Physics › Section J · Thermodynamics › Topic J.3
Heat engines and efficiency
Power stations, car engines and jet engines all turn heat into work, and every one of them throws a large share of that heat away. The second law of thermodynamics explains why some waste is unavoidable, and efficiency measures how much useful work is left.
Processes that only go one way
A hot pan on a cold worktop cools down; the worktop never cools further to make the pan hotter. A sliding book stops as friction turns its kinetic energy into thermal energy, but a warm book never cools itself and slides off. A puff of gas released into an empty box spreads to fill it and never gathers back in a corner. None of the reverse processes would break the first law, because energy would still be conserved. Yet they never happen. A separate law, the second law of thermodynamics, describes this one-way character of natural processes, and it also limits what engines can do.
The second law: heat flows downhill
The simplest statement of the second law, due to Rudolf Clausius, concerns heat flow. Left alone, heat always passes from a hot body to a cold one, and never the other way. The word spontaneously matters. A refrigerator does move heat from its cold interior to the warmer kitchen, but only because it is supplied with work, a topic later in this section. Left to themselves, two objects in contact exchange heat until their temperatures are equal, and the flow always runs from the higher temperature to the lower one.
What a heat engine does
A heat engine is a device that uses heat flowing from hot to cold to do work, repeating a cycle. It takes in heat \(Q_h\) from a hot reservoir, such as burning fuel or a nuclear reactor, does work \(W\), and rejects heat \(Q_c\) to a cold reservoir, usually the air or a river. A reservoir is a body so large that its temperature stays fixed however much heat it gains or loses. In this topic \(Q_h\), \(Q_c\) and \(W\) all stand for positive amounts, with the direction of each transfer shown by words or arrows rather than signs. Petrol and diesel engines, steam turbines and jet engines all fit this pattern.
Energy over a cycle
Because an engine works in a cycle, its working substance, such as the steam or gas inside, returns to the same state at the end of each cycle. Internal energy is a state function, so over one full cycle \(\Delta U = 0\). The first law then says the net heat in equals the net work out:
In words, the work you get is the heat you take in minus the heat you throw away. An engine that takes in 1000 J and rejects 650 J each cycle does 350 J of work per cycle.
The second law: no perfect engine
Ideally \(Q_c\) would be zero, so that every joule taken in became work. The second law forbids it. In the form due to Lord Kelvin and Max Planck: no engine working in a cycle can take heat from a reservoir and convert all of it into work. Some heat must always be rejected to a colder reservoir. This waste heat is not a design fault that better engineering will remove; it is required by the laws of physics. It also rules out any perpetual motion machine that would run forever by turning the heat of, say, the sea entirely into work. The Kelvin-Planck and Clausius statements look different, but each can be proved from the other, so they are two faces of one law.
Efficiency
The efficiency \(\mathit{Eff}\) of a heat engine is the useful work out divided by the heat put in:
The second form follows from \(W = Q_h - Q_c\). Efficiency is a pure number, often written as a percentage. Since \(Q_c\) can never be zero, efficiency is always less than 1, or 100%. The engine above, taking in 1000 J and doing 350 J of work, has an efficiency of 0.350, or 35.0%.
Worked example: a power station
In one day a power station takes in \(1.80 \times 10^{14}\) J of heat from its fuel and rejects \(1.08 \times 10^{14}\) J to a cooling tower. Find its work output, its efficiency and its average power. 1. Work: \(W = Q_h - Q_c = 7.20 \times 10^{13}\) J. 2. Efficiency: \(7.20 \times 10^{13} \div 1.80 \times 10^{14} = 0.400\), or 40.0%. 3. Power: one day is 86,400 s, so
about 833 MW. 4. Check with the other formula: \(1 - 1.08/1.80 = 1 - 0.600 = 0.400\). Note that 60% of the energy leaves as waste heat; some stations pipe it to nearby buildings for heating.
Worked example: a car engine
A car engine is 25.0% efficient and delivers 30.0 kW of mechanical power at a steady motorway speed. At what rate does it use heat from its fuel, and at what rate does it reject waste heat? 1. Efficiency applies to rates as well as amounts: \(P_{\text{out}} = \mathit{Eff} \times P_{\text{in}}\). 2. Heat input rate: \(30.0 \div 0.250 = 120\) kW. 3. Waste heat rate: \(120 - 30.0 = 90.0\) kW, which leaves through the exhaust and the radiator. 4. Check: \(90.0 \div 120 = 0.750\), and \(1 - 0.750 = 0.250\), the efficiency given. The engine rejects three joules for every joule of work it delivers.
The Otto cycle
A four-stroke petrol engine is modelled by the Otto cycle, a loop on a PV diagram built from the processes of the previous topic. A to B: the fuel-air mixture is compressed quickly, almost adiabatically, so work is done on it and it heats up. B to C: the spark ignites the fuel so fast that the volume barely changes, so heat enters at nearly constant volume and the pressure soars. C to D: the power stroke, a near-adiabatic expansion in which the hot gas does work on the piston. D to A: the exhaust valve opens and heat leaves at nearly constant volume. The gas does more work during the high-pressure expansion than the piston does on it during the low-pressure compression, and the difference, the area inside the loop, is the net work.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, dividing by the wrong heat: efficiency is work divided by the heat taken in, \(Q_h\), not by the heat rejected. Second, writing \(Q_c/Q_h\) as the efficiency; that is the fraction wasted. Third, thinking a perfect design could reach 100%; the second law requires some rejected heat. Fourth, forgetting that \(\Delta U = 0\) only over a whole cycle, not during each step. Fifth, mixing a power with an energy, such as kilowatts with joules per day, in one calculation.
Key takeaways
Many natural processes run only one way, and the second law describes this. Clausius: heat flows spontaneously only from hot to cold. Kelvin-Planck: no cyclic engine converts all the heat it takes in into work. A heat engine takes in Q_h, does work W and rejects Q_c, and over a cycle ΔU = 0, so W = Q_h − Q_c. Efficiency is Eff = W/Q_h = 1 − Q_c/Q_h, always below 100%. The Otto cycle models a petrol engine with two adiabatic and two constant-volume steps; its net work is the area of the loop.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Heat flows spontaneously only from hotter to colder
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
An engine takes in 2500 J of heat and rejects 1750 J each cycle. What is its efficiency?
Question 2 of 5
Each cycle, an engine that is 35.0% efficient delivers 700 J of work. What heat does it reject each cycle?
Question 3 of 5
Which statement is a form of the second law of thermodynamics?
Question 4 of 5
A power station takes in heat at a rate of 3.00 × 10⁹ W and is 36.0% efficient. At what rate does it reject waste heat?
Question 5 of 5
In the Otto cycle model of a petrol engine, which step is the power stroke?
