US History › Section D · Building a republic › Topic D.2

How much change? Debating democracy under the Articles

The Revolution's language of equality raised hopes among women, enslaved people and ordinary farmers, but most of the old order survived. In the 1780s, state constitutions and the Articles of Confederation became testing grounds for how much democracy the new republic would allow.

The promise and its limits

The Declaration of Independence claimed that all men are created equal, and Americans of every rank heard that claim. Most elite revolutionaries, however, did not intend to remake society. They expected men to rule women, White people to rule Black people, and the wealthy to lead the poor. Others pressed for change: women who wanted legal and educational equality, enslaved people who sued or fled for freedom, and farmers who wanted a louder political voice. The real question of the 1780s was how far the Revolution's ideals would reach, and who would decide.

Women and the republic

Under the English legal doctrine of coverture, a married woman, a feme covert, had no legal identity separate from her husband: he controlled her property and she could not make contracts on her own. The Revolution left coverture in place. In a 1776 letter, Abigail Adams asked her husband John to remember the ladies in the new laws and limit husbands' power; he dismissed the idea. Judith Sargent Murray published essays arguing that women's minds equalled men's and deserved equal schooling, and Mercy Otis Warren wrote a history of the Revolution. Historians use the term republican motherhood for the new ideal: educated mothers would raise virtuous citizens, which justified better schooling for girls but kept women out of politics.

Slavery and the first emancipations

Slavery was legal in every state in 1776, and the contradiction with revolutionary ideals was plain. Black Americans pressed it: in 1777, Prince Hall and other Black men petitioned Massachusetts for freedom. Northern states then began to act. Pennsylvania passed the first gradual abolition law in 1780, under which children born after the act would be freed at age twenty-eight. In Massachusetts, freedom suits brought by enslaved people such as Elizabeth Freeman and Quock Walker in the early 1780s, citing the 1780 state constitution's statement that all men are born free and equal, made slavery unenforceable in the courts. Other northern states followed gradually, New York not completing emancipation until 1827. Virginia eased private manumission in 1782, and thousands were freed, but slavery grew stronger in the South overall.

Native nations and religious freedom

The 1783 Treaty of Paris transferred British claims as far west as the Mississippi without mentioning the Native nations who lived there. Many of those nations had sided with Britain, the Iroquois Confederacy had split, and in 1782 Pennsylvania militiamen killed about ninety-six Christian Lenape (Delaware) people at Gnadenhutten, most of them women and children. After the war, the United States treated western land as conquered, and a Western Confederacy of nations organised to resist. Religion changed more. Virginia's Statute for Religious Freedom of 1786 barred the state from forcing anyone to attend or pay for any church, while Massachusetts and Connecticut kept tax-supported Congregational churches into the nineteenth century.

State constitutions as experiments

Each new state had to write a constitution, and each answered the democracy question differently. In Thoughts on Government (1776), John Adams urged a separation of powers: a two-house legislature, an independent executive and courts, each checking the others. Pennsylvania's 1776 constitution went the other way. It created a single-house legislature, replaced the governor with an elected executive council, and let adult men who paid taxes vote, opening the ballot to most free men: the most democratic plan of its day. Maryland and South Carolina did the opposite, setting steep property requirements for high office. Massachusetts's 1780 constitution, drafted mainly by Adams, was written by a specially elected convention and then approved by the towns.

Worked example: two constitutions compared

Compare Pennsylvania 1776 with Massachusetts 1780. 1. Voters: Pennsylvania required tax payment; Massachusetts required property or income, which excluded more men. 2. Legislature: Pennsylvania had one house, directly answering to voters; Massachusetts had two, with an upper house for wealthier men. 3. Executive: Pennsylvania had a council with limited power; Massachusetts had a governor with a veto. 4. Judges: Massachusetts appointed them, keeping them away from popular pressure. 5. Conclusion: Pennsylvania trusted the majority, while Massachusetts built barriers against it. 6. Check: Adams attacked the Pennsylvania model as far too democratic, which fits this reading.

The Articles of Confederation

Congress drafted the Articles of Confederation, the country's first written plan of national government, in 1776 and 1777, but they took effect only in March 1781. Maryland refused to ratify until states such as Virginia gave up their claims to western lands. The Articles created a league of sovereign states with a one-house Congress in which each state had one vote. There was no national executive and no national court system. Major measures needed nine of the thirteen states, and any amendment needed all thirteen. Congress could make war and treaties, but it could not tax or regulate trade. It could only request money from the states, which sent far less than it asked.

Weakness and one great success

The results showed. A plan for a 5 percent tax on imports failed when Rhode Island refused to agree, and the national debt went largely unpaid. Britain kept forts on American soil, and Spain closed the lower Mississippi to American trade in 1784. Yet Congress's land ordinances lasted. The Land Ordinance of 1785 surveyed western land into townships six miles square, each divided into thirty-six sections of 640 acres, with one section reserved for schools. The Northwest Ordinance of 1787 set a path to statehood on equal terms and banned slavery north of the Ohio River. It promised good faith to Native nations, yet planned for their land to pass to settlers.

Worked example: causes and effects of Shays's Rebellion

Trace the chain in Massachusetts. 1. Cause: after the war, money was scarce, and the state raised heavy taxes payable in hard currency to repay its war debts. 2. Pressure: creditors sued, and farmers, many of them veterans, faced losing their land to foreclosure. 3. Protest: petitions to the legislature in Boston brought little relief, so in 1786 armed crowds closed county courts. 4. Climax: in January 1787, rebels associated with Daniel Shays attacked the federal arsenal at Springfield and were driven off; a militia army funded by Boston merchants scattered them in February. 5. Effects: the state later eased taxes and pardoned most rebels, while nationalists cited the uprising as proof that the Confederation was too weak.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming the Revolution freed enslaved people in the North at once: most northern laws were gradual, and slavery lingered for decades. Second, thinking the Articles had a president or a Supreme Court: they had neither. Third, claiming the Confederation achieved nothing: its land ordinances shaped western settlement for a century. Fourth, treating republican motherhood as women's equality: it valued women's education but kept them in the home. Fifth, describing Shays's rebels as mere bandits: they were indebted farmers, many of them veterans, who saw their protest as continuing the fight against unresponsive government.

Key takeaways

The Revolution's language of equality outran its results. Coverture survived, though republican motherhood widened girls' education. Northern states began gradual emancipation, pushed by Black petitions and freedom suits, while Native nations were left out of the peace and slavery strengthened in the South. State constitutions ranged from democratic Pennsylvania to cautious Massachusetts. The Articles of Confederation created a weak league that could not tax, though its land ordinances and the Northwest Ordinance were lasting achievements. Shays's Rebellion convinced many leaders that a stronger national government was needed.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Coverture

Legal doctrine giving a married woman no legal identity separate from her husband

Unchanged by the Revolution.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What did the legal doctrine of coverture mean for a married woman in the 1780s?

Question 2 of 5

How did slavery lose its legal standing in Massachusetts in the 1780s?

Question 3 of 5

Which feature made Pennsylvania's 1776 constitution the most democratic of its time?

Question 4 of 5

Why did Congress under the Articles of Confederation struggle to pay the national debt?

Question 5 of 5

What national effect did Shays's Rebellion have?

← Previous topicNext topic →