US History › Section D · Building a republic › Topic D.4
Federalists and Democratic-Republicans
The Constitution said nothing about political parties, yet within four years of Washington's inauguration Americans had split into two rival camps. The split began with Alexander Hamilton's plans for the nation's finances and grew into a contest over what the republic should become.
Launching the new government
After ratification by nine states in 1788, the new Congress first assembled in New York City in the spring of 1789. George Washington, chosen unanimously by the electors, took the oath of office there on 30 April 1789, with John Adams as vice president. Everything he did set a precedent. Congress created departments of State, Treasury and War, plus an attorney general, and Washington came to consult these officers as a group, later called the cabinet. The Judiciary Act of 1789 set up a Supreme Court of six justices and lower federal courts, and the Tariff of 1789 placed duties on imports to raise revenue.
The Bill of Rights
Several states had ratified the Constitution only after recommending amendments, and North Carolina and Rhode Island were still outside the union. Madison, now a member of the House, gathered these proposals and introduced amendments in June 1789. Congress sent twelve to the states, and ten were ratified by December 1791 as the Bill of Rights. They protect freedom of religion, speech, the press, assembly and petition, the right to bear arms, security against unreasonable searches, and the rights of the accused, including trial by jury. The Ninth and Tenth Amendments reserve unlisted rights to the people and undelegated powers to the states or the people.
Hamilton and the debt
Washington chose Alexander Hamilton, a nationalist born in the British West Indies, as secretary of the treasury, and Thomas Jefferson as secretary of state. Hamilton inherited a federal debt of more than $50 million, owed to foreign lenders and to Americans holding wartime certificates, while the states owed roughly $25 million more. Because the Confederation had failed to pay, European lenders saw the country as a poor risk. Hamilton believed that a government able to pay its debts would win the loyalty of wealthy creditors and the trust of foreign markets, and that public credit underpinned every other national power.
The Report on Public Credit
In January 1790, Hamilton proposed funding the national debt at its full face value by exchanging old certificates for new interest-bearing federal bonds, and assuming the states' war debts as federal debts. Both ideas met resistance. Many soldiers and farmers had sold their certificates in the 1780s to speculators for a fraction of face value, so full payment would reward the buyers, not the original holders. Madison proposed paying original holders a share, but Congress rejected it as unworkable. Assumption angered states such as Virginia that had already paid off much of their debt and saw no reason to pay for others.
Worked example: the Compromise of 1790
Trace how a deadlock was broken. 1. The problem: in spring 1790, the House narrowly rejected assumption, and Hamilton's plan stalled. 2. A second dispute: Congress also could not agree where the permanent capital should be. 3. The bargain: according to Jefferson's later account, he hosted a dinner in June at which Madison agreed not to block assumption, in return for a capital on the Potomac River, which Virginians wanted. 4. The laws: the Residence Act of July 1790 placed the capital on the Potomac, with Philadelphia as a temporary seat for ten years, and assumption passed in August. 5. Caution: historians note other votes were also traded, so the dinner was one part of a wider deal.
A national bank and the Constitution
In December 1790, Hamilton proposed a Bank of the United States, modelled on the Bank of England. Private investors would own most of its stock, with the government holding one-fifth; it would hold federal money, lend to merchants and issue notes that circulated as currency. Jefferson and Attorney General Edmund Randolph told Washington the bank was unconstitutional, because the Constitution nowhere granted Congress the power to create corporations. Hamilton replied that the power to make laws "necessary and proper" for carrying out its listed powers, such as taxing and borrowing, implied the power to choose a bank as the means. Washington accepted Hamilton's reasoning and signed a twenty-year charter in February 1791.
Revenue and manufactures
To pay interest on the debt, Hamilton also proposed an excise tax on distilled spirits, which Congress passed in 1791 and which would provoke the Whiskey Rebellion. In his Report on Manufactures of December 1791, he urged Washington and Congress to promote American industry with protective tariffs and government payments, called bounties, to new industries, so the country would depend less on imported goods. Congress adopted little of this report at the time. Even so, Hamilton's overall programme restored the nation's credit, created a market in federal bonds and laid the foundations of the American financial system.
Jefferson's agrarian republic
Jefferson and Madison saw Hamilton's system as a threat to the republic. They believed it enriched speculators, tied the government to a moneyed interest, and stretched federal power beyond the Constitution's words. Jefferson's ideal citizen was the independent yeoman farmer who owned his land and therefore could not be bought or bullied; cities, banks and debt bred dependence and corruption. He also welcomed the French Revolution, while Hamilton looked to Britain as a trading partner and model. Jefferson's agrarian vision had a hard edge: across his life he held hundreds of people in slavery, and he imagined the farming republic as a White man's one.
Worked example: two visions, two parties
Compare the camps on four questions. 1. Economy: Hamilton's Federalists favoured commerce, banking and manufacturing; Jefferson's Democratic-Republicans favoured farming. 2. Constitution: Federalists read it broadly, with implied powers; Democratic-Republicans read it strictly, a view called strict construction, citing the Tenth Amendment. 3. Foreign policy: Federalists leaned towards Britain, Democratic-Republicans towards France. 4. Who should lead: Federalists trusted an educated elite; Democratic-Republicans trusted ordinary White men more. 5. Organisation: each side built newspapers, Jefferson's ally Philip Freneau editing the National Gazette from 1791 against the Federalist Gazette of the United States, and artisans formed Democratic-Republican societies. 6. Conclusion: this was the first party system, born from policy disagreements the founders had not expected.
Who counted as a citizen?
The parties agreed more than they disagreed about who belonged. The Naturalization Act of 1790 let immigrants become citizens only if they were free White persons of good character who had lived in the country for two years, shutting out people of African and Asian descent. Voting rules were left to the states, and most required property or tax payment. New Jersey was a striking exception: its 1776 constitution let property-holding inhabitants vote, so some unmarried women and widows, as well as free Black men, cast ballots. In 1807 New Jersey limited the vote to White male citizens.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming the Constitution created political parties: it never mentions them, and many founders condemned factions. Second, confusing Jefferson's Democratic-Republicans with today's Republican Party, founded in the 1850s. Third, thinking the Bill of Rights came with the original Constitution: it was added between 1789 and 1791. Fourth, believing Congress adopted the whole Report on Manufactures: most of it was set aside. Fifth, treating the Compromise of 1790 as just one dinner: it settled two disputes through a wider exchange of votes.
Key takeaways
Washington's administration created the executive departments, the cabinet and the federal courts, and the Bill of Rights won over many critics. Hamilton funded the debt at face value, assumed state debts through the Compromise of 1790, and created a national bank, defending it with implied powers under the necessary and proper clause. Jefferson and Madison opposed him with a strict reading of the Constitution and an agrarian ideal. The clash produced the first party system: Federalists against Democratic-Republicans. Citizenship was defined narrowly, as the 1790 Naturalization Act showed.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Washington inaugurated in New York City
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why did Madison introduce the amendments that became the Bill of Rights?
Question 2 of 5
Why did critics object to funding the national debt at full face value?
Question 3 of 5
What did the Compromise of 1790 exchange?
Question 4 of 5
How did Hamilton argue that the Bank of the United States was constitutional?
Question 5 of 5
Who was Thomas Jefferson's ideal citizen of the republic?
