US History › Section K · Progressives and empire › Topic K.6

The Spanish-American War and overseas empire

In 1898 the United States fought a short war against Spain over Cuba and emerged with an overseas empire stretching from the Caribbean to the western Pacific. Holding the Philippines then required a far longer and deadlier war against Filipinos who wanted independence.

Cuba's fight for independence

Cubans had already fought Spain once, in the Ten Years' War of 1868 to 1878. In 1895 a new revolt began, organised partly from New York by the poet and journalist José Martí, who was killed early in the fighting, and led in the field by Máximo Gómez and Antonio Maceo. Rebels burned sugar estates to wreck the colonial economy. Spain's commander, Valeriano Weyler, answered with reconcentration, forcing rural families into fortified towns where disease and hunger killed an estimated 100,000 or more civilians. Many Americans sympathised with the rebels, and US investors had sizeable stakes in Cuban sugar and mining.

The road to war

New York's rival newspapers, William Randolph Hearst's Journal and Joseph Pulitzer's World, competed with lurid stories of Spanish cruelty, a style called yellow journalism. In February 1898 the Journal published a stolen private letter in which the Spanish minister, Enrique Dupuy de Lôme, insulted President McKinley. Days later, on 15 February, the battleship USS Maine exploded in Havana harbour, killing about 260 sailors. A US naval court blamed a mine, and the press cried "Remember the Maine!" A 1976 study led by Admiral Hyman Rickover concluded that an internal coal-bunker fire was more likely; the cause is still debated. In April Congress authorised force.

Worked example: why did the United States go to war?

1. Humanitarian concern: reconcentration and its civilian deaths outraged many Americans. 2. Public pressure: the yellow press, the de Lôme letter and the Maine made restraint politically costly for McKinley, who had resisted war. 3. Economic interests: investors wanted stability for Cuban sugar, though many business leaders feared war would disrupt recovery from the 1890s depression. 4. Strategy: expansionists such as Roosevelt and Lodge saw a chance to gain bases, as Mahan urged. 5. Limiting factor: the Teller Amendment, attached to the April war resolution, pledged that Cuba would not become a US possession. 6. Conclusion: several causes combined, and historians still weigh how much each mattered.

A war on two oceans

The first blow fell far from Cuba. On 1 May 1898 Commodore George Dewey's squadron destroyed the Spanish fleet in Manila Bay in the Philippines. In Cuba, US troops landed near Santiago in June. On 1 July they took the San Juan Heights; Roosevelt's volunteer Rough Riders charged Kettle Hill alongside the Black regulars of the 9th and 10th Cavalry, whose role newspapers often played down. On 3 July the US Navy destroyed Spain's Caribbean squadron as it fled Santiago harbour. US forces invaded Puerto Rico in late July, and an armistice came on 12 August. Cuban insurgents had fought for years, yet US commanders excluded them from Santiago's surrender.

A short war's real killer

Fewer than 400 American servicemen died in battle, but disease, especially typhoid, yellow fever and malaria, killed at least 2,000 more, many in badly run training camps in the United States. John Hay, then ambassador to Britain, called it "a splendid little war" in a letter to Roosevelt. For Black soldiers the war brought a cruel contrast: they won praise in Cuba, including several Medals of Honor, while facing racist violence in segregated camps in Florida and other Southern states.

The Treaty of Paris and the great debate

Under the Treaty of Paris, signed on 10 December 1898, Spain gave up Cuba and ceded Puerto Rico and Guam to the United States, and ceded the Philippines, for which the United States paid $20 million. The Anti-Imperialist League, founded in 1898, whose members included Mark Twain, Andrew Carnegie, Jane Addams, Samuel Gompers and former President Grover Cleveland, argued that ruling people without their consent betrayed the Declaration of Independence. Some opponents also feared competition from cheap labour or, in racist terms, the inclusion of non-white peoples. Supporters stressed markets, bases and a duty to govern. The Senate ratified the treaty on 6 February 1899, by 57 votes to 27, just one more than the two-thirds needed.

The Philippine-American War

Filipinos had rebelled against Spain in 1896, and in June 1898 Emilio Aguinaldo declared Philippine independence. When it became clear the United States meant to rule, fighting broke out near Manila on 4 February 1899. After early defeats, Filipino forces turned to guerrilla warfare. US troops burned villages, used the "water cure", a form of torture, and in some provinces forced civilians into guarded zones. After Filipino fighters killed about 48 US soldiers at Balangiga in 1901, an American general ordered the island of Samar turned into a "howling wilderness". Aguinaldo was captured in March 1901. Roosevelt declared the war over in July 1902, but resistance continued, especially in the Muslim south, until about 1913.

Worked example: counting the cost in the Philippines

1. American deaths: about 4,200 US soldiers died, most from disease rather than combat. 2. Filipino soldiers: historians commonly estimate around 16,000 to 20,000 killed in battle. 3. Civilians: most estimates of civilian deaths from violence, famine and disease fall around 200,000 to 250,000. 4. Range: some scholars argue for much higher totals, a few as high as a million, while others warn that a cholera epidemic and a cattle plague, spread and worsened by the war, make war deaths hard to separate. 5. Evidence problem: records were incomplete and censuses unreliable. 6. Conclusion: the precise toll is unknowable, but the war killed far more Filipinos than the war with Spain killed Americans.

Ruling the new possessions

In the Insular Cases, beginning in 1901, the Supreme Court ruled that the Constitution did not fully apply in territories such as Puerto Rico, which Congress could govern as it chose. The Foraker Act of 1900 gave Puerto Rico a government with a US-appointed governor; Puerto Ricans became US citizens only in 1917. Guam was run by the navy. In the Philippines, William Howard Taft became civil governor in 1901, building schools and roads while relying on Filipino elites; independence was promised in 1916 and granted in 1946.

Cuba under the Platt Amendment

US troops occupied Cuba until 1902. Before leaving, Washington required Cubans to write the Platt Amendment of 1901 into their constitution. Its terms gave the United States the right to intervene to preserve Cuban independence and order, barred Cuba from treaties that impaired its independence or from debts it could not repay, and provided land for US naval bases, which became the base at Guantánamo Bay. In practice Cuba became a protectorate: US troops returned between 1906 and 1909 and again later. The amendment was repealed in 1934, but the Guantánamo base remains under US control.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming the war began in Cuba; the first major battle was at Manila Bay. Second, stating as fact that Spain sank the Maine; the cause has never been proved. Third, thinking Cuba was annexed; the Teller Amendment ruled that out, though the Platt Amendment made Cuba a protectorate. Fourth, treating the Philippine-American War as a brief mopping-up after 1898, when it lasted years and killed far more people. Fifth, giving casualty figures for that war as exact numbers rather than ranges.

Key takeaways

Cuba's revolt from 1895, Spanish reconcentration, yellow journalism and the Maine explosion drew the United States into war in April 1898. Dewey won at Manila Bay, and US forces, including Black regiments, won around Santiago; disease killed far more Americans than battle. The Treaty of Paris gave the United States Puerto Rico, Guam and the Philippines, despite anti-imperialist opposition. The Philippine-American War, from 1899, killed about 4,200 Americans and, by most estimates, hundreds of thousands of Filipinos. The Insular Cases and the Platt Amendment defined a new kind of colonial rule.

Flashcards

Flashcard

José Martí

Cuban writer who helped organise the 1895 independence revolt

Killed early in the war.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Where was the first major battle of the Spanish-American War fought?

Question 2 of 5

What do historians now say about the cause of the explosion of the USS Maine?

Question 3 of 5

What was the main argument of the Anti-Imperialist League against keeping the Philippines?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement about deaths in the Philippine-American War reflects current scholarship?

Question 5 of 5

How did the Platt Amendment shape Cuba's independence?

← Previous topicNext topic →