US History › Section E · Industry and Jacksonian democracy › Topic E.5

The Nullification Crisis and the Bank War

In Jackson's presidency two fights tested the reach of federal power. South Carolina claimed the right to cancel a federal tariff, and Jackson made war on the national bank. Both shaped American politics until the Civil War.

Two tests of federal power

Jackson promised limited government, yet used presidential power forcefully. In the Nullification Crisis of 1832 and 1833, he defended federal authority against a state that tried to void a national law. In the Bank War, he used the veto and his control of the Treasury to destroy a federally chartered bank. The fights look opposite, but both rested on Jackson's belief that the president spoke for the majority.

The Tariff of Abominations

Protective tariffs raised the price of imported manufactured goods so that American factories could compete. The Tariff of 1828 pushed rates very high, including on raw materials. Many historians argue that Jackson's allies in Congress shaped it to win votes in the middle and western states for the coming election, expecting New England to reject it; instead it passed, and President Adams signed it. Southern planters, who sold cotton abroad and bought imported goods, called it the Tariff of Abominations. In South Carolina, falling cotton prices, worn-out soils and fear for slavery in a state with a Black majority made the anger especially intense.

Calhoun's theory of nullification

Vice President John C. Calhoun answered in the South Carolina Exposition and Protest, written anonymously in 1828. He argued that the Union was a compact among sovereign states, so each state could judge whether a federal law exceeded the Constitution. A state convention could declare such a law null and void within its borders, and only a constitutional amendment approved by three-quarters of the states could override it. Calhoun drew on the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions of 1798, but James Madison, who had written the Virginia text, rejected nullification. Calhoun saw it as protection for a minority; critics saw a recipe for disunion.

Liberty and union

The argument went national in January 1830, when Senator Robert Hayne of South Carolina debated Senator Daniel Webster of Massachusetts. Hayne defended states' rights; Webster replied that the Constitution came from the people, not the states, and ended with a famous line: "Liberty and Union, now and for ever, one and inseparable!" In April 1830, at a dinner honouring Jefferson's birthday, Jackson offered a toast usually printed as "Our Federal Union: it must be preserved." Calhoun's reply put liberty ahead of union. President and vice president now stood openly on opposite sides.

Showdown, 1832 to 1833

A new Tariff of 1832 lowered some rates but kept protection. In November 1832 a South Carolina convention passed the Ordinance of Nullification, declaring the tariffs of 1828 and 1832 void in the state from February 1833, and threatening secession if force was used. In December, Jackson's Nullification Proclamation answered that no state could annul a federal law and that disunion by armed force was treason. Calhoun resigned as vice president to defend his state in the Senate. In March 1833 Congress passed two laws together: a Force Bill allowing the president to use the army to collect duties, and Henry Clay's Compromise Tariff, which cut rates gradually over about ten years.

The Second Bank and its enemies

The Second Bank of the United States, chartered in 1816 for twenty years, held federal deposits, issued widely trusted notes and restrained state banks by returning their notes for gold and silver. Under Nicholas Biddle it was well run, but it was a private corporation with enormous power, wealthy and partly foreign shareholders, and no accountability to voters. Jackson distrusted paper money and banks, partly because of debts from his own land deals, and believed the Bank was unconstitutional despite the Supreme Court's ruling in McCulloch v. Maryland. State bankers and western debtors resented its discipline.

The veto of 1832

The Bank's charter ran until 1836, but Henry Clay and Daniel Webster urged Biddle to seek renewal early, in 1832, so that a veto would hurt Jackson in that year's election. Congress passed the recharter bill, and on 10 July 1832 Jackson vetoed it. His message argued that the Bank was unconstitutional, a monopoly that enriched a privileged few, and too open to foreign influence; it also claimed that the president could judge constitutionality for himself. The plan backfired on Clay. Jackson won the 1832 election easily, taking 219 electoral votes to Clay's 49, and treated the result as a popular mandate against the Bank.

Worked example: reading the veto message

Analyse one sentence from Jackson's veto: "It is to be regretted that the rich and powerful too often bend the acts of government to their selfish purposes." 1. Author and date: the president, July 1832, a few months before the election. 2. Audience: Congress formally, but really the voting public, since the message was widely reprinted. 3. Argument: the Bank is a case of government favouring the wealthy over farmers, mechanics and labourers. 4. Purpose: to cast the election as the people against privilege. 5. Limits: the message says little about the Bank's useful role in steadying the currency. Check: the source shows Jackson's political strategy as clearly as his economic views.

Removing the deposits

Jackson then moved to kill the Bank before its charter ended. In 1833 he ordered federal money withdrawn from it and placed in selected state banks, which critics called pet banks. Two Treasury secretaries balked; Jackson moved one to another post and fired the next, then appointed Roger Taney, who carried out the order. Biddle retaliated by calling in loans, causing a short recession. In 1834 the Senate censured Jackson, though it later expunged the censure. His opponents, calling him "King Andrew the First", united as the Whigs, named after the British party that had opposed royal power. The Bank's federal charter expired in 1836.

Worked example: the road to the Panic of 1837

Trace the chain of causes. 1. Freed from the national bank's restraint, pet banks and other state banks issued more paper money and loans. 2. Easy credit fed a speculative boom in western land, and federal land sales soared. 3. To curb speculation, Jackson's Specie Circular of July 1836 required gold or silver for most public land purchases, drawing specie westward. 4. At the same time, the Bank of England tightened credit and cotton prices fell. 5. In May 1837 New York banks stopped paying out specie, and a long depression followed under the new president, Martin Van Buren. Check: historians still debate whether Jackson's policies or international forces mattered more.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, Jackson was not a nullifier: though a southern slaveholder who favoured limited government, he denied that any state could cancel federal law. Second, the 1828 tariff was not simply Adams's plan; congressional Jacksonians shaped it, and Adams signed it. Third, the crisis ended with both a compromise tariff and the Force Bill, not with one side's total surrender; South Carolina repealed its ordinance, then defiantly nullified the Force Bill. Fourth, the Bank was not a government agency but a private corporation with a federal charter. Fifth, the Panic of 1837 had international causes as well as Jackson's policies.

Key takeaways

The Tariff of 1828 provoked Calhoun's theory of nullification. South Carolina acted on it in 1832, Jackson declared it illegal, and the Force Bill and Clay's Compromise Tariff settled the crisis in 1833, leaving states' rights arguments alive. Jackson vetoed the Bank's recharter, framed the fight as the people against privilege, won re-election and moved federal deposits to pet banks. Opposition to his use of power created the Whigs. Easy credit, the Specie Circular and international shocks led to the Panic of 1837.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Protective tariff

A tax on imports meant to shield domestic manufacturers from competition

Raised prices for southern buyers of manufactured goods.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

According to Calhoun's theory of nullification, what could a state do with a federal law it judged unconstitutional?

Question 2 of 5

How was the Nullification Crisis brought to an end in 1833?

Question 3 of 5

Which argument appeared in Jackson's 1832 message vetoing the Second Bank's recharter?

Question 4 of 5

What did the Specie Circular of 1836 require?

Question 5 of 5

Why did Jackson's opponents call their new party the Whigs?

← Previous topicNext topic →