US History › Section L · The Great War and the 1920s › Topic L.8

Republican politics in the 1920s

Three Republican presidents, Harding, Coolidge and Hoover, led the country through the 1920s with a promise of limited government and close partnership with business. Their era brought tax cuts, scandal, arms control and booming markets, but also hidden weaknesses that the decade's prosperity concealed.

The Republican ascendancy

After 1920, Republicans held the White House and both houses of Congress for the rest of the decade. They believed that business growth, not government reform, was the surest path to prosperity, and they cut taxes, raised tariffs and regulated lightly. In a 1925 speech to newspaper editors, Calvin Coolidge put the mood in a famous phrase: "the chief business of the American people is business." Critics, then and later, argued that this approach favoured the wealthy, neglected farmers and workers, and let dangerous speculation go unchecked.

Harding's cabinet

Warren G. Harding, a genial newspaper publisher and senator from Ohio, had won on a promise of "normalcy" and pledged to appoint "the best minds", and some of his choices were strong. Charles Evans Hughes, the 1916 candidate, became Secretary of State. Andrew Mellon, one of the richest men in America, ran the Treasury. Herbert Hoover, famous for wartime food relief, became Secretary of Commerce and urged businesses to cooperate voluntarily. But Harding also gave posts to old friends from Ohio, the so-called Ohio Gang, led by his campaign manager Harry Daugherty, whom he made attorney general. Several of them used office to enrich themselves.

Harding's policies at home

Harding's administration created the first formal federal budget process with the Budget and Accounting Act of 1921, which required the president to submit an annual budget to Congress. Congress began cutting taxes, especially on high incomes, and raised tariffs, first with an emergency law in 1921 and then with the Fordney-McCumber Tariff of 1922, to protect American farms and factories from imports. Harding signed the 1921 immigration quota act. He also showed a conciliatory side: in December 1921, he commuted the prison sentence of the socialist Eugene Debs, who was released on Christmas Day and later visited the White House.

Peace through treaties

Although the United States stayed out of the League, it did not withdraw from the world. In 1921, it made separate peace treaties with Germany and Austria. At the Washington Naval Conference of 1921-1922, Hughes proposed scrapping battleships, and the Five-Power Treaty set limits on large warships for the United States, Britain, Japan, France and Italy. Other agreements promised to respect each other's Pacific possessions and China's independence. Later, the Dawes Plan of 1924 used American loans to ease German reparations, and in 1928 the Kellogg-Briand Pact renounced war as an instrument of national policy, though it had no means of enforcement.

Worked example: the Teapot Dome scandal

Question: why is Teapot Dome remembered as the era's worst scandal? 1. Background: the navy kept oil fields at Teapot Dome, Wyoming, and Elk Hills, California, as reserves for emergencies. 2. Transfer: Interior Secretary Albert B. Fall arranged for control of the reserves to pass to his department. 3. Deal: in 1922 he leased them, without competitive bidding, to the oilmen Harry Sinclair and Edward Doheny. 4. Payment: Fall received roughly $400,000 in loans, cash and bonds, along with livestock for his New Mexico ranch. 5. Exposure: a Senate investigation uncovered the deals after Harding's death. 6. Result: in 1929, Fall was convicted of bribery, the first cabinet member imprisoned for crimes in office. Conclusion: it became a lasting symbol of government corruption.

Harding's death and "Silent Cal"

Other scandals surfaced as well. Charles Forbes, head of the Veterans' Bureau, was later jailed for fraud that cost the government many millions of dollars. Harding, increasingly troubled, died suddenly in San Francisco in August 1923, probably of heart failure, while on a speaking tour. Vice President Calvin Coolidge was visiting his family's farm in Vermont, where his father, a notary public, swore him in by lamplight. Coolidge, a reserved New Englander known as "Silent Cal", had won national fame by opposing the 1919 Boston police strike. His reputation for honesty helped Republicans survive the scandals.

Coolidge and business

Coolidge believed government should do little and spend less. With Mellon at the Treasury, Congress cut the top income tax rate, which had been 73% in 1921, to 25% by 1926, arguing that lower rates would spur investment. The government ran budget surpluses and paid down the war debt. Coolidge vetoed the McNary-Haugen bills in 1927 and 1928, which would have supported farm prices, calling them unsound. In 1924 Coolidge also signed the Indian Citizenship Act, making all Native Americans born in the United States citizens, though several states still kept many from voting.

The election of 1924

In 1924, the Democrats tore themselves apart. At their convention in New York, delegates fought over whether to condemn the Klan by name, and the proposal failed by a narrow margin. Rural, dry Southern and Western delegates backed William McAdoo, while urban, wet Northerners backed Governor Al Smith of New York, a Catholic. After 103 ballots, they chose a compromise candidate, the corporate lawyer John W. Davis. Senator Robert La Follette of Wisconsin ran as a Progressive, backed by farmers, unions and socialists, and won about 17% of the vote. Coolidge won easily, with about 54%.

Worked example: the election of 1928

Question: what does the 1928 election reveal about the nation's divisions? 1. Candidates: Coolidge announced, "I do not choose to run for President in nineteen twenty eight"; Republicans nominated Herbert Hoover, Democrats Al Smith. 2. Issues: Hoover stood for prosperity and efficiency; Smith opposed Prohibition and was the first Catholic nominated by a major party, which drew open religious prejudice. 3. Result: Hoover won about 58% of the vote and 444 electoral votes to 87, even carrying several Southern states. 4. Hidden shift: taken together, the nation's twelve largest cities gave Smith more votes than Hoover, many from immigrant and Catholic voters. 5. Interpretation: some historians argue this urban vote foreshadowed the Democratic coalition of the 1930s. Conclusion: a Republican landslide masked a realignment beginning in the cities.

Beneath the boom

When Hoover took office in March 1929, prosperity seemed permanent, yet there were serious weaknesses. Farmers had been in depression since 1920, burdened by debt and low prices. Income and wealth were increasingly concentrated at the top, so mass consumption depended heavily on credit. Thousands of small banks, many of them rural, failed during the decade, and there was no federal insurance for deposits. Stock prices soared on speculation, much of it with borrowed money. High tariffs also made it harder for Europeans to sell goods in America and repay their debts. These problems set the stage for the crash of October 1929.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, calling 1920s foreign policy simply isolationist; the United States led naval arms limits, the Dawes Plan and the Kellogg-Briand Pact while staying out of the League. Second, blaming Harding personally for taking bribes; his failure was trusting corrupt friends. Third, misquoting Coolidge as saying "the business of America is business"; his words were "the chief business of the American people is business". Fourth, treating the 1928 result as a sign of total Democratic weakness; Smith's urban vote hinted at change. Fifth, assuming the boom helped everyone; farmers were in trouble all decade.

Key takeaways

Republicans dominated the 1920s with a pro-business programme of tax cuts, high tariffs and light regulation. Harding's cabinet mixed able men with corrupt friends, and the Teapot Dome scandal became a symbol of corruption. Abroad, the United States pursued arms limits and treaties without joining the League. Coolidge restored trust and cut taxes but vetoed farm relief. Divided Democrats lost in 1924, and Hoover beat Al Smith in 1928, though Smith's city vote hinted at a coming realignment. Farm distress, inequality and speculation lay beneath the boom.

Flashcards

Flashcard

"Normalcy"

Harding's 1920 promise of calm, limited government

Republicans held the presidency all decade.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which statement best describes US foreign policy in the 1920s?

Question 2 of 5

What was the Teapot Dome scandal?

Question 3 of 5

Why did Coolidge veto the McNary-Haugen bills?

Question 4 of 5

What did Al Smith's results in the 1928 election suggest to historians?

Question 5 of 5

Which of these was a hidden weakness of the 1920s economy?

← Previous topicNext topic →