US History › Section K · Progressives and empire › Topic K.5

The roots of American empire

In the 1890s the United States began reaching beyond its continental borders for markets, naval bases and influence. The motives were economic, strategic and ideological at once, and the people of places such as Hawaii paid the price of decisions made in Washington.

From continent to ocean

For most of the nineteenth century, American expansion meant pushing west across North America, at the expense of Native nations and Mexico. After the Civil War, Reconstruction and western settlement absorbed most national attention, and the army and navy shrank. By the 1890s that was changing. After the 1890 count, the census superintendent reported that a continuous line of frontier settlement no longer existed. Industry was producing more than Americans could buy, and the depression that began in 1893 made overseas markets look urgent. A new generation of leaders wanted the country to act as a great power.

Early steps under Seward

William Seward, secretary of state from 1861 to 1869, imagined an American commercial empire in the Pacific. In 1867 he bought Alaska from Russia for $7.2 million, adding about 586,000 square miles, and the navy took possession of the Midway Islands the same year. Critics mocked Alaska as a frozen waste, though gold strikes in the region in the 1890s later changed many minds. The Tlingit, Aleut, Yup'ik and other Alaska Native peoples were not consulted. Congress stayed cautious: in 1870 the Senate rejected President Grant's treaty to annex the Dominican Republic.

The search for markets

Economic change drove much of the new interest abroad. American factories and farms produced huge surpluses, and by the late 1890s the value of US exports exceeded $1 billion a year. Business leaders feared that the domestic market was saturated, a fear sharpened by the depressions of the 1870s and 1890s, when unsold goods, falling prices and unemployment fed strikes and unrest. Many concluded that steady growth required foreign customers, especially in Latin America and Asia. Historians since the 1950s, notably William Appleman Williams, have argued that this search for markets, more than a desire for colonies, was the core of American expansion.

Missionaries, race and mission

Protestant missionary societies sent thousands of Americans, a majority of them women, to China, India, the Middle East and the Pacific, where they ran schools and clinics as well as churches. The minister Josiah Strong's Our Country (1885) argued that Anglo-Saxon Protestants were destined to spread their faith and institutions across the world. Social Darwinists applied a distorted reading of evolution to nations, claiming that stronger races were meant to rule weaker ones. In 1899 the British poet Rudyard Kipling urged Americans to take up "the White Man's Burden" in the Philippines. Such thinking combined genuine humanitarian concern with assumptions of racial superiority.

Turner's frontier thesis

In 1893 the young historian Frederick Jackson Turner presented a paper in Chicago, citing the census report, during the World's Columbian Exposition, arguing that the frontier had shaped American democracy, individualism and energy. With the frontier gone, he suggested, the country faced a turning point, and later writings pointed to overseas expansion as a new outlet for that energy. Later historians, especially the New Western historians of the 1980s such as Patricia Nelson Limerick, criticised it for treating the West as empty land and ignoring conquest, Native nations, Mexican Americans and women. Today it is read mainly as evidence of how Americans of the 1890s understood themselves.

Mahan and the new navy

Alfred Thayer Mahan, a naval officer, gave expansion a strategy. His book The Influence of Sea Power upon History, 1660-1783 (1890) argued that great nations had always relied on strong navies and overseas trade. He urged three steps: build a modern battle fleet, acquire coaling stations and bases around the world, and dig a canal across Central America. Theodore Roosevelt and Senator Henry Cabot Lodge were admirers. The Naval Act of 1890 authorised three modern battleships, and steady building followed. By about 1900 the United States had moved from a minor naval power to one of the world's larger fleets, made of steel ships.

Worked example: Mahan's chain of reasoning

1. Premise: national wealth depends on foreign trade carried by sea. 2. Protection: trade in wartime needs a navy strong enough to defeat rivals. 3. Technology: steam-powered warships burned coal quickly and could sail only a limited distance before refuelling. 4. Requirement: a fleet operating far from home therefore needed coaling stations and bases spread across the oceans. 5. Geography: moving the fleet between the Atlantic and Pacific meant a long voyage around South America, so a Central American canal was essential. 6. Conclusion: Mahan's logic made Pacific and Caribbean islands, and a canal route, strategic prizes.

Pressing claims in the hemisphere and the Pacific

Secretary of State James G. Blaine hosted the first Pan-American Conference in 1889 and 1890 to expand trade with Latin America. In 1895, during a boundary dispute between Venezuela and British Guiana, Secretary of State Richard Olney told Britain that the United States was "practically sovereign on this continent", and Britain accepted arbitration. In the South Pacific, the United States had obtained rights to a naval station at Pago Pago in Samoa in 1878. After rivalry with Germany and Britain, an 1889 agreement set up joint oversight, and in 1899 the islands were divided: Germany took the western islands and the United States the eastern ones, now American Samoa.

Hawaii: sugar and a coup

American missionaries' descendants and planters had built a sugar economy in the Kingdom of Hawaii, with tariff-free access to the US market under an 1875 treaty and US rights to Pearl Harbor from 1887. That year, planters forced King Kalākaua to accept the "Bayonet Constitution", which limited royal power and gave wealthy foreigners the vote. The McKinley Tariff of 1890 removed Hawaii's sugar advantage, and planters began seeking annexation. When Queen Liliʻuokalani moved to restore royal authority in January 1893, a group of planters and businessmen overthrew her, backed by US Marines landed on the order of the American minister, John Stevens.

Worked example: weighing the annexation of Hawaii

1. Planters' view: annexation would secure their sugar profits and political control. 2. Native Hawaiian view: in 1897 more than 21,000 people signed petitions opposing annexation, a majority of the Native Hawaiian population at the time. 3. Washington's first response: President Cleveland withdrew the annexation treaty and, after an investigation, judged the overthrow wrong, so the planters declared a Republic of Hawaii in 1894. 4. Strategic view: during the war with Spain in 1898, Pearl Harbor's value as a mid-Pacific base became decisive. 5. Outcome: Congress annexed Hawaii by a joint resolution, the Newlands Resolution, in July 1898, avoiding the two-thirds Senate vote a treaty needed. 6. Epilogue: in 1993 Congress formally apologised for the US role in the overthrow.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking empire began suddenly in 1898; Alaska, Midway, Samoa and Hawaii show earlier steps. Second, reducing expansion to one motive, when markets, naval strategy, missionary zeal and racial ideas worked together. Third, treating Turner's frontier thesis as settled fact rather than an influential, now heavily criticised interpretation. Fourth, saying Hawaii was annexed by treaty; supporters lacked a two-thirds Senate majority and used a joint resolution. Fifth, overlooking Native Hawaiian resistance, which included mass petitions against annexation.

Key takeaways

After 1865 the United States took modest steps, such as buying Alaska in 1867. By the 1890s surplus production, depression, the closing of the frontier, missionary zeal and racial ideas pushed leaders to look abroad. Turner's frontier thesis and Mahan's case for sea power, bases and a canal shaped their thinking, and a modern steel navy followed. The United States asserted itself in the Venezuela crisis and in Samoa. In Hawaii, planters overthrew Queen Liliʻuokalani in 1893 with help from US Marines, and despite Native Hawaiian petitions Congress annexed the islands in 1898.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Alaska purchase, 1867

Seward bought Alaska from Russia for $7.2 million

Alaska Native peoples were not consulted.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did Mahan's ideas make Pacific islands strategically valuable?

Question 2 of 5

How did Frederick Jackson Turner's frontier thesis connect to overseas expansion?

Question 3 of 5

What triggered the overthrow of Queen Liliʻuokalani in 1893?

Question 4 of 5

Why was Hawaii annexed by joint resolution rather than by treaty?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement best reflects the economic argument for expansion in the 1890s?

← Previous topicNext topic →