Statics › Section E · Rigid body equilibrium › Topic E.6
Stability and determinacy
Before solving for reactions, ask two questions: will the supports actually hold the body still, and can statics alone find every reaction? Counting unknowns answers part of each, and checking how the supports are arranged answers the rest.
Two questions before solving
Every equilibrium problem so far has had exactly three unknown reactions, well placed, on a planar body. Real structures are not always so tidy. A shelf might sit on too few supports, a bridge beam on more than it strictly needs, or a bracket on supports that line up badly. Two separate questions sort these cases out. Is the body stable, meaning its supports prevent every possible motion? And is it determinate, meaning the equilibrium equations alone can find every reaction? A problem is solvable by statics only when the answer to both is yes.
Determinate and indeterminate
A body is statically determinate when its reactions can all be found from the equilibrium equations, and statically indeterminate when they cannot. The count comes first. A planar body gives three independent equations and a body in space gives six, one per degree of freedom. Call the number of unknown reaction components \(r\) and the number of independent equations \(n\). If a stable body has \(r > n\), it is indeterminate, and its degree of indeterminacy is \(r - n\): the number of extra equations it would need. Those extra equations come from how the body and its supports deform, which mechanics of materials courses cover.
Stable and unstable
A body is stable when its supports stop it translating and rotating in every direction. It is unstable if any motion is left unblocked, even when it happens to be at rest. Stability depends on the supports alone, not on the loads. A beam resting on two rollers with only vertical loads stays put, and its equations even balance, but the slightest sideways push slides it off, because nothing resists horizontal force. So it is unstable. With \(r < n\), a body is always unstable: there are not enough restraints to block every degree of freedom. With \(r \ge n\), it may or may not be stable, depending on the arrangement.
Two ways the count can lie
Three reactions on a planar body are necessary but not sufficient. They fail in two arrangements, called improper constraints. First, all reactions parallel: three vertical rollers can carry vertical loads but cannot resist any horizontal force, so the body can translate. Second, all reaction lines passing through one point: a pin at A plus a roller whose line of action also passes through A cannot resist any moment about A, so the body can rotate about it. Parallel lines can be thought of as meeting at a point infinitely far away, so both failures are really the same failure: concurrent reactions.
The three checks
For a planar body, run these checks in order, quickest first. 1. Count the reaction components: fewer than 3 means unstable; more than 3 means indeterminate if the body proves stable. 2. Are all the reaction forces parallel? If so, the body is unstable in translation. 3. Do all the reaction lines of action meet at one point? If so, it is unstable in rotation about that point. With exactly 3 reactions that pass checks 2 and 3, the body is stable and determinate. With more than 3, it is stable if some set of 3 of its reactions passes both checks. In matrix terms, the 3-row coefficient matrix of the reactions in the equilibrium equations must have rank 3; with exactly 3 reactions it is square and non-singular.
Worked example: classifying supports
Classify six horizontal beams, each 6 m long. 1. Pin at the left end, vertical roller at the right: \(r = 3\), not parallel, not concurrent, so stable and determinate. 2. Vertical rollers at both ends: \(r = 2 < 3\), unstable; it can slide sideways. 3. Pin at the left end and a horizontal link at the right end, lying along the beam: \(r = 3\), but the link's line passes through the pin, so it can rotate about the pin: unstable. 4. Vertical rollers at both ends and the middle: \(r = 3\) but all parallel, unstable. 5. Pin at the left end, vertical rollers at the middle and right end: \(r = 4\), stable, indeterminate to degree 1. 6. Pins at both ends: \(r = 4\), stable, indeterminate to degree 1.
Worked example: a propped cantilever
A 6 m beam is built into a wall at A and propped on a roller at its far end B. A 12 kN load acts at its midpoint. 1. Unknowns: \(A_x\), \(A_y\), \(M_A\) and \(B\), so \(r = 4\) against 3 equations. 2. \(\sum F_x = 0\) gives \(A_x = 0\). 3. \(\sum F_y = 0\) gives \(A_y = 12 - B\). 4. Moments about A give \(M_A = 36 - 6B\). 5. Every value of \(B\) satisfies all three: \(B = 0\) is a plain cantilever, \(B = 6\) kN removes the wall moment entirely. Statics cannot choose. Accounting for the beam's bending, mechanics of materials gives \(B = 3.75\) kN, which is 5/16 of the load, so \(A_y = 8.25\) kN and \(M_A = 13.5\) kN·m.
Why build indeterminate structures
Indeterminacy is not a design fault. Extra supports make a structure redundant: if one support or member fails, the rest can still carry the load instead of collapsing. Indeterminate structures are also stiffer, so they deflect less; the propped cantilever's wall moment is less than half that of a plain cantilever's 36 kN·m. The price is that the reactions depend on stiffness, settlement and temperature. A beam pinned at both ends cannot expand freely when it warms, so it pushes on its supports. That is one reason bridge girders often sit on a pin at one end and a roller at the other.
Stability in 3D
In space the count is against six equations: fewer than six reactions means at least one motion is unblocked. Arrangements can fail here too. If every reaction line crosses one common line, nothing resists rotation about that line; if every reaction is parallel to one plane, nothing resists translation perpendicular to it. The braced boom in "3D rigid body equilibrium" is an example of the first: five reactions, all passing through the boom's own axis, so it is free to spin about that axis. Its equilibrium still holds because no load tries to spin it. Such a body is called partially constrained.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming exactly three reactions guarantees a solvable problem; always check for parallel or concurrent reactions. Second, judging stability from the loads in one case: a body that balances under today's load can still be unstable. Third, calling an unstable body indeterminate, or the reverse: too few or badly arranged restraints mean motion, while too many mean extra unknowns. Fourth, forcing a fourth unknown out of a planar body by writing more moment equations; they only repeat information. Fifth, forgetting that a fixed support counts as three reactions, not one.
Key takeaways
A body is stable when its supports block every motion, whatever the load, and determinate when the equilibrium equations find every reaction. Compare the number of reactions \(r\) with the equations available: 3 for a planar body, 6 in space. Fewer means unstable. Exactly 3 in 2D means stable and determinate only if the reactions are neither all parallel nor all concurrent. More means indeterminate to degree \(r - 3\) if the body is stable. Indeterminate structures add redundancy and stiffness, but need deformation to solve.
Flashcards
Flashcard
All reactions found from the equilibrium equations alone
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A horizontal beam rests on a pin at its left end and on two vertical rollers. How is it classified?
Question 2 of 5
A beam is pinned at A and held at B by a link whose line of action passes through A. What is wrong?
Question 3 of 5
A beam on two rollers carries only vertical loads and is not moving. Which statement is true?
Question 4 of 5
A beam has three vertical rollers and no other supports. How is it classified?
Question 5 of 5
Why can statics alone not find the reactions on a propped cantilever, built in at one end and on a roller at the other?
