Philosophy › Section G · Epistemology › Topic G.1

What epistemology studies

Every subject aims at knowledge, but epistemology asks what knowledge itself is, where it comes from and how far it reaches. This topic sets out its questions, its tools and the basic distinctions the rest of the section relies on.

The theory of knowledge

The word epistemology joins the Greek epistēmē, knowledge, and logos, account or study. Epistemology asks three linked questions. What is knowledge, and how does it differ from mere belief or a lucky guess? What sources can give us knowledge: perception, memory, reasoning, the word of others? And how far does knowledge extend: can we know the past, other minds, moral truths or anything at all beyond our own experiences? Closely tied to these are questions about justification, the reasons that make a belief rational to hold, and about truth, the feature every item of knowledge must have.

How epistemologists work

Epistemology uses the methods described in "How philosophers arrive at truth". The central one is conceptual analysis: proposing an account of a concept such as knowledge, stated as necessary and sufficient conditions in the sense explained in "Logical statements". The account is then tested against cases. A counterexample, real or imagined, shows that a proposed condition is not necessary (someone knows without meeting it) or that the conditions are not sufficient (someone meets them all yet does not know). The account is revised and tested again. Epistemologists also draw on research about how people actually form beliefs.

Worked example: must knowledge be certain?

Test the proposal "you know something only if you are certain of it". 1. Identify its claim: certainty is a necessary condition of knowledge. 2. Look for a counterexample: a case of knowledge without certainty. 3. Candidate case: you see your friend wave from across the street in good light, and you believe she is there. You could in principle be wrong (a lookalike, a trick of the light), so you are not certain. 4. Judge the case: most people would still say you know she is there. 5. Conclude: if that judgement holds, certainty is not necessary for knowledge. 6. Note the reply: a sceptic may insist the judgement is mistaken, a challenge taken up in the topic "Skepticism".

Three kinds of knowledge

Propositional knowledge, or knowing that, is knowledge of a statement that is true or false: knowing that Nairobi is in Kenya or that 9 is 3 squared. Procedural knowledge, or knowing how, is a skill: knowing how to swim, knit or read a map. Gilbert Ryle, in The Concept of Mind (1949), argued that knowing how cannot be reduced to knowing facts, since someone can know every fact about swimming and still sink. Jason Stanley and Timothy Williamson (2001) replied that know-how is a special kind of knowing that, and the debate continues. Knowledge by acquaintance is direct awareness of something, such as your own pain. Traditional epistemology concentrates on propositional knowledge.

Acquaintance and the gap

Bertrand Russell contrasted knowledge by acquaintance with knowledge by description in a paper of 1910 to 1911. Acquaintance is direct: when you are in pain, you are aware of the pain without inferring it. Russell held that, in perception, we are acquainted only with sense data, the raw colours, shapes and sounds in experience, and that we infer the physical objects that cause them. If he is right, a gap opens between experience and the world, and with it the possibility of error that sceptics exploit. Direct realists object that perception presents physical objects themselves, not inner images, though they accept that illusions and hallucinations still occur.

A priori and a posteriori

Knowledge is a priori if it can be justified independently of experience, as you can see that 4 × 2 = 8 or that every square has four sides by thinking alone. It is a posteriori, or empirical, if it depends on experience, as knowing that it is raining outside does. "Prior" here is logical, not temporal: you may first learn multiplication by memorising tables, yet the facts can be justified by reason alone. Rationalists such as Descartes and Leibniz gave reason a large role; empiricists such as Locke and Hume traced most or all substantive knowledge to experience. W. V. O. Quine (1951) went further, arguing that no belief, even in logic, is wholly immune to revision in the light of experience.

Worked example: classifying knowledge

Classify each claim by type and source. 1. "Mei knows that a triangle's angles sum to 180 degrees in Euclidean geometry." Propositional, and a priori, because it can be proved without observation. 2. "Mei knows that the café on her street opens at seven." Propositional and a posteriori: she learned it by looking or being told. 3. "Mei knows how to change a tyre." Procedural: a skill. 4. "Mei feels a sharp itch on her arm." Her awareness of the itch is knowledge by acquaintance; her further belief that an insect bit her is propositional and inferred. 5. Check: every propositional item is a true statement she has reason to accept.

What is truth?

Knowledge requires truth, so epistemologists ask what truth is. A popular idea holds that truth is relative, "true for me" but not for you. Yet two people who disagree about whether Earth is flat cannot both be right, and a question can have a true answer nobody can find, such as the exact number of grains of sand on a beach. Aristotle's formula captures the core: to say of what is that it is, is true. The correspondence theory develops this: a statement is true when it matches a fact. Rivals include the coherence theory, the pragmatist view associated with William James, and deflationary views that trace back to Frank Ramsey (1927).

A normative discipline across traditions

Epistemology does not only describe how people form beliefs; it evaluates them. Calling a belief justified or careless is praise or criticism, so epistemology is normative: it concerns how we ought to believe. The Nyāya school, introduced in "Classical Indian philosophy", organised epistemology around the pramāṇas, the reliable means of knowledge. The Chinese philosopher Mozi (about 470 to 391 BCE) proposed three standards for testing a claim: its basis in the deeds of the ancient sage kings, its fit with what ordinary people see and hear, and whether applying it benefits the people.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming that a priori knowledge must be innate or learned without any teacher: the label concerns how a claim is justified, not when or how you first met it. Second, treating know-how as simply a list of facts; whether it is one is exactly what Ryle and his critics dispute. Third, saying a belief is "true for me": beliefs can differ between people, but a statement about the world is true or false whatever anyone believes. Fourth, thinking a counterexample must be a real event; imagined cases count if they are coherent. Fifth, forgetting that epistemology evaluates belief as well as describing it.

Key takeaways

Epistemology studies what knowledge is, where it comes from and how far it extends, together with justification and truth. It proceeds by conceptual analysis: proposing necessary and sufficient conditions and testing them with counterexamples. Knowledge comes in three kinds: propositional, procedural and by acquaintance, and traditional epistemology focuses on the first. A priori knowledge is justified independently of experience; a posteriori knowledge depends on it. Truth is not relative to the believer; the correspondence theory has coherence, pragmatist and deflationary rivals. Epistemology is normative, a feature shared by Nyāya's pramāṇas and Mozi's three standards.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Epistemology

The study of knowledge, its sources and its limits

From Greek epistēmē, knowledge, and logos, study.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A philosopher proposes that knowledge requires certainty. A critic describes a case where someone seems to know without being certain. What is the critic doing?

Question 2 of 5

Which is an example of procedural knowledge?

Question 3 of 5

Why can knowledge be a priori even if you first learned it from a teacher?

Question 4 of 5

On Russell's view, what are you directly acquainted with when you see a bird on a branch?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement best expresses the correspondence theory of truth?

← Previous topicNext topic →