Statics › Section D · Moments and static equivalence › Topic D.4

Moments in 3D and about an axis

In three dimensions a moment can point in any direction, and the moment arm is almost never easy to see. The cross product computes the full moment about a point from coordinates alone, and a dot product then extracts the part that turns a body about a hinge or shaft.

Beyond the page

In a plane every moment points straight out of or into the page, and a curved arrow describes it completely. In space a moment can point in any direction, and finding the perpendicular distance from a point to a skew line of action by geometry is slow and error-prone. Engineers therefore compute three-dimensional moments with the vector cross product, introduced in "Cross products". It needs only coordinates and force components.

The cross-product moment

The moment of a force F about a point O is

\mathbf{M}_O = \mathbf{r} \times \mathbf{F}

where r is a position vector from O to any point on the force's line of action. Its magnitude is \(rF\sin\theta\), with \(\theta\) the angle between r and F, which equals \(Fd_\perp\); geometrically it is the area of the parallelogram with sides r and F. Its direction is perpendicular to both r and F, given by the right-hand rule. So one calculation gives how hard the force turns the body and the axis it turns it about.

Components of the moment

Evaluating the cross product as a determinant, with i, j, k on the top row, r in the middle and F at the bottom, gives

M_x = r_yF_z - r_zF_y
M_y = r_zF_x - r_xF_z
M_z = r_xF_y - r_yF_x

and the magnitude is \(\sqrt{M_x^2 + M_y^2 + M_z^2}\). Each component is the moment's turning tendency about one coordinate axis through O. For a force in the xy-plane, \(r_z\) and \(F_z\) are zero, so only \(M_z\) survives, and it is exactly the formula \(M_O = xF_y - yF_x\) from "Varignon's theorem".

Three rules for r × F

Keep r on the left: since \(\mathbf{F} \times \mathbf{r} = -(\mathbf{r} \times \mathbf{F})\), reversing the order flips the moment. Start r at the moment centre and end it on the line of action; a vector drawn the other way round has every sign wrong. Read all the components of r and F off one right-handed set of axes, so that i × j = k holds. Within those rules you have freedom: any point on the line of action will do, because sliding a force along its line does not change its moment. Choose the point with the most zero coordinates.

Worked example: a cable on a post

A cable runs from B(2, 3, 0) m to D(0, 0, 6) m with a tension of 1.4 kN, pulling B towards D. Find its moment about the origin O. 1. \(\mathbf{r}_{BD} = \langle -2, -3, 6 \rangle\) m, of length 7 m, so

\mathbf{F} = 0.2\langle -2, -3, 6 \rangle = \langle -0.4, -0.6, 1.2 \rangle\ \text{kN}

2. Take \(\mathbf{r}_{OB} = \langle 2, 3, 0 \rangle\) m. 3. \(M_x = 3(1.2) - 0 = 3.6\), \(M_y = 0 - 2(1.2) = -2.4\), \(M_z = 2(-0.6) - 3(-0.4) = 0\). So \(\mathbf{M}_O = \langle 3.6, -2.4, 0 \rangle\) kN·m, with magnitude 4.33 kN·m. 4. Check with \(\mathbf{r}_{OD} = \langle 0, 0, 6 \rangle\) m: \(M_x = 0 - 6(-0.6) = 3.6\) and \(M_y = 6(-0.4) - 0 = -2.4\), the same.

Reading the components

The components of a moment are not just bookkeeping. In the cable example, \(M_x = 3.6\) kN·m means the cable tends to turn the body about the x-axis, counterclockwise when viewed from the positive x end, while \(M_y = -2.4\) kN·m is a tendency to turn about the y-axis in the negative sense. The zero \(M_z\) has a physical reason: the cable's line passes through D, which lies on the z-axis, so the force has no moment arm about that axis. A cable anchored on a vertical post cannot twist the post about its own axis.

Moment about an axis

Often only part of a moment matters. A door turns only about its hinge line, and a shaft only about its own axis, so the useful quantity is the component of the moment along that axis. Let u be a unit vector along the axis, and r a vector from any point on the axis to any point on the force's line of action. Then the moment about the axis is the scalar projection, as in "Dot products and projections":

M_a = \mathbf{u} \cdot (\mathbf{r} \times \mathbf{F})

A positive value means the moment points along u by the right-hand rule; a negative value means the opposite sense.

Two ways to compute it

The two-step method first finds the moment about a point on the axis, \(\mathbf{r} \times \mathbf{F}\), then dots it with u. The second method, the scalar triple product, does both in one determinant whose rows are u, r and F:

M_a = \begin{vmatrix} u_x & u_y & u_z \\ r_x & r_y & r_z \\ F_x & F_y & F_z \end{vmatrix}

It contains no unit vectors i, j, k, so the result is a plain number. If you need the moment about the axis as a vector, multiply: \(\mathbf{M}_a = M_a\mathbf{u}\).

Worked example: a hinged hatch

A hatch is hinged along the line from O(0, 0, 0) to E(4, 0, 3) m. A force \(\mathbf{F} = \langle -100, 250, 80 \rangle\) N acts at P(2, 1, 0) m. Find its moment about the hinge line. 1. Unit vector along OE: \(\mathbf{u} = \langle 0.8, 0, 0.6 \rangle\), since OE is 5 m long. 2. With \(\mathbf{r} = \langle 2, 1, 0 \rangle\) m: \(\mathbf{r} \times \mathbf{F} = \langle 80, -160, 600 \rangle\) N·m. 3. \(M_a = 0.8(80) + 0 + 0.6(600) = 424\) N·m. 4. Positive, so it turns the hatch in the sense of u by the right-hand rule. 5. Check from E: \(\mathbf{r}_{EP} = \langle -2, 1, -3 \rangle\) m gives a different moment about E, yet the same 424 N·m about the line.

When the moment about an axis is zero

Two cases give no moment about an axis, however large the force. A force parallel to the axis has none: pulling along a door's hinge line never swings the door. A force whose line of action crosses the axis has none either, because r can be chosen as zero: pushing straight at the hinges does nothing. In a plane, the moment about a point is the same thing as the moment about an axis through that point perpendicular to the plane.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, computing F × r, which reverses the moment. Second, drawing r from the force to the moment centre. Third, dropping the minus signs in the determinant, especially in the j term. Fourth, using a vector along the axis that is not a unit vector, which scales the answer by its length. Fifth, taking r from a point that is not on the axis when finding a moment about an axis. Sixth, reporting the magnitude of r × F as the moment about a hinge when only its component along the hinge turns the body.

Key takeaways

In 3D, the moment about a point is M = r × F, with r from the point to any point on the line of action, kept in that order. Its components, from the determinant, are the turning tendencies about the three axes, and in a plane only Mz = xFy − yFx remains. The moment about an axis is the scalar u · (r × F), with u a unit vector along the axis and r from any point on it; the triple-product determinant gives it in one step, and its sign shows its sense along u. Forces parallel to an axis, or crossing it, have no moment about it.

Flashcards

Flashcard

M = r × F

The vector moment of a force about a point

r first, then F.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A force F = ⟨0, 0, −200⟩ N acts at the end of r = ⟨0.5, 0, 0⟩ m from point O. What is r × F?

Question 2 of 5

A student computes F × r instead of r × F for a moment. What happens to the result?

Question 3 of 5

A force acts parallel to a door's hinge line, some distance from it. What is its moment about the hinge axis?

Question 4 of 5

A force F = ⟨0, 0, 50⟩ N acts at the point (0, 2, 0) m. What is its moment about the x-axis?

Question 5 of 5

The moment of a force about a point on a hinge line is ⟨80, −160, 600⟩ N·m, and the hinge's unit vector is u = ⟨0.8, 0, 0.6⟩. What is the moment about the hinge line?

← Previous topicNext topic →