Psychology › Section K · Personality › Topic K.7
Trait theories and the Big Five
Instead of asking where personality comes from, trait theorists asked a simpler question first: how should we describe it? Their answer, refined over a century, is the Big Five, the most widely used and best-supported model in personality psychology today.
What a trait approach does
A trait is a relatively stable tendency to think, feel and act in a certain way, such as being talkative, anxious or organised. Trait theorists make two key assumptions. First, traits are dimensions, not boxes: everyone has some amount of each trait, and most people score near the middle rather than at either extreme. Second, a small number of broad traits can summarise a great deal of personality. Their main task has been to find those few dimensions and measure them reliably. Trait models describe personality more than they explain it, but good description is what makes prediction and testing possible.
Allport: cardinal, central and secondary traits
Gordon Allport, a pioneer of the field, reasoned that important personality differences would have found their way into everyday language. In 1936, he and Henry Odbert searched an English dictionary and found about 18,000 words describing people, of which roughly 4,500 described stable traits. Allport sorted traits into three levels. A cardinal trait dominates a whole life, so that nearly everything the person does serves it; such people are rare. Central traits are the handful of broad characteristics, perhaps five to ten, that friends would use to describe someone, such as warm or reliable. Secondary traits appear only in particular situations or concern narrow preferences.
Worked example: Allport's three levels
Classify three descriptions of a fictional woman, Rosa. A: her friends call her generous, loyal, quick-witted and stubborn. B: she becomes impatient in queues at the post office. C: every decision she has made for 40 years, from her career to her friendships, has served one passion: protecting wildlife. 1. Ask how much of her life each trait governs. C organises nearly everything she does, so it is a cardinal trait. 2. A lists the broad traits that describe her across settings: central traits. 3. B appears only in one narrow kind of situation: a secondary trait. 4. Check: Allport expected most people to lack a cardinal trait, so C makes Rosa unusual.
Cattell and the 16PF
Raymond Cattell wanted to reduce the long list of trait words scientifically rather than by judgement. He used factor analysis, a statistical method that finds which items tend to be answered together and groups them into underlying dimensions. Cutting Allport's list to about 171 clusters, and then analysing ratings and questionnaire data, he arrived at 16 source traits, such as warmth, emotional stability, dominance and perfectionism. His questionnaire, the Sixteen Personality Factor Questionnaire, or 16PF, scores each trait on a continuum from low to high. The 16PF is still used, but later researchers found that its 16 factors overlap and can be reduced further.
The Eysencks: two dimensions
Hans Eysenck and Sybil Eysenck argued for far fewer dimensions, tied closely to biology. Their two main dimensions were extraversion-introversion, from sociable and outgoing to reserved and solitary, and neuroticism-stability, from anxious and moody to calm and even-tempered. Hans Eysenck proposed that introverts have higher baseline arousal in the brain, so they seek less stimulation; the evidence for this is mixed. Crossing the two dimensions gives four quadrants that echo Galen's temperaments: stable extraverts resemble the sanguine type, unstable extraverts the choleric, unstable introverts the melancholic, and stable introverts the phlegmatic. They later added a third dimension, psychoticism, linked to coldness, impulsiveness and hostility.
The Big Five
Many independent research teams, analysing both trait words and questionnaires, kept finding the same five broad factors. Paul Costa and Robert McCrae built one of the best-known questionnaires around them. They are remembered as OCEAN. Openness to experience: curious, imaginative and drawn to new ideas, versus conventional and practical. Conscientiousness: organised, dependable and self-disciplined, versus careless and spontaneous. Extraversion: sociable, assertive and energetic, versus reserved and quiet. Agreeableness: trusting, kind and cooperative, versus critical and competitive. Neuroticism: prone to anxiety, sadness and other negative emotions, versus emotionally stable. Each factor contains narrower facets, and each is a continuum.
Worked example: building a Big Five profile
Describe a fictional student, Kofi, in Big Five terms. He plans his revision weeks ahead, rarely misses a deadline and keeps a tidy desk. He prefers a quiet evening with one friend to a big party. He loves debating unusual ideas and trying unfamiliar food. He is patient and generous with classmates, and he rarely feels anxious, even before exams. 1. Conscientiousness: high. 2. Extraversion: low. 3. Openness: high. 4. Agreeableness: high. 5. Neuroticism: low, so emotional stability is high. 6. Eysenck check: low extraversion plus stability puts him in the stable-introvert quadrant. Note the profile describes a pattern; it is not a judgement or a diagnosis.
How good is the evidence?
The Big Five has strong support. Twin studies find each factor moderately heritable, at about 40% to 50%. The factors appear in questionnaire studies across dozens of countries, though they replicate less clearly in some small-scale, non-industrial societies. They predict real outcomes: conscientiousness predicts school grades and job performance across many kinds of work, and several traits predict health and even length of life. The links are typically modest for any single outcome, but they add up across many outcomes and years. A rival model, HEXACO, adds a sixth factor, honesty-humility (sincere, fair and modest versus manipulative and boastful), and often predicts dishonest behaviour better than the Big Five.
Stability and change
Big Five traits are fairly stable in adulthood, and people's rank order relative to others grows more stable with age. Average levels still shift in a predictable pattern sometimes called the maturity principle: from early adulthood into middle age, conscientiousness and agreeableness tend to rise and neuroticism tends to fall. Major life roles, such as a first serious job, may contribute. Change is also possible on purpose: studies of people who set goals to change a trait, and of therapy, find modest shifts over months. So traits describe where a person usually stands, not a fixed sentence.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating traits as types: you are not "an extravert" or "an introvert" so much as somewhere along a continuum, usually near the middle. Second, reading neuroticism as a diagnosis; it is a normal personality dimension that everyone has to some degree. Third, mixing up openness (curiosity about ideas and experience) with extraversion (sociability). Fourth, forgetting that trait links to outcomes are modest for any single event. Fifth, swapping the Eysenck quadrants: stable extraverts match the sanguine type, unstable extraverts the choleric. Sixth, saying traits never change: they shift in a predictable pattern across adulthood.
Key takeaways
Traits are stable tendencies measured as dimensions. Allport's lexical search found about 18,000 person-describing words and distinguished cardinal, central and secondary traits. Cattell used factor analysis to reach 16 factors in the 16PF. The Eysencks proposed extraversion-introversion and neuroticism-stability, whose quadrants echo the four temperaments, and later psychoticism. The Big Five, OCEAN, is the best-supported model: moderately heritable, found across many cultures, and modestly predictive of grades, work and health. HEXACO adds honesty-humility. Traits are stable but follow the maturity principle: conscientiousness and agreeableness rise, neuroticism falls.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A relatively stable tendency to think, feel and act in a certain way
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which Big Five factor describes the tendency to experience anxiety, sadness and other negative emotions?
Question 2 of 5
Allport would call a trait that shapes almost every choice in a person's life a:
Question 3 of 5
On the Eysencks' two dimensions, a person who is highly extraverted and emotionally stable falls in the quadrant matching which ancient temperament?
Question 4 of 5
From early adulthood into middle age, how do average Big Five levels typically change?
Question 5 of 5
What does the HEXACO model add to the Big Five?
