Statics › Section I · Friction › Topic I.2
Slipping versus tipping
Push a tall object hard enough and it gives way in one of two ways: it slides along the floor or it tips over an edge. Statics predicts which comes first, and that prediction is how engineers make bookcases, vending machines and loaded vehicles safe.
Two ways to give way
Imagine pushing a filing cabinet with a slowly increasing horizontal force. At first nothing happens: static friction grows to match the push, and the normal force shifts toward the front edge, as the topic "Dry friction" showed. Eventually one of two limits is reached. Either friction reaches its ceiling and the cabinet slides, or the push lifts the back of the cabinet and it rotates about its front bottom edge. These are two different impending motions with different free-body diagrams. The method is to find the push that causes each and compare: the smaller push is the one that actually happens.
The slipping check
To find the push that causes slipping, assume the body is on the point of sliding while still upright. Friction is then at its limit, \(F = \mu_s N\), and the normal force acts at some unknown point under the body. For a horizontal push \(P\) on a level floor, the force equations give \(N = W\) and \(P = F\), so
The height of the push does not appear: it changes where the normal force acts, not how much friction is available. The moment equation only locates \(N\), and that point must lie within the base for the slipping answer to be valid.
The tipping check
To find the push that causes tipping, assume the body is about to rotate about its leading bottom edge. Its trailing edge is just lifting, so the whole normal force, and the friction, act at the leading edge. Taking moments about that edge removes both of them:
Here \(h\) is the height of the push above the floor and \(d\) is the horizontal distance from the centre of gravity to the tipping edge. For a uniform box of base width \(b\), \(d = b/2\). At tipping, friction is static but not impending: it equals \(P\), which is less than \(\mu_s N\) whenever tipping is the mode that occurs.
Compare and decide
With both limits found, compare them with the actual push. If the push is below both, the body stays put. If it reaches the smaller limit first, that motion begins: slipping if \(P_{slip}\) is smaller, tipping if \(P_{tip}\) is smaller. In design language, the mode that occurs at the smaller load is the controlling failure mode. The same habit runs through all engineering: list every way a part can fail, compute the load for each, and design for the lowest.
Watching the normal force move
Before either limit, you can locate the normal force. Take moments about the point on the floor directly below the centre of gravity. Friction acts along the floor, so it has no moment about that point; the weight passes through it too. That leaves the push and the normal force: \(P h = W x\), so the normal force sits a distance \(x = Ph/W\) ahead of the centre of gravity. When \(x\) reaches \(d\), the normal force is at the edge and cannot move further, which is exactly the tipping condition. A wide base gives a large \(d\), so the normal force has further to travel.
Worked example: a tall bookcase
A uniform bookcase has mass 70 kg, a base 0.50 m deep in the direction of the push and a height of 2.0 m. It stands on a floor with \(\mu_s = 0.45\) and is pushed horizontally 1.6 m above the floor. Which happens first? 1. Weight: \(W = 70 \times 9.81 = 686.7\) N. 2. Slipping: \(P_{slip} = 0.45 \times 686.7 = 309.0\) N. 3. Tipping, with \(d = 0.25\) m: \(P_{tip} = 686.7 \times 0.25 / 1.6 = 107.3\) N. 4. Since 107.3 N is far below 309.0 N, the bookcase tips first, at about 107 N. 5. Check with the normal force: at an 80 N push, \(x = 80 \times 1.6/686.7 = 0.19\) m, still inside the 0.25 m half-depth, so it stands, as expected below 107 N. A push as small as 107 N tips it, which is why tall bookcases are anchored to the wall with anti-tip straps.
Push height and the critical height
Because only the tipping force depends on \(h\), there is a critical height where the two forces are equal. Setting \(\mu_s W = W d/h\) gives
which does not depend on the weight. Push below \(h^*\) and the body slides first; push above it and the body tips first. For the bookcase, \(h^* = 0.25/0.45 = 0.56\) m. Pushed at 0.40 m, it would need \(686.7 \times 0.25/0.40 = 429\) N to tip, more than the 309 N needed to slide, so it slides. This is why removal crews push tall furniture low down, and why a slippery floor, with a small \(\mu_s\), favours sliding.
Slipping or tipping on a slope
A box resting on a surface that is slowly tilted faces the same two limits, with no push at all. It slips when the tilt reaches the friction angle, \(\tan\theta = \mu_s\). It tips when the vertical line through its centre of gravity passes the downhill bottom edge. For a uniform box of width \(b\) along the slope and height \(h\), the centre of gravity is at half-width and half-height, so tipping begins when
Whichever condition gives the smaller angle occurs first. Neither depends on the weight, so a full crate and an empty one of the same shape and material behave the same way.
Worked example: a crate on a tipping bed
A uniform crate 1.20 m tall stands upright on the bed of a tipper truck, with its 0.60 m base length running up and down the slope and \(\mu_s = 0.60\) between crate and bed. The bed is raised slowly. Does the crate slide or topple, and at what angle? 1. Slipping angle: \(\theta = \tan^{-1} 0.60 = 31.0^\circ\). 2. Tipping angle: \(\tan\theta = 0.60/1.20 = 0.50\), so \(\theta = 26.6^\circ\). 3. The tipping angle is smaller, so the crate topples at about 26.6° before it can slide. 4. Check: at 26.6°, \(\tan\theta = 0.50 < 0.60\), so friction still holds. Laying the crate on its side, 1.20 m along the slope and 0.60 m tall, raises the tipping angle to 63.4°, so it would slide at 31.0° instead.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, putting the normal force under the centre of gravity in the tipping check; at tipping it acts at the edge. Second, setting \(F = \mu_s N\) in the tipping check. Friction is at its limit only if the body is also slipping. Third, thinking the push height affects the slipping force; it affects only tipping. Fourth, using the full base width instead of the distance from the centre of gravity to the edge, which doubles the tipping force for a uniform box. Fifth, stopping after one check. A body can pass the slipping check and still fall over.
Key takeaways
A pushed body can slip or tip; find the push for each and the smaller one controls. For a horizontal push on a level floor, slipping needs P = μs W, whatever the push height. Tipping happens when the normal force reaches the edge; moments about that edge give P h = W d, with friction below its limit. The normal force sits Ph/W ahead of the centre of gravity until then. The critical push height is d/μs: push lower to slide, higher to tip. On a tilting surface a uniform box slips when tan θ = μs and tips when tan θ = b/h, and the smaller angle wins.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Find the push for each; the smaller one happens first
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A uniform cabinet weighing 900 N has a base 0.80 m wide and stands on a floor with μs = 0.35. It is pushed horizontally 1.2 m above the floor. What happens first as the push grows?
Question 2 of 5
A uniform crate with a base 0.90 m wide stands on a floor with μs = 0.50. Below what push height will a horizontal push make it slide rather than tip?
Question 3 of 5
A uniform box 0.40 m wide along a slope and 1.0 m tall rests on a board with μs = 0.50. The board is slowly tilted. What happens first?
Question 4 of 5
A pushed box is on the point of tipping and has not started to slip. Which describes the floor's forces on it?
Question 5 of 5
A machine weighing 2,000 N has its centre of gravity 0.30 m horizontally from the front edge it could tip about. It stands on a floor with μs = 0.25 and is pushed horizontally 1.5 m above the floor. What push starts motion?
