World History › Section S · Latin American independence › Topic S.1

Revolution for whom?

Between 1808 and 1825 most of Spain's American empire broke away. But colonial society was deeply divided by birth, colour and wealth, so independence meant very different things to a creole landowner, an Andean villager, an enslaved worker and a free artisan of mixed descent.

Many revolutions in one

When historians ask "revolution for whom?", they are pointing to a problem at the heart of Latin American independence. The leaders who demanded self-government were mostly wealthy men of European descent, yet they lived among Indigenous majorities, enslaved Africans and large mixed populations, each with grievances of its own. Some of these groups joined the patriots; many fought for the king, who could look like a protector against local elites. This topic examines the society, reforms and European crisis that set the stage for the wars that followed.

A society ranked by birth

At the top of Spanish American society stood the peninsulares, Spaniards born in Europe, who held most senior posts in government and church. Just below were creoles (criollos), people of Spanish descent born in the Americas, who often owned the mines, estates and trading houses. Indigenous people formed the majority in regions such as the Andes and central Mexico and owed tribute and labour. Enslaved Africans and their descendants were concentrated on plantations and in ports. A large and growing population of mixed descent, the castas, included mestizos, of Spanish and Indigenous ancestry, and pardos, of partly African ancestry. In Portuguese America, European-born Portuguese were called reinóis.

Casta paintings and real life

In the eighteenth century, artists in New Spain produced casta paintings: series of panels showing a father and mother of different origins with their child, each labelled with a category such as mestizo or castizo. They reveal an elite anxiety to name and rank every mixture. Historians caution, however, that everyday life was more fluid. A person's recorded category could change with wealth, occupation, marriage or the judgement of a parish priest, and people argued about their own status in court. Colour mattered greatly, but it was one marker among several, alongside honour, legitimacy of birth, religion and money.

The Bourbon reforms

The Bourbon dynasty, which took Spain's throne in 1700, set out to make the empire more profitable and easier to control, especially under Charles III, who reigned from 1759 to 1788. New viceroyalties were created: New Granada, made permanent in 1739, and Río de la Plata in 1776. Salaried officials called intendants, nearly all peninsulares, took over local tax collection, and fewer creoles were appointed to high courts. The Crown raised sales taxes, enforced monopolies on tobacco and spirits, and opened trade between more ports within the empire. In 1767 it expelled the Jesuits, who had educated many creole sons. The historian John Lynch called the reforms a second conquest of America.

Worked example: why the reforms angered creoles

Trace the chain from policy to grievance. 1. The aim: Madrid wanted more revenue and firmer control after costly wars with Britain. 2. The method: it sent European-born officials to run local government and courts. 3. The effect on creoles: posts that wealthy American families had won over generations now went to newcomers, so wealth no longer brought matching office or honour. 4. The economic effect: higher taxes and monopolies squeezed merchants and producers. 5. The cultural effect: the expulsion of the Jesuits removed teachers and exiled many American-born priests. 6. Conclusion: the reforms strengthened the Crown in the short run but taught creoles to see themselves as Americans governed by outsiders.

Revolts from below

Burdens fell hardest on the poor, and some rose in revolt. In 1780 José Gabriel Condorcanqui, a kuraka, or hereditary Indigenous leader, of mixed descent near Cuzco, took the name Túpac Amaru II, claiming descent from the last Inca ruler. He denounced forced labour and the forced sale of goods by local officials, and tens of thousands followed him. As the violence turned against white people in general, creoles sided with Spanish forces; he was executed in Cuzco in 1781, and the wider rebellions cost many lives. In 1781 the Comunero revolt in New Granada, against higher taxes and monopolies, won promises that officials later broke, and some of its leaders were executed.

Worked example: the Caracas protest

Read an elite reaction as evidence. 1. The law: in 1795 the Crown published fees by which people of partly African descent could buy a royal dispensation that removed the legal disadvantages of their birth, opening doors to office and university. 2. The protest: the creole city council of Caracas objected that raising pardos would destroy the social order. 3. Motives: fear of losing status and posts, and alarm at the revolution in Saint-Domingue that had begun in 1791. 4. What it reveals: these creoles wanted more power from Spain but no equality with those below them. 5. Conclusion: the same men who would soon demand rights from Madrid wished to deny them at home.

The crisis of 1808

European war broke the empire open. Allied with Napoleon, Spain lost much of its fleet at Trafalgar in 1805, and British forces attacked Buenos Aires in 1806 and 1807 before local militias drove them out, showing both Spain's weakness and colonists' ability to defend themselves. In 1807 French troops crossed Spain to invade Portugal, Britain's ally. In 1808 Charles IV abdicated in favour of his son Ferdinand VII, and Napoleon then forced both to give up the throne at Bayonne and made his brother Joseph king. Spaniards rose against the French, starting in Madrid on 2 May 1808, and the Peninsular War lasted until 1814.

Juntas and sovereignty

With the king a captive, who ruled? In Spain, local councils called juntas claimed to govern in Ferdinand's name. Many Americans argued that sovereignty had returned to the people of each of the king's kingdoms, including theirs, and juntas formed in Quito and La Paz in 1809 and in Caracas, Buenos Aires, Bogotá and Santiago in 1810. Most first swore loyalty to Ferdinand. Older nationalist histories told independence as the triumph of nations long struggling to be free; historians such as Jaime E. Rodríguez O. argue instead that it grew out of the monarchy's collapse in 1808 and quarrels over representation, with many Americans first seeking autonomy, not separation.

Cádiz and the restoration

Spanish resisters summoned a parliament, the Cortes, which met in Cádiz from 1810 with American deputies, though far fewer than their population justified. Its Constitution of 1812 created a constitutional monarchy and protected a free press, and in 1813 the Cortes abolished the Inquisition. It made Indigenous and mestizo men citizens but largely excluded men of African descent, partly so that they would not be counted towards American seats. When Ferdinand VII returned in 1814, he annulled the constitution, restored absolute rule and sent armies to crush the American juntas. Royalists welcomed the order; patriots who had tasted self-government now saw full independence as the only answer.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming all colonists wanted independence: many Indigenous, pardo and enslaved people fought for the king. Second, treating creoles and peninsulares as the same: birthplace divided them. Third, reading casta paintings as an exact record of daily life rather than an elite ideal. Fourth, assuming Túpac Amaru II led a creole independence movement; creoles helped crush him. Fifth, forgetting that the first juntas swore loyalty to Ferdinand VII. Sixth, imagining the Cádiz Constitution gave equal rights to all Americans; it largely excluded people of African descent.

Key takeaways

Spanish America was ranked by birth and colour: peninsulares, creoles, Indigenous people, enslaved Africans and the castas, though real status was more fluid than casta paintings imply. The Bourbon reforms favoured European-born officials and raised taxes, alienating creoles and fuelling the revolts of Túpac Amaru II and the Comuneros. The Caracas protest showed creoles wanted power without equality. Napoleon's seizure of the Spanish throne in 1808 led to juntas, the Cádiz Constitution of 1812 and, after Ferdinand VII's return, wars for full independence.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Peninsulares

Spaniards born in Europe who held most senior posts in Spanish America

Called reinóis in Portuguese America.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What distinguished creoles from peninsulares in Spanish America?

Question 2 of 5

How did the Bourbon reforms help turn creoles against Spanish rule?

Question 3 of 5

Why did many creoles help Spanish forces crush the rebellion of Túpac Amaru II?

Question 4 of 5

What does the Caracas council's protest against the 1795 dispensations reveal?

Question 5 of 5

What political crisis led juntas to form across Spanish America in 1809 and 1810?

← Previous topicNext topic →