US History › Section D · Building a republic › Topic D.1
From monarchy to republic
Breaking with Britain meant more than winning a war: Americans had to decide what kind of government would replace a king. Their answer, a republic resting on the virtue of its citizens, shaped every political argument of the next fifty years.
A government to invent
When the Second Continental Congress declared independence in July 1776, it explained why Americans were leaving the British Empire, but it did not say what should replace the Crown. Almost every colonist had lived under a king, and kings ruled nearly all of Europe. The few states without monarchs, such as Venice, Genoa, the Swiss cantons and the Dutch Republic, were small or in decline. Many European thinkers, following the French writer Montesquieu, believed a republic could survive only in a small territory. Choosing a republic for thirteen states spread along a long coastline was therefore a bold experiment, and many observers expected it to fail.
Monarchy and its American critics
A monarchy is government headed by a single ruler whose office passes by dynastic succession, usually to a child or other close relative. Its defenders described the king as a father who protected his subjects, and Britons praised their own system for balancing Crown, Lords and Commons. By the mid-1770s, however, many Patriots believed George III had abandoned that duty by backing Parliament's taxes and sending troops against his own subjects. Thomas Paine's pamphlet Common Sense, published in January 1776 and discussed in the topic on independence, went further. It attacked not one bad king but hereditary monarchy itself, and urged Americans to build a republic.
What a republic meant
A republic is a government without a hereditary ruler, in which authority comes from the people and is exercised by representatives they choose. The word comes from the Latin res publica, "the public thing": government was meant to serve the common good, not a ruling family. Revolutionaries looked to the Roman Republic, which had expelled its kings and governed through elected magistrates and a senate. They borrowed its language and imagery. Political essayists signed themselves with Roman names such as Brutus and Publius, and in the early 1790s an Italian sculptor, Giuseppe Ceracchi, portrayed Washington as a Roman statesman.
A republic is not a democracy
To the revolutionary generation, a republic also stood apart from democracy, a system in which the majority of citizens make decisions binding on everyone. Many wealthy merchants, landowners and planters equated democracy with disorder. They feared a poor majority might vote to cancel debts or seize property, overriding the rights of a minority. Historians often call those who wanted government by a small, educated elite conservative Whigs, and those who wanted wider popular participation radical Whigs. After independence the central question became who should rule at home. Few on either side imagined women, enslaved people or Native Americans as full members of the political community.
Virtue: what a republic runs on
Republican theory held that a republic survives only while its citizens are virtuous. Virtue here meant civic virtue: the willingness to place the public good above private gain. Corruption, through luxury, self-interest or dependence on powerful patrons, was believed to have destroyed Rome and could destroy America too. Leaders therefore stressed education, simplicity and self-discipline. Benjamin Franklin's list of thirteen personal virtues, among them temperance, frugality and industry, which he drew up as a young man and described in his autobiography, was read by later generations as a model of the disciplined republican citizen.
Property and political rights
How could a republic tell who was virtuous enough to vote? Most leaders answered: look at property. A man who owned land or paid taxes had a stake in society and was independent, so an employer or landlord could not easily dictate his vote. Men without property were thought to be dependent, and so were wives, servants and enslaved people. Most states therefore kept property or taxpaying qualifications. This bias towards the elite reflected colonial habits of deference, in which ordinary people were expected to follow the lead of the wealthy and well born.
Worked example: why a republic?
Explain why Americans chose a republic rather than a new king. 1. Experience: colonists had elected their own assemblies for generations, beginning with Virginia's House of Burgesses in 1619, so self-government was familiar. 2. Grievance: blaming George III for tyranny discredited monarchy itself, not just one ruler. 3. Ideas: Roman history and English opposition writers taught that power and corruption constantly threatened liberty. 4. Practicality: America had no royal family or titled nobility from which to draw a king. 5. Persuasion: Paine's Common Sense turned these strands into a popular argument. 6. Check: a few leaders, Alexander Hamilton among them, still admired Britain's mixed government in 1787, so enthusiasm for a pure republic was not universal.
Worked example: Washington as Cincinnatus
Read one act as evidence of republican values. 1. The event: in December 1783, George Washington returned his commission to Congress, then meeting in Annapolis, and went home to Mount Vernon. 2. The model: the Roman Cincinnatus was given emergency power, saved the republic and then returned to his farm. 3. The meaning: surrendering power voluntarily showed civic virtue and placed the army under civilian rule, when history offered victorious generals, Oliver Cromwell among them, who had seized power instead. 4. The complication: Washington's leisure for public service rested on wealth produced by people he enslaved. 5. The conclusion: the gesture shows both the ideal of virtue and its narrow social base.
The Society of the Cincinnati
Officers of the Continental Army founded the Society of the Cincinnati in 1783, with Washington as its first president general. French officers who had served in the war could join, but ordinary soldiers and militiamen could not. Membership passed to each member's eldest son, following the rule of primogeniture. Critics warned that a hereditary order of military men looked like the start of an American nobility, exactly what a republic was supposed to prevent. Washington urged the society to drop hereditary membership in 1784, but the change was never fully adopted. The dispute shows how aristocratic and democratic ideas competed inside republicanism.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, calling the newly independent nation a democracy: its founders built a republic, and many of them distrusted majority rule. Second, assuming the Declaration of Independence set up a government: it announced and justified separation, and left the design of government to later debates. Third, reading civic virtue as purely private good behaviour: it meant putting the public good first. Fourth, treating property qualifications as simple greed: leaders tied them to the idea of independence, even though the result excluded most adults. Fifth, confusing this republicanism with the later Republican Party, founded in the 1850s.
Key takeaways
Independence forced Americans to replace monarchy, a system of dynastic succession, with something new. Experience of elected assemblies, distrust of George III and Paine's attack on hereditary rule made a republic the natural choice. A republic placed authority in the people and their chosen representatives, on the Roman model, but most leaders saw it as a safeguard against democracy and majority rule. Republics were thought to depend on civic virtue, and property was used to measure who was independent enough to vote. Washington's resignation in 1783 embodied the ideal, while the hereditary Society of the Cincinnati showed its aristocratic side.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Government by a single ruler whose office passes by dynastic succession
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
How did most revolutionary leaders distinguish a republic from a democracy?
Question 2 of 5
Why did most states tie the right to vote to owning property or paying taxes?
Question 3 of 5
Which factor helped make a republic a practical choice for Americans after 1776?
Question 4 of 5
Why did Americans compare George Washington to the Roman leader Cincinnatus?
Question 5 of 5
Why did critics object to the Society of the Cincinnati?
