Philosophy › Section F · Metaphysics › Topic F.2
Identity and the self in religious traditions
Much of the matter in your body has been replaced over the past ten years, yet you call yourself the same person. What makes that true? Religious traditions have given some of the deepest answers, from an immortal soul to the Buddhist claim that there is no lasting self at all.
Same person, new parts
Many of the atoms in your body are exchanged over the years as you eat, breathe and repair tissue, and many of your cells die and are replaced, though some, such as most neurons in the brain's cortex, last a lifetime. Your memories and beliefs change too. Yet you treat the child in old photographs as yourself. This is the problem of persistence: how much change can a thing undergo and still be the same thing? Endurantists say a thing is wholly present at each moment; perdurantists say it is spread through time with temporal parts, as a film has frames. For persons the stakes are high, because promises, blame, love and hopes for an afterlife all assume that someone stays the same.
The ship of Theseus
The Greek writer Plutarch reported that the Athenians preserved the ship of their hero Theseus for centuries, replacing each rotten plank with new timber, and that philosophers argued over whether it was still the same ship. Thomas Hobbes, in the seventeenth century, added a twist: suppose someone saved every discarded plank and rebuilt the original ship from them. Which ship is Theseus's? The puzzle turns on a distinction. Two things are qualitatively identical when they are exactly alike, like two new coins. A thing is numerically identical with something when they are one and the same thing. The puzzle asks about numerical identity.
Worked example: two ships, one name
Test each answer to Hobbes's version. 1. Identity follows continuity: the ship kept in use, repaired plank by plank, never stopped existing, so it is Theseus's ship. Objection: the rebuilt ship has all the original matter. 2. Identity follows matter: the reassembled ship is the original. Objection: then the ship the Athenians sailed during the repairs gradually became a different ship without anyone noticing. 3. Identity is partly convention: "same ship" means whatever our purposes require, original timber for a museum, the vessel in service for a navy. 4. Conclusion: each answer gives up an intuition, which is why the puzzle has lasted. The same options return for persons.
The soul as the lasting self
Many religious and philosophical traditions answer the persistence problem for persons with a soul: a non-physical self that remains one and the same while the body's matter is replaced. In Greek philosophy, Plato's dialogue Phaedo argues that the soul is distinct from the body and outlasts it. On a soul view, the body's matter can change completely, like the ship's planks, without threatening personal identity, and survival after death becomes possible. Christian, Islamic and Jewish thinkers, especially after contact with Greek philosophy, developed rich accounts of the soul, though they differ on how closely it is tied to the body.
Aquinas: the soul as form of the body
Thomas Aquinas (about 1225 to 1274) rejected the picture of a soul simply lodged in a body. Building on Aristotle's hylomorphism from the previous topic, he held that the soul is the form of the human body: it is what makes this matter a living, thinking human being. Because thinking is not, for Aquinas, the act of any bodily organ, the human soul can continue to exist after death. Yet a soul alone is not a complete human person, which fits the Christian teaching of bodily resurrection. The self is one unified living substance, not a ghost in a body.
Hindu views: ātman and brahman
In Hindu traditions, the ātman is the true self: eternal, never created, and distinct from the changing body and mind. Bound by karma, the consequences of action, the ātman passes through repeated births, a cycle called saṃsāra. The goal is mokṣa, liberation from that cycle. The Upanishads, ancient scriptures, link ātman with brahman, the ultimate reality. Schools read that link differently. Advaita Vedānta, systematised by Śaṅkara around the eighth century CE, holds that ātman and brahman are strictly identical. Dvaita Vedānta, founded by Madhva in the thirteenth century, holds that individual selves remain distinct from God.
Buddhism: no self
The Buddha rejected the idea of a permanent ātman. The doctrine of anātman, or no-self, holds that nothing in a person is an unchanging, independent essence. It is one of three marks of existence, alongside impermanence and dukkha, the suffering or unsatisfactoriness of conditioned life. The doctrine of dependent origination adds that everything arises in dependence on conditions and passes away when they change. The four noble truths diagnose the problem: life involves dukkha; its cause is craving, including craving for a lasting self; it can cease, in nirvana; and the eightfold path leads there.
The five aggregates and the chariot
If there is no self, what is a person? Buddhist philosophy answers with five aggregates, or skandhas: bodily form, feeling, perception, mental formations such as habits and intentions, and consciousness. A person is these changing streams working together. In the Questions of King Milinda, the monk Nāgasena asks the king whether his chariot is the wheels, the axle or the frame. It is none of them alone, and nothing beyond them. "Chariot" is a useful name for parts arranged in a certain way. Nāgasena says his own name works the same way.
Worked example: rebirth without a soul
Buddhism teaches rebirth but denies a soul. What, then, is reborn? 1. On the Hindu view, the answer is simple: the same ātman takes a new body. 2. The Buddhist cannot say this, since no unchanging thing passes from life to life. 3. Instead, the later life depends causally on the earlier one. Nāgasena compares this to lighting one lamp from another: the new flame is neither the same flame nor wholly unconnected. 4. Karma links the lives through cause and effect, not through a shared essence. 5. Compare the ship: the Buddhist treats "same person" as answer 3 treated "same ship", a label for a continuous causal process.
Other views: bundles and relations
The Scottish philosopher David Hume reached a view close to the Buddhist one without religion. In his Treatise of Human Nature (1739) he reported that when he looked inward he always met some particular perception, such as heat, love or pain, but never a self apart from them. He concluded that a person is "a bundle or collection of different perceptions". Other traditions locate the self in relationships. The southern African ethic of ubuntu holds that one's humanity is realised through relationships with others, so personhood is achieved within a community rather than being a private inner substance.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, qualitative and numerical identity are different: identical twins are qualitatively similar but numerically two. Second, Aquinas's soul is not a separate being housed in a body; it is the body's form. Third, not all Hindu schools identify ātman with brahman; Dvaita denies strict identity. Fourth, anātman does not deny that persons exist or act; it denies an unchanging essence beneath them. Fifth, Buddhist rebirth is causal continuity, not a soul moving between bodies.
Key takeaways
The problem of persistence asks how a thing can change yet stay numerically the same, as in the ship of Theseus. Soul views answer that a non-physical self lasts while matter changes; Aquinas made the soul the form of the body. Hindu traditions hold that an eternal ātman passes through saṃsāra until mokṣa, with Advaita identifying it with brahman and Dvaita keeping them distinct. Buddhism denies a lasting self: a person is five changing aggregates, and rebirth is causal continuity. Hume's secular bundle theory and ubuntu's relational view offer further alternatives.
Flashcards
Flashcard
How a thing can change and still be the same thing
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What twist did Thomas Hobbes add to the ship of Theseus puzzle?
Question 2 of 5
How did Thomas Aquinas describe the relation between the soul and the body?
Question 3 of 5
Which school holds that the individual self, ātman, is strictly identical with brahman?
Question 4 of 5
What is Nāgasena's chariot analogy meant to show?
Question 5 of 5
In the Buddhist account of rebirth, what links one life to the next?
