US History › Section K · Progressives and empire › Topic K.8
Big Stick and Dollar Diplomacy
Theodore Roosevelt and William Howard Taft used naval power, canal building, debt and diplomacy to make the United States the dominant power in the Caribbean and a major player in East Asia. Their methods differed, but both left a legacy of intervention that Latin Americans long resented.
Speak softly and carry a big stick
Roosevelt's favourite motto, which he called a West African proverb, advised speaking softly while holding a big stick. The stick was military power, above all the growing US Navy. Roosevelt believed that a credible threat of force often made force unnecessary, and that great nations had a duty to keep order among weaker ones. In practice his policy combined hard bargaining, shows of strength and, at times, open intervention, especially in the Caribbean.
Choosing a canal route
Mahan and Roosevelt saw a Central American canal as essential for moving the fleet between oceans. A French company led by Ferdinand de Lesseps had tried to dig across Panama in the 1880s and failed, defeated by landslides, money troubles and disease that killed an estimated 20,000 or more workers. In 1901 Britain gave up its claim to share control of any canal. In 1902 Congress chose Panama over a rival route through Nicaragua and agreed to buy the French company's assets for $40 million. Panama was then a province of Colombia, and in 1903 the Colombian Senate rejected the Hay-Herrán Treaty, which offered $10 million and $250,000 a year for a canal zone.
Panama breaks away
Panamanian separatists, who had rebelled against Colombia several times before, prepared a revolt with the help of Philippe Bunau-Varilla, a French engineer with a stake in the old canal company. On 3 November 1903 they declared independence. The US gunboat Nashville, already offshore, prevented Colombian troops from moving to crush the rising, and the United States recognised Panama within days. Bunau-Varilla, acting as Panama's envoy, then signed a treaty granting the United States a zone ten miles wide in perpetuity for the same payments Colombia had refused. No Panamanian signed it. Roosevelt later boasted, "I took the Isthmus"; in 1921 the United States paid Colombia $25 million.
Worked example: judging the Panama episode
1. Panamanian view: many Panamanians had long wanted independence from distant Bogotá, so the revolt had real local roots. 2. Colombian view: a great power had helped dismember the country after a negotiation failed, and Colombia received nothing until 1921. 3. Treaty evidence: a foreign businessman, not a Panamanian, signed away a zone in perpetuity, which Panamanians resented for decades. 4. Roosevelt's view: he argued the canal served civilisation and that Colombia had tried to extract more money. 5. Later judgement: the 1977 treaties returned the canal to Panama, which took full control at the end of 1999. 6. Conclusion: Panama gained independence, but on terms that made it a US protectorate for decades.
Building the canal
Construction ran from 1904 to 1914, and sanitation came first. Building on the discovery, confirmed by Walter Reed's commission in Cuba in 1900 following the Cuban doctor Carlos Finlay's theory, that mosquitoes spread yellow fever, the medical officer William Gorgas drained standing water, fumigated buildings and screened windows; yellow fever was gone from the zone by about 1906, and malaria fell sharply. Engineers chose locks rather than a sea-level channel. Most labourers came from Barbados and other Caribbean islands and were paid less, in silver, on the "silver roll", while white Americans were paid in gold on the "gold roll". About 5,600 deaths were recorded. The canal opened in August 1914.
The Roosevelt Corollary
The Monroe Doctrine of 1823 had warned Europe against new colonies in the Americas. In 1902 Britain, Germany and Italy blockaded Venezuela to collect unpaid debts, and soon the Dominican Republic faced similar threats. Roosevelt feared European footholds near the canal. In his annual message of December 1904 he announced that "chronic wrongdoing" by a nation in the hemisphere might force the United States to exercise "an international police power". This Roosevelt Corollary turned a warning against European intervention into a claim that the United States itself could intervene. In 1905 US officials took over the collection of Dominican customs revenue to pay its creditors.
Balancing power in East Asia
In Asia, where the navy was thinner, Roosevelt relied on balance rather than force. In February 1904 Japan attacked Russian forces at Port Arthur, and it went on to win at sea and on land. Roosevelt at first welcomed Japan's success, but he did not want either power to dominate. In 1905 he brought both sides to Portsmouth, New Hampshire, where they signed a peace treaty. Japan won control of Korea, Russia's lease at Port Arthur, a southern Manchurian railway and the south of Sakhalin, but no cash indemnity, which provoked riots in Tokyo. Roosevelt won the Nobel Peace Prize in 1906, the first American to do so.
Japan, race and the Great White Fleet
In 1906 San Francisco ordered Japanese pupils into a segregated school, angering Japan. Roosevelt pressed the city to back down, and in the Gentlemen's Agreement of 1907 and 1908 Japan agreed to stop issuing passports to labourers bound for the United States. He also showed the stick: from December 1907 to February 1909, sixteen battleships painted white sailed around the world, including a friendly visit to Japan. In the Root-Takahira Agreement of 1908, the two countries pledged to respect each other's Pacific possessions and the Open Door in China.
Taft's dollar diplomacy
Taft and his secretary of state, Philander Knox, wanted to use investment rather than troops. Taft described the policy as "substituting dollars for bullets". American banks would lend to unstable Caribbean and Central American governments to pay off European creditors, with US officials running customs houses to ensure repayment. In China, Knox pushed American banks into international railway loans and in 1909 proposed internationalising Manchuria's railways, but Japan and Russia rejected the plan. In 1912 the Senate added the Lodge Corollary, warning against foreign companies, implicitly Japanese ones, acquiring strategic sites in the Americas.
Worked example: dollar diplomacy in Nicaragua
1. Starting point: in 1909 the United States backed a revolt that drove out Nicaragua's nationalist president, José Santos Zelaya. 2. Dollars: the new government accepted loans from New York bankers, who gained control of its customs revenue, national bank and railway. 3. Resistance: in 1912 Nicaraguans rose against the US-backed president, Adolfo Díaz. 4. Bullets after all: Taft sent about 2,700 Marines to crush the revolt. 5. Aftermath: Marines stayed, with one short break, until 1933, and fought a long guerrilla war led by Augusto Sandino in its final years. 6. Conclusion: dollar diplomacy depended on force when local people resisted, and it bred lasting anti-American feeling.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, confusing the Monroe Doctrine, which warned Europe away, with the Roosevelt Corollary, which claimed a US right to intervene. Second, thinking the United States simply bought Panama from Colombia; Colombia rejected the treaty, and the canal followed a US-backed secession. Third, crediting Walter Reed alone; Carlos Finlay proposed the mosquito theory. Fourth, assuming dollar diplomacy avoided force; Nicaragua shows otherwise. Fifth, forgetting that Roosevelt's Asian policy relied on balancing Japan and Russia, not on the big stick alone.
Key takeaways
Roosevelt's big stick backed diplomacy with naval power. After Colombia rejected a canal treaty, the United States helped Panama secede in 1903 and gained a canal zone; sanitation work made construction possible, and the canal opened in 1914. The Roosevelt Corollary of 1904 claimed a US police power in the hemisphere, first used in the Dominican Republic. In Asia, Roosevelt mediated the 1905 Treaty of Portsmouth, eased tension with Japan and sent the Great White Fleet. Taft's dollar diplomacy used loans and customs control, but in Nicaragua it led to years of Marine occupation.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Roosevelt's policy of backing diplomacy with the threat of force
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
How did the Roosevelt Corollary change the meaning of the Monroe Doctrine?
Question 2 of 5
What happened after the Colombian Senate rejected the Hay-Herrán Treaty in 1903?
Question 3 of 5
Why was sanitation work so important to building the Panama Canal?
Question 4 of 5
What role did Roosevelt play in the Russo-Japanese War?
Question 5 of 5
What does the Nicaraguan case show about dollar diplomacy?
