US History › Section K · Progressives and empire › Topic K.7
Economic imperialism in East Asia
In China the United States pursued empire by trade rather than by conquest, asking rival powers to keep the door open to American goods. The Open Door policy reveals both the reach and the limits of American power around 1900, and how Chinese people resisted foreign domination.
The lure of the China market
American merchants had traded with China since 1784, when the ship Empress of China sailed to Guangzhou. By the 1890s many business leaders dreamed of selling textiles, kerosene and machinery to China's population of roughly 400 million. The dream outran reality: China bought only a small share of US exports, a few percent at most. But the idea of a vast future market shaped policy. With the Philippines newly in hand, the United States had a base near Asia, but no zone in China itself, just as other powers were dividing the country.
A weakened Qing empire
China's Qing dynasty had been forced open by war. In the Opium Wars of 1839 to 1842 and 1856 to 1860, Britain and later France compelled China to legalise the opium trade, open treaty ports and grant foreigners special rights. The Treaty of Nanjing of 1842 ceded Hong Kong to Britain. The United States, without fighting, signed the Treaty of Wangxia in 1844, gaining the same trading privileges and the right of Americans in China to be tried in American, not Chinese, courts. Chinese reformers called these the unequal treaties. The vast Taiping rebellion of 1850 to 1864 weakened the dynasty further.
The scramble for concessions
China's defeat by a modernised Japan in the war of 1894 to 1895 exposed its weakness. Japan took Taiwan and ended Chinese influence over Korea. In 1897 Germany used the killing of two German missionaries as a pretext to seize Jiaozhou Bay in Shandong, then took a 99-year lease on it. In 1898 Russia leased Port Arthur and extended its railway rights across Manchuria, Britain leased Weihaiwei and land beside Hong Kong, and France leased a port in the south. Each power was building a sphere of influence, a region where it claimed priority for its railways, mines and trade, and Americans feared they would be shut out.
Why not take a sphere?
The United States faced a dilemma. It wanted access to all of China but had no army there, and annexing Chinese territory would have outraged anti-imperialists already fighting the war in the Philippines. Secretary of State John Hay, advised by the China expert William Rockhill, who drew on ideas from Alfred Hippisley, a British official in China's customs service, chose a diplomatic route. Rather than claim a zone, Hay would ask the other powers to promise equal commercial treatment inside the zones they already held. If trade were open, efficient American industry expected to compete well.
The first Open Door note
In September 1899 Hay sent a circular note, first to Britain, Germany and Russia and then to Japan, Italy and France. He asked each power to agree that, within its sphere, it would not interfere with treaty ports or the trade of other nations; that China's own tariff would apply equally to all goods and be collected by Chinese officials; and that harbour dues and railway charges would not favour its own citizens. The replies were evasive, and Russia's was the vaguest. Hay nevertheless announced in March 1900 that the powers had accepted, calling their assent "final and definitive". It was a bold bluff.
Worked example: reading the first note
1. What it asked: equal tariffs, harbour dues and railway rates for all foreign traders within each sphere. 2. What it did not ask: it did not demand that spheres be abolished, and it accepted the leases already taken. 3. Who was absent: China was not a party to the exchange, though its territory was the subject. 4. Enforcement: the United States had no means to compel compliance; the policy depended on the powers' own rivalries and on publicity. 5. Beneficiary: equal access favoured the most competitive exporter, which Americans believed they were. 6. Conclusion: the note sought open trade, not Chinese sovereignty, and its power was largely rhetorical.
Chinese grievances
Many Chinese resented the foreign presence. Missionaries won converts, but some used treaty protections to intervene in local disputes on behalf of Chinese Christians, causing anger. Foreign goods undercut local crafts, and drought and floods in northern China brought famine. Americans added their own insult. The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, an earlier topic, barred Chinese labourers from entering the United States; Congress renewed it in 1892 and extended it again in the early 1900s with no end date. Chinese merchants and students admitted under the law often faced humiliating treatment by US immigration officials.
The Boxer Uprising
In 1899 a movement the foreign press called the Boxers, from its members' martial arts, spread across northern China. Calling itself the Righteous and Harmonious Fists, it attacked foreign missionaries and, above all, Chinese Christians, killing tens of thousands of them, along with about 200 foreign missionaries and family members. In June 1900 the Qing court declared war on the foreign powers, and Boxers and imperial troops besieged the foreign legations in Beijing for about 55 days. An international force of roughly 20,000 soldiers from eight nations, including about 2,500 Americans sent from the Philippines, relieved the legations in August. Foreign troops then looted Beijing and carried out reprisals.
The second note and the Boxer Protocol
During the crisis, in July 1900, Hay sent a second circular declaring that US policy was to preserve China's "territorial and administrative entity", meaning China should not be partitioned. The Boxer Protocol of 1901 forced China to pay the powers an enormous indemnity of 450 million taels over 39 years. The US share later proved larger than American losses, and from 1908 the United States returned part of it to fund Chinese students in American universities, a programme that also helped found Tsinghua University. The Open Door remained a stated principle of US policy for decades.
Worked example: the 1905 boycott
1. Cause: in 1904 China declined to renew an 1894 treaty accepting exclusion, Congress kept exclusion in force by law, and abuses of admitted Chinese continued. 2. Action: in 1905 merchants and students in Shanghai launched a boycott of American goods, which spread to Guangzhou, other cities and overseas Chinese communities. 3. Pressure: American exporters of cotton cloth and kerosene felt the loss, and President Roosevelt ordered immigration officials to treat admitted Chinese with more courtesy. 4. Limits: the Qing government, fearing unrest, suppressed the boycott, and exclusion remained until 1943. 5. Conclusion: the boycott was an early sign of modern Chinese nationalism and showed the Open Door could swing both ways.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking the Open Door notes abolished spheres of influence; the first note accepted them and asked only for equal trade within them. Second, assuming the other powers fully agreed; their replies were evasive, and Hay declared acceptance anyway. Third, attributing the notes' protection of China's territory to the 1899 note; that came in the second note of 1900. Fourth, picturing the Boxers as attacking only foreigners; most of their victims were Chinese Christians. Fifth, assuming China was a passive object of policy; the 1905 boycott shows Chinese people pushing back.
Key takeaways
Americans dreamed of a huge China market, though China bought only a small share of US exports. After Japan defeated China in 1895, European powers and Japan carved out spheres of influence. In 1899 Hay's first Open Door note asked for equal trading rights within those spheres, and he declared the evasive replies an acceptance. The Boxer Uprising of 1899 to 1901 brought an international intervention, including US troops, and Hay's second note in 1900 called for preserving China's territory. Chinese resentment of exclusion produced the 1905 boycott of American goods.
Flashcards
Flashcard
American dream of selling to China's huge population
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did Hay's first Open Door note of 1899 ask the other powers to do?
Question 2 of 5
Why did the United States choose diplomacy rather than seizing a sphere of influence in China?
Question 3 of 5
Who were the main victims of the Boxers' attacks?
Question 4 of 5
How did the second Open Door note of 1900 differ from the first?
Question 5 of 5
What prompted the Chinese boycott of American goods in 1905?
