US History › Section K · Progressives and empire › Topic K.4

Progressivism in the White House

Between 1901 and 1916, three presidents carried reform from cities and states to the national government. Theodore Roosevelt, William Howard Taft and Woodrow Wilson disagreed about how to tame big business, but together they built the regulatory state Americans still live with.

A president by accident

In September 1901 an anarchist shot President William McKinley in Buffalo, New York, and he died eight days later. Theodore Roosevelt, aged 42, became the youngest president ever. Roosevelt believed the president was a steward of the people, free to do anything the Constitution and laws did not forbid, and he used the office as a "bully pulpit", his own phrase for a platform to rally public opinion. That view of presidential power changed the office for the twentieth century.

Roosevelt and the trusts

Roosevelt revived the little-used Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890. In 1902 his Justice Department sued the Northern Securities Company, a holding company formed by J. P. Morgan, James J. Hill and E. H. Harriman to control rival Northwestern railways; in 1904 the Supreme Court ordered it dissolved by a vote of 5 to 4. Roosevelt also created a Bureau of Corporations in 1903 to investigate business. Yet he did not oppose size as such. He distinguished "good trusts", which he thought served consumers efficiently, from "bad trusts" that abused their power, and he preferred regulation to break-up.

Worked example: two strikes, two responses

1. Pullman, 1894: President Cleveland sent federal troops to break a railway strike, and the union's leaders were jailed. 2. Anthracite coal, 1902: about 150,000 Pennsylvania miners struck for higher pay and shorter hours, and coal prices soared as winter approached. 3. Roosevelt's move: he invited both union and owners to the White House and, when the owners refused to bargain, let it be known he might have the army run the mines. 4. Outcome: the owners accepted a commission, which in 1903 granted a 10 percent pay rise and a nine-hour day, though not union recognition. 5. Conclusion: the government acted as a broker, not simply as the owners' ally.

The Square Deal: food, drugs and railways

Winning a full term in 1904, Roosevelt offered Americans what he called a "Square Deal". Upton Sinclair's novel The Jungle, published as a book in 1906, described filthy Chicago meatpacking plants; Roosevelt's own investigators confirmed much of it. In 1906 Congress passed the Meat Inspection Act, providing federal inspection of meat shipped across state lines, and the Pure Food and Drug Act, banning adulterated and falsely labelled food and medicines. Sinclair, a socialist, had wanted sympathy for the workers; he said he had aimed at the public's heart and hit its stomach. On railways, the Elkins Act of 1903 banned rebates, and the Hepburn Act of 1906 let the Interstate Commerce Commission set maximum rates.

Conservation and its limits

Roosevelt placed about 230 million acres under federal protection as national forests, parks, bird reserves and monuments. The Newlands Act of 1902 funded irrigation dams in the West, and the Antiquities Act of 1906 let presidents protect sites such as Devils Tower and the Grand Canyon. Roosevelt and his forester Gifford Pinchot favoured conservation, the managed use of resources for future generations, while John Muir argued for preservation of wilderness untouched. Protection had costs: many reserves were carved from lands Native nations had used for hunting and gathering. Roosevelt's record on race was also poor; after a shooting in Brownsville, Texas, in 1906, he discharged 167 Black soldiers without trial, a decision the Army reversed only in 1972.

Taft: more suits, fewer friends

Roosevelt chose William Howard Taft as his successor, and Taft won in 1908. Taft brought roughly twice as many antitrust suits as Roosevelt; in 1911 the Supreme Court broke up Standard Oil and American Tobacco. The Mann-Elkins Act of 1910 extended railway regulation to telephones and telegraphs, and Congress sent the states the Sixteenth Amendment, permitting a federal income tax, ratified in 1913. But Taft angered reformers. He signed the Payne-Aldrich Tariff of 1909, which kept most rates high, and in 1910 fired Pinchot after Pinchot publicly attacked Interior Secretary Richard Ballinger's handling of public lands. A 1911 suit against US Steel completed the break with Roosevelt.

The election of 1912

Roosevelt challenged Taft for the Republican nomination in 1912, but party leaders kept control of the convention. His supporters formed the Progressive, or Bull Moose, Party, and he survived being shot in Milwaukee during the campaign. He ran on the New Nationalism: a strong federal government that would regulate big business and provide social protections. The Democrat Woodrow Wilson, governor of New Jersey, offered the New Freedom, shaped by the lawyer Louis Brandeis: break up monopolies and restore competition rather than manage giant firms. Eugene Debs ran for the Socialists, offering voters a more radical alternative.

Worked example: reading the 1912 results

1. Data: Wilson won about 42 percent of the popular vote, Roosevelt about 27, Taft about 23 and Debs about 6. 2. Electoral college: Wilson took 435 electoral votes, Roosevelt 88 and Taft 8. 3. Cause: the Republican split divided a majority of voters, so Wilson won easily without a majority. 4. Pattern: Roosevelt finished ahead of Taft, and his share remains the highest won by a third-party candidate. 5. Interpretation: adding the Wilson, Roosevelt and Debs totals, about three-quarters of voters chose a candidate promising substantial change. 6. Conclusion: 1912 was a national endorsement of reform, even though the reformers disagreed about its form.

Wilson's New Freedom in action

The Underwood Tariff of 1913 cut average rates sharply and introduced a graduated income tax under the new amendment, from 1 percent up to 7 percent on the highest incomes. The Federal Reserve Act of 1913 created twelve regional reserve banks under a central board, giving the country a more flexible currency and a lender to banks in crises. In 1914 the Federal Trade Commission was set up to police unfair business practices, and the Clayton Act strengthened antitrust law. Before the 1916 election, Wilson backed a ban on interstate trade in goods made by children, an eight-hour day for railway workers and farm loans, and named Brandeis the first Jewish Supreme Court justice.

Progress for whom?

Wilson's reforms did not extend to Black Americans. A Southerner by birth, he allowed members of his cabinet to segregate offices, washrooms and dining areas in federal departments from 1913, and many Black civil servants were demoted or dismissed. The child labour law of 1916 was struck down by the Supreme Court in 1918, and courts narrowed the Clayton Act's protections for unions. National Progressivism thus left a lasting framework of regulation, income tax and central banking, but its benefits were unevenly shared.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, calling Roosevelt an enemy of all big business; he separated "good" from "bad" trusts and often preferred regulation. Second, assuming Roosevelt brought the most antitrust suits; Taft brought more. Third, mixing up New Nationalism, which accepted big firms under strong federal regulation, with New Freedom, which aimed to restore competition. Fourth, thinking the Pure Food and Drug Act dealt with workers' conditions; it targeted unsafe and mislabelled products. Fifth, treating Progressive presidents as champions of racial equality; Roosevelt's Brownsville discharges and Wilson's segregation show otherwise.

Key takeaways

Roosevelt's stewardship view expanded presidential power: he revived antitrust law, brokered the 1902 coal strike, won food and drug laws and railway regulation, and protected about 230 million acres. Taft brought more antitrust suits but split his party over tariffs and conservation. In 1912 Roosevelt's New Nationalism faced Wilson's New Freedom, and the Republican split elected Wilson. Wilson's administration produced the Underwood Tariff with an income tax, the Federal Reserve, the FTC and the Clayton Act. Reform largely excluded Black Americans, and Wilson segregated federal offices.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Stewardship theory

Roosevelt's view that a president may do anything the Constitution does not forbid

Expanded presidential power.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

How did Roosevelt's handling of the 1902 coal strike differ from Cleveland's response to the Pullman strike?

Question 2 of 5

What did the Pure Food and Drug Act of 1906 do?

Question 3 of 5

Which statement correctly compares New Nationalism and New Freedom?

Question 4 of 5

Why did Wilson win the 1912 election with only about 42 percent of the popular vote?

Question 5 of 5

Which shows the limits of Progressive reform under Wilson?

← Previous topicNext topic →