Philosophy › Section E · Logic and reasoning › Topic E.1

Philosophical methods for discovering truth

Philosophy has few settled answers, so it relies on a disciplined way of moving towards them. Reasoned dialogue, careful testing of hypotheses and a handful of basic laws of logic do most of the work.

Philosophy as a method

Philosophy has few results that everyone accepts. Bertrand Russell observed in The Problems of Philosophy (1912) that once a subject allows definite knowledge, it usually breaks away and becomes a separate science. What remains is as much a method as a body of knowledge: imagine the alternatives, then work out what each would imply, knowing that changing one belief can force changes in many others. Logic, the study of good reasoning, sits at the centre of that method. The topic "How philosophers arrive at truth" introduced its broad tools; this topic looks closely at dialectic, hypothesis testing and the basic laws of logic.

Argument and dialectic

In philosophy an argument is not a quarrel but a group of reasons put forward to back a conclusion. A dialectic is a reasoned discussion between people who hold different views, and its aim is to get closer to the truth, not to win. Debates often reward rhetorical tricks and appeals to emotion; dialectic is meant to be collaborative. The participants, called interlocutors, follow a familiar cycle: a question is asked, someone proposes an answer, the others test it, often with a counterexample, a case showing the answer is wrong, and the group works out what failed before trying a refined answer. Even without a final answer, each round improves understanding.

Dialectic in classical India

Many Upanishads are dialogues between a teacher and a seeker, and some record public contests; in one, the sage Yajnavalkya answers challengers at the court of King Janaka. Later the Nyaya school set rules for debate. It distinguished honest discussion aimed at truth (vada) from debate aimed only at victory (jalpa) and from purely destructive attack (vitanda). Nyaya also standardised a five-part argument: 1. Thesis: the hill has fire. 2. Reason: because it has smoke. 3. Example: wherever there is smoke there is fire, as in a kitchen. 4. Application: this hill has such smoke. 5. Conclusion: so the hill has fire.

Dialectic in classical Greece

Socrates pursued truth by questioning, and in Plato's Phaedrus he complains that written words cannot answer back: ask a book a question and it keeps saying the same thing. Fittingly, Plato wrote dialogues. In the Meno, Socrates suggests that a true belief becomes knowledge when it is tied down by reasoning about why it is true. Aristotle wrote the Topics, a handbook for dialectical argument, and went further by building the first formal system of logic, the syllogistic, which remained the standard account of valid inference until the late nineteenth century.

Testing hypotheses

A hypothesis is a suggested explanation for something we observe. To test one, derive a prediction in the form of a conditional: if the hypothesis is true, then we should observe a certain result. Suppose your phone's battery drains overnight and you suspect a particular background app. Prediction: if the app is the cause, removing it should stop the drain. If the drain continues, the hypothesis in this form is refuted, provided the test was fair. If the drain stops, the hypothesis is supported but not proven, since something else may also have changed. Reasoning matters at every stage: framing the hypothesis, choosing the test and judging the result.

Worked example: a dialectic in miniature

Question: what is a lie? 1. Answer A: a lie is a false statement. 2. Counterexample: someone who sincerely repeats a wrong train time is mistaken, not lying. 3. Diagnosis: lying depends on what the speaker believes, not on what is actually true. 4. Answer B: a lie is a statement the speaker believes is false. 5. Counterexample: an actor delivering a villain's lines says things he believes false, yet he is not lying. 6. Answer C: a lie is a statement the speaker believes is false, made with the intention that the hearer believe it. 7. Check: C covers ordinary lies and excludes mistakes and acting. Philosophers still debate harder cases, which is normal: each round leaves a better answer.

The law of non-contradiction

Three terms come first. A statement is a sentence with a truth value, true or false, such as "The library is open"; questions and commands are not statements. The negation of a statement denies it: "The library is not open." A contradiction joins a statement to its negation: "The library is open and the library is not open." The law of non-contradiction says that no statement is true together with its own negation, at once and in the same respect. The qualifiers matter. A library open in the morning and closed at night involves no contradiction. Aristotle called this law the most certain of all principles.

The law of excluded middle

The law of excluded middle says that for any statement, either it or its negation is true: P or not P. Together with non-contradiction, it means exactly one of P and not P is true, so either the library is open now or it is not. This law has critics. Intuitionist mathematicians do not accept it as a general law, because for them a statement counts as true only once it is proved, and vague words such as "tall" or "bald" raise puzzles about borderline cases. A third traditional law, the law of identity, says that everything is identical to itself.

Worked example: testing a set of beliefs

A manager believes three things: (a) every file in the folder was deleted; (b) the budget file was not deleted; (c) the budget file was in the folder. 1. From (a) and (c), it follows that the budget file was deleted. 2. That is the negation of (b). 3. So the three beliefs together imply a contradiction, and by the law of non-contradiction they cannot all be true. 4. Logic shows that the set is inconsistent, but not which belief to drop. 5. Next step: check the evidence for each. Perhaps "every file" was an exaggeration, or the budget file was saved somewhere else. Consistency is necessary for truth, but it is not enough.

Logic as a norm

Normativity concerns standards that we ought to meet. Ethics is normative for action; logic is normative for reasoning, because we ought not to accept contradictions or draw conclusions our reasons do not support. Some philosophers go further and call logic constitutive of reasoning: a stream of thoughts that ignored logic entirely would not count as reasoning at all. Notice that logic says how we should reason, not how people actually do; psychology studies the many ways real reasoning falls short.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating dialectic as debate: the goal is truth, and conceding a good point is a success. Second, calling any two opposing statements a contradiction without checking that they concern the same moment and the same respect. Third, thinking a passed test proves a hypothesis; it only supports it. Fourth, assuming that a consistent set of beliefs must be true: a story can be fully consistent and entirely false. Fifth, treating the laws of logic as descriptions of how people think rather than standards for how they should.

Key takeaways

Philosophy is largely a method, with logic at its core. Dialectic is collaborative reasoning towards truth through answers, counterexamples and refinements; it flourished in India, with Nyaya's rules and five-part argument, and in Greece, from Socrates to Aristotle. Hypotheses are tested through conditional predictions: failure refutes, success only supports. Non-contradiction rules out a statement and its negation both being true at once in the same respect; excluded middle says one of them is true. Logic is normative: it sets standards for reasoning.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Argument

Reasons put forward to back a conclusion

Not a quarrel.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What most clearly distinguishes a dialectic from an ordinary debate?

Question 2 of 5

Which of these sentences has the form of a contradiction?

Question 3 of 5

What does the law of excluded middle state?

Question 4 of 5

If a new fertiliser speeds growth, treated plants should outgrow untreated ones. In a fair test, they grow no faster. What follows?

Question 5 of 5

In the Nyaya five-part argument about the hill, what does the example step do?

← Previous topicNext topic →