Physics › Section C · Forces and Newton's laws › Topic C.5
Problem-solving with Newton's laws
A hanging sign, a cart pulled by a falling mass and two weights over a pulley look like different problems, but they all give way to the same four steps: choose a system, draw its forces, apply Newton's second law along each axis, and check the answer.
Why a routine helps
A crane lifting a load, a sledge on a hill, two crates joined by a rope: Newton's second law, \(\Sigma F = ma\), links forces to motion in all of them. The algebra is rarely the hard part; deciding which object to study and which forces act on it is. A four-step routine turns those decisions into habits.
Step 1: sketch the problem and choose the system
Make a rough sketch and list what you know and what you must find. Then choose the system: the object, or group of objects, whose motion you will analyse. This matters because the second law counts only external forces, those exerted on the system by things outside it. Forces between parts of the system are internal: by Newton's third law they come in equal and opposite pairs inside the system, so they cancel from its net force. A rope's tension can be external for one choice of system and internal for another.
Step 2: draw the free-body diagram and pick axes
Draw the system as a dot or a box with an arrow for every external force on it, pointing the way that force acts: the weight \(mg\), a normal force \(F_N\), a tension \(T\), an applied push \(F\). Show forces only; velocity and acceleration never go on the diagram. Then choose axes. If you know which way the system accelerates, put one axis in that direction and call it positive. Split every force at an angle to the axes into components, so one two-dimensional problem becomes two one-dimensional ones.
Steps 3 and 4: apply the second law, then check
Write the second law separately for each axis:
If the system does not accelerate along an axis, the net force along it is zero; an object at rest or at constant velocity has zero net force along both. You need as many independent equations as unknowns, so two unknown tensions need both axes. Then check: a force must come out in newtons, its size should be reasonable, and the answer should behave sensibly in a limiting case, such as one mass shrinking to zero.
Worked example: a sign on two cables
A 20.0 kg sign hangs at rest from two light cables. Cable A, on the left, makes 30.0° with the horizontal; cable B, on the right, makes 60.0°. Find both tensions. 1. System: the sign, with \(T_A\) up and to the left, \(T_B\) up and to the right, and weight \(mg = 196\) N down; \(a = 0\). 2. Take x to the right and y upwards. 3. Horizontal balance:
so \(T_B = 1.732\,T_A\). 4. Vertical balance:
which becomes \(0.500T_A + 1.500T_A = 196\) N. So \(T_A = 98.0\) N and \(T_B = 170\) N. 5. Check: the steeper cable carries more of the load. The cables meet at a right angle, so \(98.0^2 + 169.7^2\) should equal \(196^2\), and both are about 38,400 N².
Bodies joined by strings
String-and-pulley problems use a standard model: the string is light (negligible mass) and does not stretch, and each pulley is light and frictionless. Then the tension is the same all along the string, and the joined objects have accelerations of the same size. Treating the whole group as one system makes the tension internal, so it drops out and the acceleration comes quickly. Giving every object its own free-body diagram yields one equation per object, and solving them together also gives the tension. For each object, call positive the way it moves with the system, following the string round the pulley, so all share one positive \(a\).
Worked example: a cart pulled by a hanging mass
A 3.00 kg cart on a level, frictionless track is tied to a string that runs over a light, frictionless pulley to a hanging 2.00 kg mass. Find the acceleration and the tension. 1. Whole system, 5.00 kg: the cart's weight and normal force balance, so the only unbalanced force along the string is the hanging weight, \(2.00 \times 9.80 = 19.6\) N. 2. Acceleration:
3. Cart alone: the only horizontal force on it is the tension, so \(T = m_1 a = 3.00 \times 3.92 = 11.8\) N. 4. Check with the hanging mass: \(m_2 g - T = 19.6 - 11.76 = 7.84\) N, which equals \(m_2 a = 2.00 \times 3.92\). The tension is less than the hanging weight, as it must be for that mass to speed up.
Worked example: an Atwood machine
Masses of 5.00 kg and 3.00 kg hang from opposite ends of one light string over a light, frictionless pulley, released from rest. Find the acceleration, the tension and the speed after 2.00 s. 1. The heavier mass falls: take down as positive for it and up for the lighter one. 2. Heavier mass: \(m_1 g - T = m_1 a\). Lighter mass: \(T - m_2 g = m_2 a\). 3. Add the equations, and \(T\) cancels:
4. Tension, from the lighter mass: \(T = m_2(g + a) = 3.00 \times 12.25 = 36.8\) N. 5. Kinematics: \(v = v_0 + at = 0 + 2.45 \times 2.00 = 4.90\) m/s. 6. Check: \(T\) lies between the weights, 29.4 N and 49.0 N, and equal masses would give \(a = 0\) and \(T = mg\).
Choosing the system for a contact force
On a frictionless floor you push a 3.00 kg block with a horizontal 12.0 N force, and it pushes a 1.00 kg block ahead of it. With both blocks as the system, the contact force between them is internal, so \(a = 12.0 \div 4.00 = 3.00\) m/s². Now take the front block alone: the contact force is the only horizontal force on it, so it is \(1.00 \times 3.00 = 3.00\) N. Check with the rear block: \(12.0 - 3.00 = 9.00\) N, which equals \(3.00 \times 3.00\). Your push is not passed on in full; the front block gets just enough to share the acceleration.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, putting a force the object exerts on something else onto its own free-body diagram; only forces on the system belong there. Second, drawing \(ma\) as an extra force: it is the result of the forces, not one of them. Third, mixing sign conventions between joined objects; follow the string so every object has the same positive direction. Fourth, assuming a string's tension equals the hanging weight, which is true only when nothing accelerates. Fifth, using one axis only when forces act at angles and there are two unknowns.
Key takeaways
Choose a system: only external forces enter the second law, since internal forces cancel in third-law pairs. Draw forces only, put an axis along the acceleration, and resolve angled forces. Apply ΣF = ma along each axis, with zero net force along any axis without acceleration. Light strings over light, frictionless pulleys carry one tension, and joined objects share one acceleration. For a cart pulled by a hanging mass, a = m₂g/(m₁ + m₂); for an Atwood machine, a = (m₁ − m₂)g/(m₁ + m₂). Always check units, size and limiting cases.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Sketch and choose the system; draw the free-body diagram; apply ΣF = ma per axis; check
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A 4.0 kg cart on a level, frictionless track is pulled by a string over a light, frictionless pulley attached to a hanging 1.0 kg mass. What is the acceleration? Use g = 9.80 m/s².
Question 2 of 5
In an Atwood machine, masses of 6.0 kg and 2.0 kg hang from a light string over a light, frictionless pulley. What is the tension in the string? Use g = 9.80 m/s².
Question 3 of 5
Two blocks joined by a string are pulled across a frictionless floor by a rope attached to the front block. If you take both blocks together as the system, which force does not appear in the second law for that system?
Question 4 of 5
On a frictionless floor, an 18 N horizontal push acts on a 4.0 kg block, which pushes a 2.0 kg block ahead of it. What force does the 4.0 kg block exert on the 2.0 kg block?
Question 5 of 5
A 15.0 kg sign hangs at rest from two light cables on opposite sides, one at 30.0° and one at 60.0° above the horizontal. What is the tension in the 60.0° cable? Use g = 9.80 m/s².
