US History › Section H · Civil War and Reconstruction › Topic H.6
Congress and the remaking of the South
In 1865 and 1866, Southern governments tried to rebuild something close to slavery under another name, and Congress answered with new federal protections. The Fourteenth Amendment that came out of this struggle still shapes American law on citizenship and equal rights.
Freedom and its opponents
Freed people knew what they wanted from freedom: to keep their families together, to work for wages they could bargain over, to own land, to learn to read and to take part in government. Many white Southerners, defeated but unreconciled, wanted the opposite: a Black labour force that stayed on the plantations, worked under white control and had no political power. Between these two visions stood the federal government, divided between a president who thought Reconstruction was finished and a Congress that increasingly believed it had barely begun. The years 1865 and 1866 decided which branch would lead.
The Freedmen's Bureau
Congress created the Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen, and Abandoned Lands, known as the Freedmen's Bureau, in March 1865, as a temporary agency under the War Department, led by General Oliver O. Howard. It handed out millions of food rations to Black and white Southerners, ran hospitals, helped people trace relatives and register marriages, and supervised labour contracts so that freed workers were paid. Its local agents also heard disputes in which Southern courts would not treat Black people fairly. But it was small, with never more than about 900 agents across the South, and many agents pressed freed people to sign contracts with their former owners.
A hunger for schools
Education was one of the bureau's lasting successes, and freed people drove it. Black communities raised money, donated land and built schoolhouses, often before any outside help arrived; adults sat beside children to learn to read. The bureau worked with Northern missionary societies such as the American Missionary Association, whose teachers, many of them women, Black and white, came south despite threats and violence. Together they supported thousands of schools. Colleges founded in these years, such as Fisk University in 1866, Howard University in 1867 and Hampton Institute in 1868, became pillars of Black higher education.
The Black Codes
In late 1865, the new Southern legislatures elected under Johnson's plan passed Black Codes, laws that applied only to Black people. They recognised a few rights, such as marrying and owning some property, but their main purpose was to control labour. Black workers had to sign yearly contracts and could be arrested for leaving before the contract ended. Vagrancy laws let officials arrest unemployed Black people, fine them and hire them out to whoever paid the fine. Apprenticeship laws allowed courts to bind Black children to employers, often their former owners. Black people were also barred from juries and from voting.
Worked example: analysing a Black Code
Source: Mississippi's labour and vagrancy laws of November 1865, among the first Black Codes. 1. Provisions: Black workers needed written proof of employment for the coming year; those who quit early lost their wages and could be arrested and returned. 2. Effect: workers could not move to a better employer, so wages stayed low. 3. Comparison: like slavery, the law tied Black labour to particular landowners and punished escape. 4. Difference: workers were paid and could marry legally, so it was not slavery in name. 5. Northern reaction: Republicans saw the codes as proof that the South meant to undo emancipation, and support for congressional action grew.
The Civil Rights Act of 1866
Congress responded in early 1866 with two bills. The first extended the Freedmen's Bureau and widened its powers; Johnson vetoed it, and the veto held, though a revised bureau bill passed over his veto in July. The second, the Civil Rights Act, declared that everyone born in the United States, except Native Americans not taxed, was a citizen, overturning the reasoning of the Dred Scott decision. Citizens of every race had the same right to make contracts, sue, testify in court and own property. Johnson vetoed it as an invasion of states' rights, but in April 1866 Congress overrode him, the first time it had done so for a major law.
The Fourteenth Amendment
A law could be repealed or struck down, so Republicans wrote its principles into the Constitution. Congress passed the Fourteenth Amendment in June 1866, and it was ratified in July 1868. Section 1 made all persons born or naturalised in the United States citizens, and barred states from denying any person due process of law or "the equal protection of the laws". Section 2 cut a state's representation in Congress if it denied the vote to adult male citizens. Section 3 barred from office former officials who had joined the rebellion, unless two-thirds of Congress removed the bar. Section 4 voided Confederate debts and any claims for the loss of enslaved people.
Worked example: who did the amendment include?
Question: how far did the Fourteenth Amendment extend equal citizenship? 1. Included: formerly enslaved people and all others born in the country became citizens, and states had to treat every person equally under the law. 2. Limited for Native Americans: the phrase "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" was read to exclude most members of tribal nations, who were not all made citizens until 1924. 3. Limited for women: Section 2 used the word "male", the first time the Constitution did so; Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony protested. 4. No direct vote: it penalised states for excluding voters but did not require Black suffrage. 5. Conclusion: a broad promise of equality, with real exceptions.
Johnson's defeat in 1866
Johnson urged Southern states to reject the amendment, and all of them except Tennessee did; Tennessee ratified and was readmitted in July 1866. Violence made the stakes plain. In Memphis in May 1866 and New Orleans in July, white mobs, including police, killed dozens of Black residents and, in New Orleans, white Republicans as well. That summer, Johnson toured the North in a speaking campaign called the "swing around the circle", trading insults with hecklers and harming his own cause. In the autumn elections, Republicans won more than two-thirds of both houses, enough to override any veto.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking the Black Codes were the same as later Jim Crow segregation laws; they came earlier and focused on controlling labour. Second, assuming the Fourteenth Amendment gave Black men the vote; it only reduced representation for states that denied it. Third, forgetting that its citizenship clause excluded most Native Americans and that Section 2 wrote "male" into the Constitution. Fourth, describing the Freedmen's Bureau as large or permanent; it was small and short-lived. Fifth, overlooking freed people's own leadership in building schools.
Key takeaways
The Freedmen's Bureau, created in 1865, gave relief, supervised labour contracts and, with missionary societies and Black communities, built schools. Southern legislatures passed Black Codes in 1865-1866 to control Black labour through contracts, vagrancy and apprenticeship laws. Congress passed the Civil Rights Act of 1866 over Johnson's veto, defining citizenship. The Fourteenth Amendment, ratified in 1868, guaranteed citizenship, due process and equal protection. Southern rejection, riots and Johnson's failed tour gave Republicans veto-proof majorities in the 1866 elections.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Federal agency created in March 1865 to aid freed people and refugees
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What was the main purpose of the Black Codes passed by Southern legislatures in 1865-1866?
Question 2 of 5
Which statement about the Fourteenth Amendment is correct?
Question 3 of 5
Why did Republicans write the principles of the Civil Rights Act of 1866 into a constitutional amendment?
Question 4 of 5
Which group was largely left out of the Fourteenth Amendment's citizenship clause as it was interpreted at the time?
Question 5 of 5
What was the most important result of the 1866 congressional elections?
