US History › Section G · Reform and a decade of crisis › Topic G.8
John Brown and the election of 1860
In 1859 John Brown tried to start a war against slavery from a federal armoury in Virginia. A year later the election of Abraham Lincoln, carried by northern votes alone, convinced the Deep South to leave the Union.
A country losing its middle ground
By 1859 compromise seemed out of reach. Republicans had won the most seats in the House in the 1858 elections, and a bitter fight over choosing its Speaker lasted about two months into 1860. Southern leaders disagreed about how to respond. Radical secessionists, known as fire-eaters, such as Robert Barnwell Rhett of South Carolina and William Lowndes Yancey of Alabama, openly urged the South to leave the Union. Others, such as Senator Jefferson Davis of Mississippi, demanded instead a federal slave code: national laws to protect slavery in every territory. Into this atmosphere came a raid that confirmed the South's worst fears.
John Brown
John Brown, born in Connecticut in 1800, failed at a string of businesses in Ohio, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts and New York. A stern Calvinist, he believed God had called him to destroy slavery, and he had lived among and worked with free Black communities, unusual for a white man of his time. In Kansas in 1856 he had led the Pottawatomie killings. He then planned a larger blow: to seize weapons, arm enslaved people and create a refuge in the Appalachian Mountains. Six northern supporters, mostly well-off reformers, later called the Secret Six, secretly gave him money. Frederick Douglass heard the plan and refused to join, judging it suicidal.
The raid on Harpers Ferry
On the night of 16 October 1859 Brown led 21 men, 16 white and 5 Black, into Harpers Ferry, Virginia, a town with a federal armoury and arsenal. They seized the buildings and took hostages, including Lewis Washington, a great-grandnephew of George Washington. But no general uprising followed: few enslaved people lived nearby, none had been told in advance, and only a handful took part. Local militia trapped the raiders in the armoury's engine house. On 18 October United States Marines commanded by Colonel Robert E. Lee broke in. Ten raiders, including two of Brown's sons, were killed or fatally wounded, and Brown was wounded and captured.
Trial and execution
Virginia tried Brown quickly for treason against the state, murder and conspiring with enslaved people to rebel. He was convicted and hanged at Charles Town on 2 December 1859. At his trial he spoke calmly, insisting he had acted for people held in bondage, and his dignity impressed many northern newspaper readers. Several of his men, including the Black raiders John Copeland and Shields Green, were also hanged. On the morning of his death, Brown handed a guard a short written note, which became one of the most quoted documents of the crisis.
Worked example: Brown's last note
Brown wrote that "the crimes of this guilty, land: will never be purged away; but with Blood." (The odd punctuation is his own.) 1. Source: a handwritten note given to a guard on 2 December 1859, the day of his execution. 2. Meaning: slavery was a national sin so deep that only bloodshed could cleanse it. 3. Context: compromise had failed repeatedly, and his own raid had failed. 4. Tone: religious and prophetic, echoing the Bible's language of sin and sacrifice. 5. Hindsight: the Civil War began less than eighteen months later, so the note reads like a prophecy. 6. Caution: Brown predicted violence in general, not the specific war that came, so avoid reading later events back into the source.
Two reactions to one man
In the North, many people who had never supported violence began to see Brown as a martyr. Church bells rang on the day of his execution in some northern towns, and Henry David Thoreau defended him in public lectures. Yet most Republican leaders, including Lincoln, condemned the raid as lawless, and many northerners were shocked by it. In the South, the raid seemed proof of a northern plot to set off rebellions by enslaved people. Southern states strengthened their militias and tightened controls on enslaved people and visiting northerners.
The Democrats split
In April 1860 the Democratic convention met at Charleston, South Carolina. Northern delegates, a majority, refused to adopt a federal slave code for the territories, and delegates from several Deep South states walked out. The party tried again at Baltimore in June and broke apart. Northern Democrats nominated Stephen Douglas on a platform of popular sovereignty, and southern Democrats nominated Vice President John C. Breckinridge of Kentucky, demanding federal protection of slavery in the territories. Former Whigs from the upper South and border states formed the Constitutional Union Party and nominated John Bell of Tennessee, promising to defend the Constitution and the Union while saying little about slavery.
The Republicans choose Lincoln
The Republicans met in Chicago in May 1860. William Seward of New York was the favourite, but his talk of a higher law and an irrepressible conflict made him seem too radical to win swing states. Lincoln, a moderate from Illinois, a state Republicans needed, won on the third ballot. The platform opposed slavery in the territories but promised not to interfere with it in the states. It also offered economic measures with wide northern appeal: a protective tariff, free western homesteads for settlers, and federal support for a railway to the Pacific. Following custom, Lincoln did not campaign in person.
The result and secession
In November Lincoln won about 40 percent of the popular vote but 180 of the 303 electoral votes, a clear majority, by carrying every free state except part of New Jersey. He was not even on the ballot in ten southern states. Breckinridge carried most of the slave states, Bell won Virginia, Kentucky and Tennessee, and Douglas, second in the popular vote, won only Missouri and part of New Jersey. To many white southerners, a president elected with no southern support threatened slavery's future. On 20 December 1860 South Carolina seceded, and by 1 February 1861 six more Deep South states had followed.
Worked example: reading the 1860 results
Analyse why the 1860 result alarmed the South. 1. Geography: Lincoln's 180 electoral votes all came from free states, so a president could now be elected by one section alone. 2. Population: the free states held a majority of the population, so this pattern could repeat. 3. Split opposition: the Democratic split helped Lincoln, but historians calculate that he would most likely still have won the electoral college even if his opponents' votes had been combined. 4. Southern fear: secessionists argued that a hostile federal government would block slavery's growth and could eventually threaten it in the states. 5. Conclusion: the election showed that the South had lost national power through ordinary democratic means.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, Harpers Ferry did not spark a slave uprising; nearby enslaved people were not told, and only a handful joined. Second, Brown was hanged by Virginia, not by the federal government, and for treason against Virginia. Third, most Republicans, including Lincoln, condemned the raid. Fourth, Lincoln won only about 40 percent of the popular vote, though a majority of electoral votes. Fifth, Lincoln's platform did not promise to abolish slavery in the states; it promised to stop slavery's spread.
Key takeaways
By 1859 fire-eaters urged secession and others, such as Jefferson Davis, demanded a federal slave code. John Brown's raid on Harpers Ferry in October 1859 failed, but his execution made him a martyr to many northerners and a symbol of northern menace to the South. In 1860 the Democrats split between Douglas and Breckinridge, the Constitutional Union Party ran Bell, and the Republicans nominated Lincoln on a platform against slavery's expansion. Lincoln won with about 40 percent of the vote and every free state's support, and South Carolina led the Deep South out of the Union.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Radical southern secessionists
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did John Brown hope to achieve at Harpers Ferry?
Question 2 of 5
Why did the Harpers Ferry raid fail to start an uprising?
Question 3 of 5
Why did the Democratic Party split in 1860?
Question 4 of 5
What share of the popular vote did Lincoln win in 1860?
Question 5 of 5
Which state was the first to secede after Lincoln's election?
