US History › Section M · Depression and New Deal › Topic M.1
The stock market crash of 1929
In the autumn of 1929 the New York stock market lost about half its value in a few weeks. The crash did not on its own cause the Great Depression, but it exposed a fragile economy and helped tip it into the worst slump in American history.
A crash and a depression are not the same thing
The crash was a sharp fall in share prices in October and November 1929. The Great Depression was a collapse of output, jobs and banks that lasted, in its worst phase, from 1929 to 1933, with hard times continuing until about 1941. The crash was the most visible shock, but most economists and historians now see it as one link in a chain rather than the single cause. The deeper damage came from existing weaknesses and from later policy mistakes.
Hoover takes office in good times
Herbert Hoover, a mining engineer who had organised food relief for occupied Belgium during the First World War and then served as secretary of commerce under Harding and Coolidge, won the 1928 election easily and took office in March 1929. He believed government should encourage voluntary cooperation among business, farmers and workers rather than direct the economy. In June 1929 he signed the Agricultural Marketing Act, which created a Federal Farm Board to support crop prices through farm cooperatives, a sign that farming was already in trouble before the crash.
Easy credit and a speculative mood
During the 1920s many middle-class and wealthy Americans came to believe that asset prices would keep rising. A land boom in Florida collapsed in 1925-1926, yet speculation simply moved to the stock market. The Dow Jones Industrial Average climbed from about 64 in 1921 to a peak of about 381 on 3 September 1929, roughly six times higher. Prices rose far faster than company profits. New investment trusts sold shares in pools of other shares, often bought with borrowed money. The Federal Reserve raised interest rates in 1928 and 1929 to cool the market, but by then the boom had a momentum of its own.
Buying on margin
Many investors bought shares on margin: they paid part of the price themselves and borrowed the rest from a broker, using the shares as security. Loans to brokers grew to an estimated $8 billion or more by 1929. Margin magnifies gains while prices rise, but it also magnifies losses. If prices fall far enough, the broker issues a margin call, a demand for more cash. An investor who cannot pay has the shares sold at whatever price the market offers. In a falling market, thousands of forced sales at once push prices down further and trigger still more margin calls.
Worked example: a margin call
A hypothetical investor in 1929, traced step by step. 1. She buys shares worth $5,000, paying $1,000 of her own money and borrowing $4,000 from her broker. 2. If prices rise 20 percent, the shares are worth $6,000; after repaying the loan she holds $2,000, double her stake. 3. Instead, prices fall 25 percent, so the shares are worth $3,750. 4. That is less than the $4,000 she owes, so her own $1,000 is gone and she still owes $250. 5. The broker sells her shares, adding to the selling. 6. Conclusion: a 25 percent fall in prices wiped out more than all of her own money.
The October panic
On Thursday 24 October, Black Thursday, a record of almost 13 million shares changed hands as prices plunged, until leading bankers pooled money to buy shares and briefly steadied the market. The calm did not last. On Monday 28 October the Dow fell about 13 percent, and on Tuesday 29 October, Black Tuesday, it fell about 12 percent more as over 16 million shares were traded. By mid-November the market had lost almost half its September value. Prices partly recovered in early 1930, then slid for more than two years.
The long slide to 1932
The market's lowest point came in July 1932, when the Dow closed at about 41, roughly 89 percent below its 1929 peak. It did not regain its 1929 high until 1954. This long decline tracked a collapsing real economy, as profits vanished and banks failed in waves. Unemployment rose from about 3 percent in 1929 to about 9 percent in 1930 and about 16 percent in 1931, and it peaked at about 25 percent in 1933. Rates were higher still for some groups, including Black workers, who were often the first laid off.
Weaknesses beneath the boom
Farmers had suffered low prices and heavy debts since about 1920. Income was highly concentrated: by most estimates the richest 1 percent received over a fifth of all income, so mass spending relied on instalment credit for cars, radios and appliances, and by 1929 many households had already bought what they could afford. The banking system was fragile, with thousands of small, lightly regulated banks and no deposit insurance; over 5,000 banks, mostly rural, failed during the 1920s. International finance rested on a loop of American loans, German reparations and Allied war debts, and American lending abroad fell sharply in 1928 and 1929.
How the shock spread
Lost wealth made investors cut spending. Even people who owned no shares grew uncertain about the future and put off buying cars, furniture and other durable goods, which hit factories hard. Businesses cancelled investment plans and laid off workers. Banks that had lent to speculators took losses, and nervous depositors began to withdraw cash. Abroad, the slump spread through trade and the gold standard, which linked countries' money supplies. Each effect fed the next, turning a recession that had begun in the summer of 1929 into a deep depression.
Worked example: did the crash cause the Depression?
A cause-and-effect analysis. 1. Timing: industrial production had begun to fall in the summer of 1929, so a downturn was already under way before October. 2. Reach: estimates suggest that only about one household in ten owned shares, so direct losses fell on a minority. 3. Indirect effects: the crash shook confidence, and spending on durable goods fell sharply in 1930. 4. Later shocks: from late 1930, waves of bank failures and a fall of about a third in the money supply, which the economists Milton Friedman and Anna Schwartz blamed on the Federal Reserve, did far more damage. 5. Conclusion: the crash was a trigger and an amplifier, not the sole cause. Historians and economists still debate how much weight to give spending, money, banks and the gold standard.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, saying the crash alone caused the Great Depression; it was one cause among several, and the worst damage came later. Second, assuming most Americans owned shares; only a minority did, though the crash affected almost everyone indirectly. Third, thinking the market hit bottom in October 1929; the low came in July 1932. Fourth, treating the 1920s as prosperous for everyone; farmers and many workers struggled throughout the decade. Fifth, quoting the 25 percent unemployment figure for 1929 or 1930; it was the peak, reached in 1933.
Key takeaways
Easy credit, margin buying and investment trusts fuelled a boom in which the Dow rose about sixfold. Panic selling in late October 1929 cut share values almost in half within weeks, and the market fell about 89 percent by July 1932. Farm distress, concentrated income, fragile banks and shaky international finance made the economy vulnerable. The crash was a trigger, not the sole cause, of a depression in which unemployment peaked at about 25 percent in 1933.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The collapse of share prices in October and November 1929
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
An investor buys $5,000 of shares on margin with $1,000 of her own money. Prices then fall 25 percent. What is her position?
Question 2 of 5
When did the stock market reach its lowest point after the 1929 crash?
Question 3 of 5
Which statement best describes the crash's role in causing the Great Depression?
Question 4 of 5
About what was the US unemployment rate at its peak, and in which year?
Question 5 of 5
Which weakness of the 1920s economy made mass spending depend heavily on credit?
