Statics › Section D · Moments and static equivalence › Topic D.2

Adding moments

Most bodies feel several forces at once, each trying to turn them a different way. Adding their moments with a clear sign convention gives the net turning tendency about a point, the quantity that rigid-body equilibrium will soon require to be zero.

Moments are vectors

Because moments are vectors, they add by the rules of vector addition. In three dimensions that means adding their x, y and z components separately. In two dimensions there is a short cut. Every moment of a force lying in the xy-plane points along the z-axis, either out of the page or into it, so each one can be described by a single signed number. Adding the moments then becomes ordinary addition of those numbers, with the sign of the total telling you which way the net moment turns.

Three sign conventions

Scalar components were introduced for forces along a line, and the same idea extends to moments. Statics uses three standard conventions at once. For forces in the x direction, to the right is positive, along \(\mathbf{i}\). For forces in the y direction, upwards is positive, along \(\mathbf{j}\). For moments in the xy-plane, counterclockwise is positive, because by the right-hand rule a counterclockwise moment points along \(\mathbf{k}\). So a scalar moment of +30 N·m means 30 N·m counterclockwise, and −30 N·m means 30 N·m clockwise. When no convention is stated, assume these.

Reading a stated moment

A problem may give a moment as a number beside a curved arrow. The arrow defines the positive sense for that number. A value of 60 N·m beside a clockwise arrow is a clockwise moment, which is −60 N·m in our convention. A value of −50 N·m beside a clockwise arrow is a moment of 50 N·m counterclockwise, +50 N·m in our convention, because the minus sign reverses the arrow. Convert every given moment to the standard convention before you add anything, and the bookkeeping takes care of itself.

Magnitude or scalar component?

A magnitude and a scalar component are both scalars with units, but they are not the same thing. A magnitude is never negative: the size of a 50 N·m moment is 50 N·m whichever way it turns. A scalar component can be positive or negative, and it means nothing without a sign convention, stated or implied. There is no special symbol to tell the two apart, so read the context. When you write a final answer, give either the signed scalar with its convention, or the magnitude with the word clockwise or counterclockwise.

Adding moments in a plane

To find the resultant moment of several forces about a point O, take each force in turn. 1. Find the magnitude of its moment about O, using \(Fd_\perp\). 2. Decide by inspection whether it turns counterclockwise or clockwise about O, and attach + or −. 3. Add the signed values:

M_O = M_1 + M_2 + M_3 + \cdots

4. Read the sign of the total: positive is counterclockwise, negative is clockwise, and its absolute value is the magnitude. A force whose line passes through O contributes zero, so it can be skipped.

Worked example: loads on a beam

A horizontal 4.0 m beam has point O at its left end. It carries 300 N downwards at 1.5 m from O, 150 N downwards at 3.0 m, an upward 200 N at the right end, and a 500 N horizontal pull along the beam's axis. Find the resultant moment about O. 1. 300 N down, to the right of O: clockwise, \(-300(1.5) = -450\) N·m. 2. 150 N down at 3.0 m: \(-150(3.0) = -450\) N·m. 3. 200 N up at 4.0 m: counterclockwise, \(+800\) N·m. 4. The 500 N pull lies on a line through O: zero. 5. Sum: \(-450 - 450 + 800 = -100\) N·m, so the resultant is 100 N·m clockwise.

The moment centre matters

Take the same beam and add moments about its right end, B, instead. The 300 N load is 2.5 m to the left of B and pushes down, which turns the beam counterclockwise about B: \(+750\) N·m. The 150 N load, 1.0 m to the left, gives \(+150\) N·m. The 200 N force acts at B and the 500 N pull lies along a line through B, so both give zero. The total is +900 N·m, counterclockwise, completely different from the −100 N·m about O. A resultant moment always belongs to a stated point.

Worked example: finding a balancing force

A 1.2 m horizontal bar is pinned at its left end O. It carries 80 N downwards at 0.5 m from O and 50 N downwards at its far end. What upward force F, applied 0.3 m from O, makes the resultant moment about O zero? 1. The 80 N load: \(-80(0.5) = -40\) N·m. 2. The 50 N load: \(-50(1.2) = -60\) N·m. 3. The force F: \(+0.3F\). 4. Set the sum to zero: \(0.3F - 100 = 0\), so \(F = 333\) N. 5. Check: F acts close to the pin, so its arm is short and it must be much larger than the loads it balances.

Adding moments in three dimensions

In space, a moment has three scalar components, \(\mathbf{M} = M_x\mathbf{i} + M_y\mathbf{j} + M_z\mathbf{k}\), each the turning tendency about one coordinate axis. Add moments component by component, then find the magnitude by Pythagoras. For example, \(\mathbf{M}_1 = \langle 30, -20, 0 \rangle\) N·m and \(\mathbf{M}_2 = \langle -10, 5, 40 \rangle\) N·m add to \(\langle 20, -15, 40 \rangle\) N·m, with magnitude \(\sqrt{400 + 225 + 1600} = 47.2\) N·m. Unlike the 2D case, one signed number is no longer enough: you need all three.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, adding magnitudes without signs, so that opposing moments reinforce instead of cancelling. Second, misreading a given moment whose arrow is clockwise: convert it to the standard convention first. Third, mixing moment centres in one sum; every term must be about the same point. Fourth, giving an answer as a bare negative number without saying which convention it uses. Fifth, reporting a negative magnitude. Sixth, in 3D, adding the components of one moment to each other instead of matching x with x, y with y and z with z.

Key takeaways

Moments add as vectors. In a plane they all lie along the z-axis, so each is a signed scalar, positive counterclockwise and negative clockwise, and they add as ordinary numbers. A given moment's arrow sets the sense of its value, so convert it before adding. Magnitudes are never negative; scalar components need a convention. The resultant moment depends on the point chosen, and a force through that point contributes nothing. In 3D, add the x, y and z components separately and find the magnitude by Pythagoras.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Adding moments

Moments add as vectors, component by component

In 2D, as signed numbers.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Three moments act about a point: 35 N·m clockwise, 50 N·m counterclockwise and 20 N·m clockwise. What is the resultant?

Question 2 of 5

A moment is labelled −40 N·m beside a clockwise arrow. Which description is correct?

Question 3 of 5

What is the magnitude of the moment ⟨12, −9, 20⟩ N·m?

Question 4 of 5

A 3.0 m beam has O at its left end. It carries 400 N downwards at 1.0 m from O and 100 N upwards at 3.0 m. What is the resultant moment about O?

Question 5 of 5

Why can the same set of forces have a different resultant moment about two different points?

← Previous topicNext topic →