US History › Section M · Depression and New Deal › Topic M.3
The depths of the Depression and the Hoover record
By the winter of 1932-1933, about one American worker in four was jobless, thousands of banks had closed and drought was turning the southern Plains to dust. The suffering fell unevenly, and it shaped how Americans judged Herbert Hoover and what they would demand of his successor.
The scale of the collapse
Between 1929 and 1933 the economy shrank further and faster than at any other time in American history. Real output, the value of goods and services after adjusting for prices, fell by about a quarter. Prices fell by about a quarter too. Roughly 9,000 banks failed between 1930 and 1933. Unemployment, about 3 percent in 1929, reached about 24 percent in 1932 and peaked at about 25 percent in 1933, when an estimated 12 to 13 million people were out of work. Millions more worked short hours for reduced pay. Relief from cities, states and charities could not keep up.
Bank failures and deflation
Banks failed in waves: in late 1930, when the Bank of United States in New York collapsed, again in 1931, and in a final panic in early 1933. With no deposit insurance, depositors lost savings, and surviving banks hoarded cash and called in loans. The money supply fell by about a third. Falling prices, or deflation, made matters worse, because debts were fixed in dollars while wages, crop prices and profits shrank. In 1933 the economist Irving Fisher called this process debt-deflation: as borrowers struggled to repay, they sold assets and cut spending, pushing prices down further.
Daily life in hard times
In cities, breadlines and soup kitchens fed the hungry, and evicted families built shacks in Hoovervilles. Relatives doubled up in crowded homes. Marriage and birth rates fell. Hundreds of thousands of young people, mostly boys, rode freight trains in search of work. Some cities ran out of relief money entirely. Women faced pressure to leave paid work so that men could have jobs, and a 1932 federal law required that, when staff were cut, married people whose spouses also worked for the government were dismissed first, which in practice fell mostly on wives. Yet because clerical and domestic jobs shrank less than factory work, more women overall took paid work during the decade.
Black Americans: last hired, first fired
Black Americans were hit especially hard. In Southern cotton country, landowners evicted sharecroppers as prices collapsed. In cities, Black workers were often the first laid off, and white workers took jobs, such as waiting tables or cleaning streets, once left to Black workers. Black unemployment ran far above white, and in some cities approached half of Black workers. In 1931 nine Black teenagers, the Scottsboro Boys, were falsely accused of rape in Alabama and quickly sentenced, eight of them to death. In Powell v. Alabama in 1932 the Supreme Court overturned the convictions because the defendants had lacked adequate lawyers.
Mexican Americans and repatriation
Mexican and Mexican American families, many of whom worked in agriculture, railways and factories across the Southwest and Midwest, faced a campaign to push them out. Federal immigration raids, local relief officials who cut off aid, and employers who fired them pressured families to leave for Mexico; many went by train at public expense. Estimates of the number who left between about 1929 and 1936 range from about 400,000 to over a million, and historians agree that a large share were US citizens, many of them children born in the United States. California formally apologised for its part in 2005.
Farmers and the Dust Bowl
Farm prices fell by more than half between 1929 and 1932, and many farmers lost their land to foreclosure. On the southern Great Plains, a second disaster struck. During the boom years of the 1910s and 1920s, farmers had ploughed up millions of acres of native grassland to grow wheat. When severe drought arrived in the early 1930s, the bare soil blew away in enormous dust storms, worst in the middle years of the decade; on Black Sunday, 14 April 1935, a vast storm darkened the region. Hundreds of thousands of migrants, often called Okies whatever their home state, headed west, many to California, where they met hostility and low-paid farm work.
Worked example: debt-deflation on a farm
A hypothetical Kansas wheat farm, traced step by step. 1. In 1928 the family borrows $3,000 to buy land and a tractor, expecting to repay $300 a year. 2. At about $1 a bushel, $300 equals about 300 bushels of wheat. 3. By 1932 wheat sells for about 40 cents a bushel, but the debt is still fixed in dollars. 4. Paying $300 now takes about 750 bushels, two and a half times as much grain. 5. Drought cuts the harvest, so the family falls behind, and the bank forecloses. 6. Conclusion: falling prices raised the real burden of debt, and forced sales of land pushed prices lower still.
The rest of Hoover's record
Hoover's presidency was more than the Depression. In foreign policy he improved relations with Latin America: the Clark Memorandum, published in 1930, rejected the idea that the Monroe Doctrine justified American intervention, and he began withdrawing marines from Nicaragua and Haiti. The Stimson Doctrine of 1932 refused to recognise Japan's seizure of Manchuria. His running mate, Vice President Charles Curtis, was a member of the Kaw Nation, and his administration increased spending on Native schools and health after the critical Meriam Report of 1928. On civil rights, however, he did little and in 1930 nominated John J. Parker, whom the NAACP opposed, to the Supreme Court; the Senate rejected him.
Worked example: weighing the Hoover record
Question: how fairly is Hoover blamed for the Depression? 1. Against blame: the downturn began before the crash, spread worldwide, and was deepened by the Federal Reserve, which the president did not control. 2. For blame: he signed the Smoot-Hawley Tariff, raised taxes in 1932 and refused direct federal relief while people went hungry. 3. Context: almost all leaders of the time, including many Democrats, shared his faith in balanced budgets and the gold standard. 4. Reassessment: since the 1970s historians such as Joan Hoff Wilson have called him a forgotten progressive who expanded federal action. 5. Conclusion: most historians now say Hoover did not cause the Depression but that his remedies were too narrow and too slow for its scale.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming suffering fell equally; Black, Mexican American and farm families often fared worst. Second, treating the Dust Bowl as a purely natural disaster; ploughing up grassland made the drought far more destructive. Third, forgetting that many people sent to Mexico were US citizens. Fourth, saying Hoover caused the Depression; most historians judge him for an inadequate response, not for starting it. Fifth, giving the Scottsboro case a quick ending; retrials and appeals ran for years, and none of the defendants was executed.
Key takeaways
From 1929 to 1933 output and prices each fell by about a quarter, about 9,000 banks failed, and unemployment peaked at about 25 percent in 1933. Deflation raised the real burden of debts. Black Americans were last hired and first fired, the Scottsboro case exposed injustice in the courts, and hundreds of thousands of Mexican Americans, many of them citizens, were pushed to leave. Drought and over-ploughing created the Dust Bowl. Hoover's record included real achievements in Latin American and Native policy, but most historians judge his response to the Depression too limited.
Flashcards
Flashcard
About 24 percent in 1932, peaking at about 25 percent in 1933
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A farm family owes $300 a year. Wheat falls from about $1 to about 40 cents a bushel. How much grain does a payment now take?
Question 2 of 5
Which statement about the Mexican repatriation campaigns is accurate?
Question 3 of 5
Why was the Dust Bowl more than a natural disaster?
Question 4 of 5
What did the Supreme Court decide in Powell v. Alabama (1932)?
Question 5 of 5
Which assessment of Hoover do most historians now accept?
