Statics › Section F · Equilibrium of structures › Topic F.6
Analyzing frames
Frames hold up buildings, bicycles and shelves, and at least one of their members is pushed and pulled at three or more places. You solve them by taking them apart, member by member, and keeping every action-reaction pair straight.
Frames and multi-force members
A frame is a stationary structure, designed to support loads, that contains at least one multi-force member. A multi-force member carries more than two concentrated forces, or a distributed load, or a couple, so it is not a two-force member. Its forces need not act along its length, so besides stretching or squashing it also bends. A frame may also contain two-force members, such as struts, ties and links, and spotting them first is the best move in any frame problem, because each carries a force of known direction.
Why joints and sections fail here
The truss methods rely on every member being a two-force member. Cut a straight truss member and you expose one unknown: an axial force along a known line. Cut a multi-force member and you expose a force of unknown size and direction plus an internal bending moment, three unknowns in 2D. A joint or section would quickly have more unknowns than equations. So for frames the rule is different: take the structure apart at its pins, not through its members, and draw a free-body diagram of each member. The pin forces between members are then the unknowns, written as x and y components.
How many equations each part gives
Each free-body diagram brings its own number of independent equations. A two-force member gives one: it simply fixes that its two end forces are equal, opposite and along the line between its pins. A body whose forces are all concurrent and that carries no couple gives two, \(\Sigma F_x = 0\) and \(\Sigma F_y = 0\), as for a particle. A general multi-force body gives three, adding \(\Sigma M = 0\). Add these up over the parts and compare the total with the unknowns. If they match and the structure is stable, it is statically determinate. Equations for the whole frame are not extra: they are sums of the member equations.
The procedure
1. Decide whether the frame is rigid on its own. If it is, treat it as one body and find the support reactions first. 2. Draw a free-body diagram of each multi-force member, showing applied loads, couples and any weight that matters. 3. Where a two-force member connects, draw one force along that member's line, of unknown size. 4. At every other pin, draw unknown x and y components, and draw the equal and opposite pair on the connected member with the same labels. 5. Write the equilibrium equations for each diagram. 6. Solve, one diagram at a time or all together. A negative result means that force or moment acts opposite to the direction you drew.
Is the frame rigid on its own?
A frame is independently rigid if it keeps its shape when lifted off its supports. Look for triangles: a closed triangle of members cannot deform. If the frame is rigid, the whole frame is one rigid body with three equations, and its reactions come out at once when there are no more than three. If it is not rigid, like two bars hinged together at their tops and pinned at their feet, it would fold without its supports. Its whole-frame equations are still true, but it usually has four reaction components, one too many. Then you combine whole-frame equations with those of individual members, as the next example shows.
Worked example: a frame that is not rigid alone
Bar AC runs from a pin support at A(0, 0) to a pin C(4, 4), in metres, and carries 12 kN downward at its midpoint (2, 2). Bar BC runs from a pin support at B(8, 0) to C and carries a 6 kN horizontal load, pointing towards A, at its midpoint (6, 2). Both bars are multi-force members, with six unknowns: \(A_x, A_y, B_x, B_y\) and the two pin components at C. 1. Whole frame, moments about A, counterclockwise positive. \(B_x\) lies on the line through A, so it drops out:
giving \(B_y = 1.5\) kN, and vertical balance gives \(A_y = 10.5\) kN. 2. Bar BC alone, moments about C:
so \(B_x = 1.5\) kN.
Worked example: finishing the frame
3. Whole frame, horizontal balance: \(A_x + 1.5 - 6 = 0\), so \(A_x = 4.5\) kN. 4. Bar BC, force balance: the pin at C must supply \(6 - 1.5 = 4.5\) kN horizontally and \(-1.5\) kN vertically, so AC pushes BC with (4.5, −1.5) kN. By the third law, BC pushes AC with (−4.5, 1.5) kN. 5. Check bar AC, whose equations were not used. Horizontally \(4.5 - 4.5 = 0\). Vertically \(10.5 - 12 + 1.5 = 0\). Moments about A: the pin force at C(4, 4) gives \(4(1.5) - 4(-4.5) = 24\) kN·m and the load gives \(-2(12) = -24\) kN·m. Everything balances. Each equation was chosen to hold only one unknown.
Worked example: a stepladder
Legs AC and BC, each 2.5 m long, are pinned at the top C(0, 2.4) and stand on a smooth floor at A(−0.7, 0) and B(0.7, 0). A horizontal tie joins D(−0.35, 1.2) on AC to E(0.35, 1.2) on BC. An 800 N painter stands on leg BC at (0.175, 1.8); the ladder's weight is neglected. 1. Legs and tie form a triangle, so the ladder is rigid alone. A smooth floor gives vertical reactions only. Moments about A: \(1.4N_B = 0.875(800)\), so \(N_B = 500\) N and \(N_A = 300\) N. 2. The tie is a two-force member; assume tension \(T\). 3. Leg AC, moments about C: \(-0.7(300) + 1.2T = 0\), so \(T = 175\) N tension. 4. Leg AC force balance: pin C pushes AC with (−175, −300) N. 5. Check leg BC about C:
Planning the order of attack
Frames reward a minute of planning. Before writing equations, list the unknowns on each diagram and look for one with three or fewer, or for a single equation that contains just one unknown, such as moments about a pin where two unknowns meet. Solve that, then carry the result, with its correct sense, to the connected member. You rarely need every diagram: the chain only has to connect the known loads to the forces you want. If stuck, write all the equations and solve them simultaneously; for a determinate frame the solution is unique.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, cutting a frame through a multi-force member as if it were a truss, which exposes an unknown moment you cannot handle with the truss methods. Second, drawing x and y components at a pin attached to a two-force member, instead of one force along that member. Third, drawing a pin force in the same direction on both connected members. Fourth, putting a load that acts at a shared pin on both members at once; assign it to one member or to the pin. Fifth, counting whole-frame equations as extra independent equations on top of the member equations: they are not independent of them.
Key takeaways
A frame is a stationary structure with at least one multi-force member, which bends as well as carrying axial force. Take frames apart at their pins, never through multi-force members, and draw a free-body diagram for each member. Identify two-force members first: each gives one force along its own line. Show every pin force as an equal and opposite pair with the same labels. Two-force members give one equation, concurrent bodies two and general bodies three. Find reactions first if the frame is rigid alone; otherwise combine whole-frame and member equations, choosing each so it holds one unknown.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A stationary load-bearing structure with at least one multi-force member
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why can't the method of joints be used on a frame whose members are loaded at three or more points?
Question 2 of 5
In a frame, member BD is pinned at B and D with nothing else attached. How should its force be drawn on the member it connects to at B?
Question 3 of 5
A planar frame has two multi-force members and one two-force member. How many independent equilibrium equations does it give in total?
Question 4 of 5
In the stepladder worked example, what would happen on the smooth floor if the tie were removed?
Question 5 of 5
Bar BC of a frame pushes bar AC at pin C with components (−4.5, 1.5) kN. Using the same labels, what is drawn on BC at C?
