US History › Section M · Depression and New Deal › Topic M.4
The rise of Franklin Roosevelt
In 1932 a wealthy New York governor who could not walk unaided promised Americans "a new deal" and won a landslide. How Franklin Roosevelt rose, what he did and did not promise, and the grim winter before he took office explain the explosion of action that followed.
From privilege to politics
Franklin Delano Roosevelt was born in 1882 into a wealthy family at Hyde Park, New York, and educated at Groton, Harvard and Columbia Law School. He was a distant cousin of President Theodore Roosevelt, and in 1905 he married Eleanor Roosevelt, Theodore's niece, who would become one of the most influential first ladies in American history. A Democrat, he won a seat in the New York state senate in 1910, served as assistant secretary of the navy from 1913 to 1920, and was the party's vice-presidential candidate in 1920, when the Republicans won easily.
Illness and recovery
In August 1921, aged 39, Roosevelt was struck by a paralysing illness diagnosed as polio. He never again walked without braces and support. He spent years in rehabilitation, founding a treatment centre at Warm Springs, Georgia, and worked hard to hide the extent of his disability; photographers and reporters mostly cooperated. Some medical researchers have since argued that his symptoms fit Guillain-Barré syndrome better, a question that cannot now be settled. Many who knew him believed the struggle deepened his empathy for people facing hardship. Eleanor Roosevelt, meanwhile, became a political force in her own right, keeping his name alive in Democratic circles.
Governor of New York
Roosevelt narrowly won the governorship of New York in 1928 and was re-elected easily in 1930. As the Depression deepened, he acted sooner than most governors. In 1931 he persuaded the legislature to create the Temporary Emergency Relief Administration, the first state agency to give large-scale relief to the jobless, and chose Harry Hopkins, a social worker, to help run it. He also backed unemployment insurance and old-age pensions. In 1932 he gathered a group of university advisers, including Raymond Moley, Rexford Tugwell and Adolf Berle, whom the press called the Brains Trust.
Winning the nomination
Democratic rules then required a two-thirds majority of convention delegates to nominate a candidate. At the party's convention in Chicago in July 1932, Roosevelt led but fell short until the fourth ballot, when supporters of John Nance Garner of Texas switched to him; Garner became the vice-presidential candidate. Breaking with custom, Roosevelt flew to Chicago to accept the nomination in person, the first major-party nominee to do so. There he declared, "I pledge you, I pledge myself, to a new deal for the American people." The party platform called for repealing Prohibition and cutting federal spending.
A campaign of mood more than plans
Roosevelt's campaign offered optimism rather than a detailed programme. In an April 1932 radio address he spoke for "the forgotten man at the bottom of the economic pyramid", and in a May speech he called for "bold, persistent experimentation". Yet he also attacked Hoover for spending too much and promised to balance the budget, so voters heard a mixture of signals. Hoover, worn down and widely blamed, warned that his opponent's ideas would endanger the American system. Most voters were less interested in the details than in the contrast between a gloomy incumbent and a confident challenger.
The 1932 landslide
On 8 November 1932 Roosevelt won about 57 percent of the popular vote to Hoover's roughly 40 percent, and 472 electoral votes to 59, carrying 42 of the 48 states. Democrats also won large majorities in both houses of Congress. The election began the New Deal coalition, a broad alliance of white Southerners, urban immigrants and their children, organised labour, many farmers and, later, Black voters, that would dominate national politics for decades. That coalition took shape between 1932 and 1936: most Black voters who could vote still backed the Republican Hoover in 1932 and moved to Roosevelt in 1936.
Worked example: what did the 1932 vote mean?
Question: was the 1932 result a mandate for the New Deal? 1. Evidence for a programme: Roosevelt promised a new deal and experimentation, and voters gave his party control of Congress. 2. Evidence against: he offered few specifics and even pledged a balanced budget, so voters could not know what the New Deal would contain. 3. Evidence of protest: Hoover's vote collapsed across the country, including farm states that had voted Republican in 1928. 4. Conclusion: the vote was above all a rejection of Hoover and a demand for action. Roosevelt treated it as permission to experiment, and his 1936 landslide later confirmed support for what he had done.
The long interregnum
The interregnum, the gap between the November election and the inauguration, then lasted until 4 March, four months in which Hoover remained president with little authority. Hoover urged Roosevelt to commit publicly to a balanced budget and the gold standard; Roosevelt declined to be bound to Hoover's policies. Meanwhile banks failed in a new panic. In February 1933 Michigan declared a bank holiday, and by inauguration day most states had closed their banks or limited withdrawals. On 15 February, in Miami, Giuseppe Zangara fired at the president-elect. Roosevelt was unhurt, but Chicago's mayor, Anton Cermak, was fatally wounded. Roosevelt's calm impressed the public.
The Twentieth Amendment
The Twentieth Amendment, often called the Lame Duck Amendment, moved the start of a president's term from 4 March to 20 January and that of Congress to 3 January, shortening the interregnum. Senator George Norris of Nebraska had campaigned for the change for years. Congress proposed it in March 1932 and the states ratified it in January 1933, during the very interregnum that showed why it was needed, but too late to apply to Roosevelt's first inauguration; it took effect for the presidency in 1937. So the crisis of 1932-1933 illustrated the problem rather than prompting the amendment.
Worked example: reading the first inaugural address
A source analysis of Roosevelt's address on 4 March 1933. 1. Purpose: with banks closed across the country, he needed to stop panic. 2. Key line: "The only thing we have to fear is fear itself" treated fear as the enemy, echoing the idea that panic had spread bank runs. 3. Promise: he said the nation "asks for action, and action now", signalling speed rather than a fixed plan. 4. Power: he warned that if Congress failed to act he would ask for broad executive power, as great as he would hold if the country were invaded. 5. Conclusion: the speech offered confidence and a wartime sense of emergency, preparing the public for rapid federal action.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming Roosevelt campaigned on a detailed New Deal; his promises were broad and sometimes contradictory. Second, thinking Black voters joined the Democratic coalition in 1932; most switched in 1936. Third, saying the Twentieth Amendment was passed in response to the 1932-1933 crisis; Congress had proposed it in March 1932. Fourth, believing the public knew the extent of his paralysis; he and the press concealed it. Fifth, forgetting the interregnum's banking panic; the system was close to collapse on inauguration day.
Key takeaways
Roosevelt rose from a wealthy family through New York politics, the navy department and a failed 1920 vice-presidential run. Paralysed in 1921, he hid his disability and became governor of New York in 1928, where he created the first large state relief agency in 1931. He won the 1932 nomination on the fourth ballot, pledged a new deal, and beat Hoover with about 57 percent of the vote. During the four-month interregnum banks collapsed, and in March 1933 his inaugural address told Americans that fear itself was the danger.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Democratic president from 1933 to 1945, born in 1882 at Hyde Park, New York
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did Roosevelt create as governor of New York in 1931?
Question 2 of 5
Which statement best describes Roosevelt's 1932 campaign?
Question 3 of 5
Why is it inaccurate to say the Twentieth Amendment was a response to the 1932-1933 interregnum?
Question 4 of 5
How did Black voters' party loyalties change in the Roosevelt years?
Question 5 of 5
What was the main purpose of the line "The only thing we have to fear is fear itself"?
