US History › Section D · Building a republic › Topic D.3
The Constitutional Convention and ratification
In the summer of 1787, delegates sent to repair the Articles of Confederation wrote an entirely new plan of government instead. Their compromises over representation, slavery and popular power, and the fierce public fight over ratification, created the framework the United States still uses.
From repair to replacement
Concern about the Confederation had been building before Shays's Rebellion. In September 1786, delegates from just five states met at Annapolis to discuss trade between the states, and, urged by Alexander Hamilton and James Madison, they called for a wider meeting in Philadelphia. Congress endorsed it in February 1787, officially to revise the Articles. From May to September 1787, fifty-five delegates from twelve states took part; Rhode Island sent no one. George Washington presided, the sessions were secret, and much of what historians know comes from Madison's detailed notes. Early on, a majority decided to draft a new constitution, and two New York delegates, Robert Yates and John Lansing, left in protest.
Two plans for Congress
The Virginia Plan, drafted largely by Madison and presented by Edmund Randolph, proposed a strong national government with legislative, executive and judicial branches. Both houses of a two-house Congress would be apportioned by population, Congress would choose the executive, and it could veto state laws. Large states such as Virginia would gain most. Small states answered with the New Jersey Plan, introduced by William Paterson. It kept a one-house (unicameral) Congress in which every state had an equal vote, but added powers the Confederation lacked: to tax imports, regulate trade and enforce its requisitions. The convention rejected the New Jersey Plan, yet the small states would not accept representation by population alone.
The Great Compromise
Connecticut's delegates, led by Roger Sherman and Oliver Ellsworth, proposed the solution adopted in July 1787, known as the Connecticut or Great Compromise. Congress would be bicameral, with two houses. In the House of Representatives, seats would follow population and members would be elected by the voters. In the Senate, each state would have two senators, chosen by its legislature and voting as individuals. Bills for raising revenue would have to begin in the House, the chamber closest to the people. The compromise saved the convention, and it explains why today a small state like Wyoming has the same Senate voice as California.
The three-fifths clause
Population raised a harder question: should enslaved people be counted? Delegates from slaveholding states wanted them counted in full, to gain House seats; many northern delegates wanted them left out. The convention adopted a ratio used in a 1783 Confederation proposal on dividing tax burdens, which the states never ratified. Article I, Section 2 apportions both representatives and direct taxes by counting free people in full, excluding untaxed Native Americans, and adding "three fifths of all other Persons." Because direct federal taxes were rarely levied, the main effect was political: slaveholding states gained extra seats in the House and extra votes in the Electoral College for people they held in bondage.
The slave trade and fugitive slave clauses
In August 1787, delegates from South Carolina and Georgia insisted that the Atlantic slave trade continue. The result, in Article I, Section 9, says that the importation of such persons as existing states choose to admit "shall not be prohibited" by Congress before 1808. Article V even barred any amendment to that clause before 1808, and Congress banned the import of enslaved Africans from 1 January 1808. Days later, at the urging of South Carolina's Pierce Butler and Charles Pinckney, delegates added a fugitive slave clause to Article IV, Section 2. The document never uses the word slave, yet it protected slavery in several ways.
Worked example: reading the fugitive slave clause
Analyse the clause in Article IV, Section 2, phrase by phrase. 1. Wording: it begins "No Person held to Service or Labour", which avoids the word slave and also covers indentured servants. 2. Limit on free states: the person who escapes cannot be freed "in Consequence of any Law or Regulation" of the state they reach. 3. Duty: they "shall be delivered up" when the enslaver makes a claim. 4. Gap: it set no procedure, so Congress later supplied one in the Fugitive Slave Act of 1793. 5. Significance: slavery's protection now reached into states that had abolished it.
Dividing power and limiting democracy
Many delegates distrusted direct popular rule as much as they disliked the Articles' weakness, so they divided and checked power. The president could veto laws; Congress could override with two-thirds of each house; the Senate confirmed appointments by a majority and approved treaties by two-thirds; federal judges served during good behaviour, in practice for life. Only the House was elected directly by the voters. Senators were chosen by state legislatures until the Seventeenth Amendment of 1913. The president was chosen by the Electoral College: each state received electors equal to its senators plus representatives, and its legislature decided how they were picked. Article VI also banned religious tests for federal office.
Federalists against Anti-Federalists
Article VII made the Constitution binding once special conventions in nine states approved it. Supporters, who called themselves Federalists, argued that only a stronger union could pay debts, defend the country and keep order. Hamilton, Madison and John Jay wrote eighty-five essays, signed Publius and later called The Federalist. In Federalist No. 10, Madison argued that a large republic, with many competing interests, made it harder for any single faction to oppress others. Opponents, the Anti-Federalists, among them George Mason, Patrick Henry, and writers using pen names such as Brutus, warned that a distant government would serve the wealthy, swallow the states, and threaten liberty without a bill of rights.
Worked example: how ratification was won
Trace the cause and effect. 1. Early wins: Delaware ratified first, in December 1787, and Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Georgia and Connecticut soon followed. 2. The obstacle: in Massachusetts, many delegates objected to the missing bill of rights. 3. The strategy: Federalists agreed to ratify while recommending amendments, and the convention approved by 187 votes to 168 in February 1788. 4. The threshold: New Hampshire became the ninth state in June 1788. 5. The large states: Virginia then ratified by 89 to 79 and New York by 30 to 27, both with recommended amendments. 6. The outcome: North Carolina and Rhode Island joined only after the new government began, and the promise of amendments led to the Bill of Rights.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, saying the Constitution declared enslaved people three-fifths of a person: it was an apportionment rule that gave slaveholding states extra power, and the antislavery position was to count enslaved people not at all. Second, thinking the 1808 clause abolished the slave trade: it only stopped Congress from banning imports before 1808, and slavery within the states was untouched. Third, picturing the Anti-Federalists as enemies of union: most wanted a looser union with more protection for rights. Fourth, believing the people elected senators and the president directly in 1789: only the House was directly elected.
Key takeaways
Called to revise the Articles, the 1787 convention wrote a new constitution. The Virginia Plan's representation by population clashed with the New Jersey Plan's equal state votes until the Great Compromise created a population-based House and an equal Senate. The three-fifths, slave trade and fugitive slave clauses protected slavery without naming it. Separation of powers, checks and balances, indirectly chosen senators and the Electoral College limited direct popular rule. Federalists won ratification narrowly, often by promising amendments, against Anti-Federalists who feared centralised power and demanded a bill of rights.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Meeting of five states that called for a convention in Philadelphia
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
How did the Great Compromise settle the dispute between large and small states?
Question 2 of 5
What was the main political effect of the three-fifths clause?
Question 3 of 5
What did Article I, Section 9 say about the Atlantic slave trade?
Question 4 of 5
What did the fugitive slave clause require?
Question 5 of 5
Which objection did Anti-Federalists raise most often against the Constitution?
