct from the will of all, the mere sum of private interests. In obeying laws they make together, citizens obey themselves. Rousseau doubted that sovereignty could be represented. Critics, including Isaiah Berlin, warned that claims to know the general will can justify suppressing dissenters, who are said to be "forced to be free".

Worked example: testing tacit consent

Few people ever sign a social contract, so Locke appealed to tacit consent: by staying in a country and enjoying its protection, such as travelling its roads, you consent to its rule. Test the claim as David Hume did in "Of the Original Contract" (1748). 1. Consent must be free to bind. 2. A poor peasant who knows no foreign language and has little money cannot realistically leave his country. 3. Staying is therefore not a free choice for him, any more than a man carried aboard a ship while asleep consents to the captain by not leaping into the sea. 4. So residence does not show consent. 5. Many modern theorists turn to hypothetical consent instead: what reasonable people would agree to.

Other grounds of obligation

Some theorists drop consent altogether. H. L. A. Hart (1955) proposed a principle of fairness: those who benefit from a cooperative scheme, such as public order, owe their share of its burdens. Robert Nozick (1974) objected with neighbours who set up a public address system and demand that everyone take turns running it: receiving unrequested benefits does not create obligations. John Rawls argued for a natural duty of justice to support just institutions that apply to us, whether or not we consented. Utilitarians justify obedience by its good consequences, and democratic theorists ground authority in equal participation. Each faces the charge of explaining why we owe obedience to this state in particular.

Whose contract?

Critics have asked who the imagined contractors were. Carole Pateman's The Sexual Contract (1988) argued that classical contract theory quietly assumed men's power over women, through marriage, before any political agreement. Charles Mills's The Racial Contract (1997) argued that the contract tradition in practice treated non-white peoples as outside its protection, helping justify colonialism and slavery. Communitarians, such as the sociologist Amitai Etzioni, objected from another direction: we are formed by communities before we choose anything, so we have responsibilities as well as rights. Defenders of contract theory reply that these critiques expose failures to apply its ideals of freedom and equality, not flaws in the ideals.

Duty and disobedience

Even if a state is legitimate, must every law be obeyed? Henry David Thoreau, in "Civil Disobedience" (1849), refused to pay a poll tax to a government that upheld slavery and waged the Mexican-American War. Mohandas Gandhi developed satyagraha, holding firmly to truth, and grounded it in ahimsa, non-harming, so that resistance to British rule would stay non-violent. Martin Luther King Jr., in his "Letter from Birmingham Jail" (1963), defended breaking unjust segregation laws openly and accepting the penalty. Rawls defined civil disobedience as a public, non-violent, conscientious breach of law that appeals to the majority's sense of justice. Critics worry that if everyone follows their own conscience, the rule of law weakens; defenders reply that its public, non-violent form shows respect for law.

Worked example: a speed limit you think is too low

Must you obey a speed limit you believe is mistaken? 1. Hobbes: yes; the sovereign's commands keep the peace, and private judgement about laws is what leads to conflict. 2. Locke: yes, unless the law violates basic rights, which a speed limit does not. 3. Fairness: you benefit when others follow traffic laws, so you owe compliance too. 4. Civil disobedience: breaking it would not qualify, since speeding secretly is neither public nor an appeal against serious injustice. 5. Philosophical anarchist: there may be no general duty to obey, but safety still gives you strong reasons to drive carefully. 6. Note how the answers converge on behaviour while disagreeing about why.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, confusing legitimacy with power or popularity: a regime can be obeyed out of fear without having the right to rule. Second, treating Weber's descriptive account as a justification: it explains acceptance, not whether acceptance is deserved. Third, thinking social contract theorists believed in a historical signing; most used the contract as a test of justification. Fourth, equating Rousseau's general will with majority opinion: it aims at the common good. Fifth, treating any law-breaking as civil disobedience: it must be public, conscientious and, for Rawls, non-violent.

Key takeaways

Legitimacy is the right to rule; political obligation is a duty to obey. Hobbes's Leviathan (1651) justified an absolute sovereign as the escape from a brutal state of nature. Locke's Second Treatise (1689) founded limited government on consent and natural rights and allowed resistance. Rousseau's Social Contract (1762) located legitimacy in the general will. Hume challenged tacit consent, prompting appeals to hypothetical consent, fairness (Hart, against Nozick's objection), natural duty (Rawls) and democracy. Pateman, Mills and communitarians questioned the contract's scope. Thoreau, Gandhi and King defended conscientious, non-violent disobedience.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Legitimacy

A state's right to rule

Normative, unlike Weber's descriptive account.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did Hobbes favour an absolute, undivided sovereign?

Question 2 of 5

What is Hume's objection to tacit consent?

Question 3 of 5

How does Rousseau's general will differ from the will of all?

Question 4 of 5

Nozick imagined neighbours who set up a public address system and demand that you take a turn running it. Which theory is this aimed against?

Question 5 of 5

A driver secretly speeds because she thinks the limit is too low. Why is this not civil disobedience in Rawls's sense?

← Previous topicNext topic →